Oh boy, this is how people get into trouble. The "perfect" physics models only work under perfect circumstances. French horns don't respond perfectly according to how the partials mathematically "ought to" line up. I could easily build you a horn that would play your wonderful perfect 8th partial either extremely sharp or extremely flat. No problem. Your choice. What it comes down to, is it's only in tune if it's in tune! You can play your perfect partial just where it should perfectly be, but if you're out of tune with somebody else, well, you're out of tune. Numbers have no value in such a case, only ears. You're gonna have to play the dreaded 6th partial (omg, 2 cents!!) sometime during the gig, so there ought to be a way to play it in tune. Most people never really have the opportunity to play in an ensemble that plays even remotely in tune. Many of the groups I've played in, your only hope was to play loud enough that you couldn't hear everybody else's horrible pitch. If you're capable of hearing when it's in tune using your ears, and you get to play with other people who are also capable of it. Oh baby, now that's living the good life! My 2 cents on tuning, tune the horn nicely at home so it's in tune with itself, all the valve slides set in a good spot. Then, on the gig, play several different notes, or a happy tune or two against the tuning note to make sure you're in the right "area". One note only tunes one note. I like to have the piano player play a chord rather than a single note maybe even a few arpeggios. Easier to get "in the pocket". Heck, don't tune on stage anyway. Take care of that before the audience gets there. I wish I could remember what it was, I used to have a duet book I used with students and the first few pages were slow half notes and whole notes where one player usually held onto one note while the other player slowly moved around different intervals against it. It might have been a trumpet book. It worked like magic though. Once you really hear that sound of a perfect 4th or a major third that "rings", you never forget it. And, yes it will be mathematically correct if it sounds right, but you have to put down your pencil to play the horn anyway so it's easier to just use your ears.
- Steve Mumford William wrote: I completely completely disagree. On every horn I've ever played the 6th partial C on the Bb horn is never in tune with the F side C. It CANT be. The 8th partial is NEVER going to be out of tune. It can't be because the frequency of a standing wave is determined by LENGTH and never by shape or curls or whatever in any tubing. The acoustic pressure on the other hand DOES change given the shape of the 'tube'. This is fundamental physics. The first harmonic is one standing wave. The 2nd is two, and so forth. The octave is always based on a ratio of 2:1, therefore the perfectly tuned harmonics are based on a ratio of 2:1 from the fundamental. If you open up Physics books (which you rail against) you'll find out why. For example, the given cents intonation of a given harmonic is the following: 1200 * ( (LN ( Note1/Note2 )) / LN 2 ) Where Note 1 is the Hamonic pitch and Note 2 is the nearest equal temperament pitch. If we were never using equal temperament, then we would never have 'flat' and 'sharp' pitches (but we'd be stuck to keys). However, we are using equal temperament and these do NOT match the harmonic series: Harmonic Series (Fundamental * N Standing Waves) Equal Temperament (2^(1/12) * n - 1) for all notes n to infinity There is an even better lecture on this located at: _http://www.physics.mcgill.ca/~guymoore/ph224/notes/lecture20.pdf_ (http://www.physics.mcgill.ca/~guymoore/ph224/notes/lecture20.pdf) -William I _______________________________________________ post: [email protected] unsubscribe or set options at https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org
