Ian Clarke wrote on 12/23/00 10:04 pm:

> From Wired News, available 
>online at:
>http://www.wired.com/news
>/print/0,1294,40816,00.htm
>l
>
>Oh dear, looks like it is time 
>once again to don my 
>fireman's hat and quench 
>the flames of 
>misinformation and 
>unquestioned self-publicity 
>with the hose of facts and 
>common sense.

Thats one great overextended metaphor there, Ian.  :)

<>
>In the case of broadband 
>connections such as cable, 
>even if you can identify that 
>a particular IP address is 
>running a Freenet node, and 
>even if the ISP can be 
>persuaded to try to remove 
>the user, there is no way for 
>the ISP to tie the IP address 
>to a given user over a cable 
>local loop, and thus no way 
>to deny them access.

I beleive the ISP would have a record of who-had-what-IP-when.

<>
>> "Unlike encryption and 
>digital rights management 
>solutions, you need  
>something to go out and 
>make sure that any leaks 
>out there are stopped  
>because those leaks mean 
>you are losing revenue," said 
>Tim Smith,  president of 
>Copyright.net, the maker of 
>Copyright Agent. "Our  
>software all developed 
>around the DMCA. We've 
>Web-enabled the DMCA."

May you and your stupid law be desroyed in a barrage of a thousand
cluesticks.

<>
>This cannot be achieved with 
>Freenet since the process of 
>checking to see whether 
>content is on a machine will 
>actually place the content on 
>that machine regardless of 
>whether it was there before, 
>so it is *this software* which 
>will cause the propagation of 
>the infringing content - by 
>their reasoning, therefore, 
>it is their own software which 
>should be banned.  We call 
>this the "I'm Sparticus" 
>strategy.

It gets really funny if they run a node, since they
will now possess infringing files :)

Beyond that, I'd like to see it hold up in court.  Maybe Brad here
will be as entertaining as Vilenti :)

<>
>Ah yes, change one bit of the 
>mp3 file and you get a 
>different checksum 
>rendering this mechanism 
>worthless.  That's *really* 
>smart.

Hehe, anyone want to start on the PERL script for this *g*


Timm Murray

-----------
Microsoft:  Re-inventing square wheels

_______________________________________________
Freenet-chat mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://lists.sourceforge.net/mailman/listinfo/freenet-chat

Reply via email to