William, the theory is just valid for 1005 normal circumstances, ideal circumstances. Why do partials shift if the lead pipe is changed in diameter at some section, or if the horns bore is changed when the tube leaves the valve section, some dramatic changes. Why does the overall intonation change very much with different hand positions or more extreme: hand in the bell verse hand out of the bell ?
Theory is good & helpful but "practica" is different, very different. I played professionally for about 50 years on first horn mostly, but on low horn occasionally to help some coplleagues out for a gig. And the written c2 (2nd space) is in tune on most F- & Bb-sides. You even can wiggle on the thumb valve while playing this note, but no change in the notes intonation, required the horn is well built horn of the upper quality class. A horn student has many other problems than to care about the maths regarding intonation. And a horn student has different problems than to care about which muscle to involve in the playing. Too much thinking around is the greatest problem for many players, as they lack the most basic instructions, so things work automatically, bypassing the brain. So the brain ids free & can act as a superb supervisor. That is reality, even the acoustic/math matter is very interesting. +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ Am 19.11.2009 um 17:54 schrieb [email protected]: > I completely completely disagree. > > On every horn I've ever played the 6th partial C on the Bb horn is never in > tune with the F side C. It CANT be. > > The 8th partial is NEVER going to be out of tune. It can't be because the > frequency of a standing wave is determined by LENGTH and never by shape or > curls or whatever in any tubing. > > The acoustic pressure on the other hand DOES change given the shape of the > 'tube'. > > This is fundamental physics. The first harmonic is one standing wave. The > 2nd is two, and so forth. The octave is always based on a ratio of 2:1, > therefore the perfectly tuned harmonics are based on a ratio of 2:1 from the > fundamental. > > If you open up Physics books (which you rail against) you'll find out why. > > For example, the given cents intonation of a given harmonic is the > following: > > 1200 * ( (LN ( Note1/Note2 )) / LN 2 ) > > Where Note 1 is the Hamonic pitch and Note 2 is the nearest equal > temperament pitch. > > If we were never using equal temperament, then we would never have 'flat' > and 'sharp' pitches (but we'd be stuck to keys). However, we are using equal > temperament and these do NOT match the harmonic series: > > Harmonic Series (Fundamental * N Standing Waves) > Equal Temperament (2^(1/12) * n - 1) for all notes n to infinity > > There is an even better lecture on this located at: > _http://www.physics.mcgill.ca/~guymoore/ph224/notes/lecture20.pdf_ > (http://www.physics.mcgill.ca/~guymoore/ph224/notes/lecture20.pdf) > > -William > > > In a message dated 11/19/2009 1:35:27 A.M. Eastern Standard Time, > [email protected] writes: > > The 8th partial on the F-side is in tune mostly as is the 6th on the > Bb-horn. > > _______________________________________________ > post: [email protected] > unsubscribe or set options at > https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/hpizka%40me.com _______________________________________________ post: [email protected] unsubscribe or set options at https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org
