>> The "issue" is that VirtualBox is not posting diskette media-change
>> status in the BIOS data table.
> the 'issue' is that VirtualBox clearly states
>   'floppy without change-line support'
> int13/15 returns '01h floppy without change-line support
> int13/16 returns '06h change line active or not supported
> but UIDE ignores this, and relies on change line support anyway.

You are WRONG, Tom!!

UIDE has NEVER ignored if a diskette has change-line support!   It
does in fact check the BIOS data table at 0:448h for bit 0 (change
line for diskette A:) or bit 4 (change line for diskette B:).   If
those bits are off, diskette A: or diskette B: will not be cached.

My update to UIDE in adding the /E switch was simply to add a mask
which is 011h without /E, 000h with /E, to "mask" against the bits
at address 0:448h.   This works fine.   With /E, the mask prevents
UIDE from "seeing" any change-line bits, so diskettes go uncached.

But, if what you wrote above is correct, VirtualBox expects people
to use ONLY the "Int 13h" requests, when determining if a diskette
has change-line support.   And in any event, by indicating NO such
support, as you also wrote above, they make it impossible for UIDE
to cache diskettes anyway!   I will NOT cache a drive which cannot
tell me when its media has changed, and I REFUSE to add all of the
logic in UIDE that Eric notes the DOS kernel contains, to find out
if a media-change has occurred using other methods!

So, I shall amend my earlier post to say that VirtualBox now needs
TWO changes:  (A) It needs to provide media-change status for each
diskette, and (B) It needs to provide a PROPER BIOS DATA TABLE, as
the table bits that are "seen" when VirtualBox runs are INCORRECT!

> maybe the real issue is that noone finds the time to do a tiny bit of
> debugging the problem but finds a lot of time to write loooooong
> emails

To which I shall add:  Maybe you might have read the UIDE.ASM file
before making any BASELESS and WRONG accusations about my drivers!

Jack R. Ellis

Live Security Virtual Conference
Exclusive live event will cover all the ways today's security and 
threat landscape has changed and how IT managers can respond. Discussions 
will include endpoint security, mobile security and the latest in malware 
Freedos-user mailing list

Reply via email to