On 2/20/2014 6:18 PM, timothy.price wrote:
> I didn't imagine the extent of the problem.
> Like much of our society today, we are charged money for "services" of poor 
> value.
> I don't believe that my work would get this sort of criticism.
>
>> Craig wrote:
>
>> You would think that if a publisher is renting a piece for $10,000
>> revenue a year (or $400,000 for the big popular ones), it shouldn't be
>> too much to ask that they pay a professional copyist to bring it into
>> Finale and correct all the errors.
>
>
> Is there no recourse available to bring charges against a publisher for 
> delivering a bad product with costly mistakes?
> Every other trade or service I know of must conform to standards, especially 
> if specific flaws in their product can be shown.
> A few successful court cases probably would help focus publishers. What else 
> could change the situation?


Who can afford a lawyer to bring such a lawsuit, even should one be 
possible?

There are no laws regarding the accuracy of printed materials -- I've 
noticed more and more typos slipping into books (both paper and ebooks). 
  Without laws governing the accuracy of printed music (or books) any 
such lawsuit would necessarily be a civil lawsuit in which the suing 
party would most likely have to prove financial damages resulted from 
the errors.

It gets even trickier because the publisher can simply pull out the 
ledger showing the many rentals of that same music over the course of 
many years and claim that nobody else had felt the need of a lawsuit and 
thus ask the judge to summarily dismiss the lawsuit.


-- 
David H. Bailey
[email protected]
http://www.davidbaileymusicstudio.com

_______________________________________________
Finale mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale

Reply via email to