In one of my examples, the composition was a major part of that concert and had been announced. It came from a house in Germany and there was no option not to program the piece. So I rewrote all the brass parts between the first and second rehearsals. Our orchestra manager even offered to the publisher that we would fix the entire score -- all parts in exchange for a credit against future rentals. This seems like a no-brainer, the proverbial gift horse. But obviously the quality of the product meant nothing to them as they did not take up our offer. Let me say this is a modern composer who has some name recognition, but this was one of those pieces that had obviously been entered through hyperscribe or something. The composer is a percussionist and the brass parts looked like they should have been played on a mallet instrument with 4 hands. The rhythms were overly complex by a factor of 4. I was able to rewrite it from the ground up using half as many notes and rests and still achieve exactly the same musical effect that the composer tried to accomplish. My guess is that this was the first time that piece had actually been played very well because most orchestras simply don't have the time to either rewrite the parts or else practice them 50 times to overcome the bad notation.
The second example was a piece with gospel choir. By the time we received the music at first rehearsal, the choir had worked on it for several weeks so it was not an option to pull it. The director couldn't understand why the brass played it so badly and wasted 45 minutes of rehearsal on this one piece. I rewrote all the brass parts and he never had to stop again -- not a single time -- in any of the other rehearsals. Again, I reduced the notes and rests by about 50% while still achieving exactly the same musical result that was indicated in the crappy version of the score. There are a lot of simple things. For example, never write a 16th followed by rests when you could write a staccato quarter or staccato 8th note instead. This one had loads of extra pick-up 16ths at a very brisk tempo. Not only is that hard to read, but it throws off the timing and emphasis. I turned those all into grace notes and the musicians played it perfectly the first time. etc. etc. etc. It takes some effort. I think the issue is that there are no professional copyists involved in the process anymore. I don't expect composers to do this properly, but I do expect the publisher to hand it over to a competent copyist to make it right before publishing. On 2/20/2014 3:21 PM, timothy.price wrote: > Craig, you make an excellent point. But as a composer, it is nearly > impossible to be confident that our manuscripts are what > musicians are comfortable with. There is lacking, imo, the interface between > the good composer, and the musicians, when it > comes to the manuscript. > > It would be greatly appreciated by some if we, as composers, were treated as > a partner in a creative process, more than willing > to make adjustments, particularly to scores, as they may be pointed out to us. > > So, who in your orchestras, is responsible for making sure that the > manuscripts are readably clear BEFORE you get the parts > and your are trapped into a schedule to performance? If is is new work, not > only is the composition new, but the manuscripts are > too. It is the musician that has to be pleased, and it is not always > possible for a composers to have their work reviewed by every > instrument player. > > Orchestras, or at least an assigned member of the orchestra, could be of > great service in furthering new music by engaging is the process of notation > of the piece. Just get the manuscript early and notify the composer of > problem areas in time for them to be happily corrected. > > thanks, > > tim > > > > On Feb 20, 2014, at 2:43 PM, Craig Parmerlee wrote: > >> These >> were not bad compositions. And I am certain the composers were >> excellent musicians. But their notation was terrible, > > > _______________________________________________ > Finale mailing list > [email protected] > http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale > > > _______________________________________________ Finale mailing list [email protected] http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale
