I apologize, in general, for whatever. I don't want to add to polemics that disdain and dissuade an inclusive environment. Like Sasha, I barely contribute, to most listservs, for fear of attack and ridicule, and yet I did apparently myself, however, depending on your POV, regarding her remarks directed at Gene Youngblood, which really irked me, and I do not apologize for them. I hope their tone was professional, but if not, then I was wrong. I know I can be a smart ass, but I did have fundamental problems with Sasha's public comments of Gene's remarks, and I make no apology for them.
Elizabeth McMahon On Tue, Mar 31, 2015 at 2:41 PM, chris bravo <[email protected]> wrote: > Saying that a film makes students want to commit suicide isn't a critique, > its an offensive derogatory statement, which is directed not just towards > the filmmaker, but towards her students especially. > > On Tue, Mar 31, 2015, 1:27 PM Dave Tetzlaff <[email protected]> wrote: > >> Chill out, people! >> >> This is a Listserv. People write short posts quickly, and hit 'Send'. >> "Rhetorical excess" comes with the territory as we dash off our thoughts >> w/o reflecting deeply about whether our wording will read to others with >> the meanings they had for us when they popped into our heads. >> >> I took Sasha's OP as meant to advocate for films that have a sort of >> perspective not-yet presented in the thread -- works one perhaps could call >> more 'post-modern' engagements with culture and identity. I took the crack >> about Wavelength as essentially tangential and polemic -- an observation >> that many contemporary students are not much engaged with the aesthetic >> concerns of that work. It's not clear whether Sasha's pique was directed at >> Wavelength specifically or 'mid-century High modernism' in general -- i.e. >> maybe all 'structural film' and/or Brakhage abstractions etc.?? Regardless, >> intentionally or not, her language was destined to stir the pot, make some >> folks feel poked with a stick, and fire off testy replies. >> >> No film is beyond criticism, including observations that whatever it's >> merits for other situations, it's a poor choice for a given programmer or >> teacher's goals in addressing the specific audiences they have at hand. >> Sasha's snark was phrased as too universal: seeming to suggest Wavelength >> is no longer any good to ANY group of "curious, excited young artists". >> But, indeed, I'm sure there ARE groups of "curious, excited young artists" >> without a background in cinema who would find Wavelength alienating, at >> least initially, and it's perfectly valid to pass on that film for an >> introduction to experimental film in favor of something more immediately >> engaging to the group at hand. >> >> As Gene so pungently observed, the problem starts with the absurdity of >> Donal's original query. First, the "3 films" concept makes no sense, since >> experimental films range in length from a few minutes to several hours. (My >> gag 3: Star Spangled to Death, Sleep, The Extravagent Shadows... no >> intermissions or bathroom breaks!) Second, "essential" is just silly and >> off-point. Unlike Hollywood films directed at mass audiences and respecting >> a common set of conventions, experimental works are often very personal, >> and incredibly varied in form and content. Thus, what works are and aren't >> "essential" is not remotely universal, but conditional and contingent on >> "for whom?" and "for what purpose?" Third, this variety and specificity >> means trying to crowd-source a list of '3 essentials' is utter folly, that >> can only lead to unproductive arguments if people play along. >> >> In the thread OP, Donal didn't tell us anything about his own approach to >> "the realm of the moving image" or what kinds of art practices and >> aesthetics the folks attending the workshops will be "coming from". For all >> we know, the attendees could all be middle-aged ceramicists or landscape >> painters. Ultimately, he needs to pick works that speak to him in some way >> he thinks will enable him to use them to engage 'noobs'. So it is with any >> instance of programming films. The work must 'fit' the programmer, the >> audience, and the purpose. >> >> Given the lack of info in the query, responses have (as one would expect) >> presumed teaching or exhibition situations with which the posters are >> familiar: Andy and Gene spoke of their students; Sasha referred to YOUNG >> ARTISTS. But I read the OP as posing an audience of experienced working >> artists who presumably already have some sort of aesthetic perspective, >> rather than the sort of student population that would sign up for a studies >> course in experimental film. >> >> Just as there is no universal "3 essential films", there is more than one >> valid pedagogical approach to introducing noobs to experimental cinema. >> Sometimes you want to ease folks in, showing work that has some familiar >> elements. Meshes is probably the most widely used introduction to >> experimental work, and over the decades so many of its elements have been >> incorporated into pop culture (advertising, music video, etc.), and it's >> subject matter (angst at gender roles and domesticity) is so enduring, that >> it offers a variety of access points. That works. But for some groups being >> introduced to experimental work, what I call 'deep end of the pool >> pedagogy' can work as well or better — tossing the initiates into the >> strangest water possible w/o a life-jacket, then tossing a safety line into >> the trashing if it's not getting anywhere... >> >> Andy and Gene speak of student appreciation of Wavelength, but under what >> conditions? What courses have they taken before? Is Wavelength the FIRST >> screening on the syllabus? Sasha's put-down seemed to me to posit >> Wavelength as a poor choice for point-of-entry, not something not worth >> screening at all, and I totally understand that. When I first taught >> 'experimental' I screened it about half-way through the term, but found the >> 'bang' too minimal for the screening time, and concluded any pedagogical >> purpose I had for showing it was better served by something else. (E.g. I >> kept <-->. A practical issue with Wavelength: depending on the sound system >> and the volume settings, that audio wave CAN be a form of physical torture, >> and we don't all have the kind of control of screening situations we'd >> like.) >> >> Gene overstates, or perhaps just lacks clarity, in his response to Sasha. >> I'd agree that anyone teaching experimental film at the college level >> should be able to present Wavelength in a way that activates student >> "excitement and curiosity." But that's a far cry from saying that film will >> engage those qualities in and of itself for any and all initiates w/o >> proper introduction and framing, and farther still from making a case >> Wavelength is among the best choices for an introduction in any given >> setting. I know Sasha just a little bit from various conferences >> back-in-the-day, and I'm quite confident she could teach Wavelength well if >> someone tssked her to do so. I do understand how Gene would read Sasha's >> off-hand jibe as 'Wavelength is so anachronistic, no one can make any good >> use of it now with young people.' And if that's what she meant to say, and >> seriously so... well, yeah, that would be pretty darn lame. But if we read >> Listserv posts with charity, we might just take her point as '_I_ find a >> lot of newer work more compelling than Wavelength, and so do the students >> who wind up in my classes, so it doesn't work well as an introduction FOR >> US, and i have a lot of choices that works a lot better for our situation.' >> That's not laziness, cowardice, or betrayal. We have no idea how >> challenging Sashs's students find It Wasn't Love, November, or A Little >> Death to be, or in what ways, or how that sets up the rest of her course. I >> don't know any of those pieces myself, and they're certainly not canon, so >> Sasha may have come to them via diligent searching, loyalty to the ongoing >> energy of avant-garde works, and courage in programming beyond the usual >> suspects. >> >> None of us are in a position to judge her harshly for her choices, or for >> her opinion of Wavelength. But she's not in a position to assert Wavelength >> is useless to other teaching situations. And I think both Sasha and Gene >> know that perfectly well (they're both smart and know their stuff), and >> this little kerfuffle would never occur in actual conversation, because >> neither party really meant their words in the way they've been read. >> >> So how about EVERYBODY apologize for anything that may have been taken as >> a personal attack, or an over-reaching universal claim, and we try to make >> something actually USEFUL out of this sorry-ass thread? Sashs's post had >> some vague abbreviated points about why she finds the films she listed to >> be useful introductions, and the posts on Wavelength make moves in a >> similar direction. How 'bout we expand on that? >> >> Thus, suggested discussion topic: >> • Define an at least modestly specific audience of experimental film >> beginners: background (age, experience, culture), interest in the subject, >> ('makers'? 'scholars'? both?) and an at least modestly specific setting >> (semester course? 3-day workshop? single presentation? >> • Tell us what you would show this group as their FIRST experimental film >> viewing experience. TRT not to exceed 60 minutes. (A single major work, a >> program of related shorts - e.g. 'The films of Maya Deren', or a diverse >> program of shorts.) >> • Explain how the choice fits your passions, the group's interests and >> tendencies, and the situation. What pedagogical values you find in the >> work(s) you've chosen. >> >> (I'd start, but i'm already late to an appt.!!) >> _______________________________________________ >> FrameWorks mailing list >> [email protected] >> https://mailman-mail5.webfaction.com/listinfo/frameworks >> > > _______________________________________________ > FrameWorks mailing list > [email protected] > https://mailman-mail5.webfaction.com/listinfo/frameworks > > -- Elizabeth
_______________________________________________ FrameWorks mailing list [email protected] https://mailman-mail5.webfaction.com/listinfo/frameworks
