Not for me. I generally know at all times what partial I'm playing on - and 
 I know which ones are naturally in tune or not - therefore if I know the 
6th is  going to be sharp I can adjust before I even get there and not worry 
about it. I  tune all my horns for the 8th partial to be in tune. 
 
I can never agree that one should ever initially tune a horn on a 6th  
partial. If it's not in tune, it's not 'close enough'. The third space C  is 
_not_ supposed to match on either side of an F/Bb horn - and there  is a very 
good reason why. You can tune the third space C on the F horn to the F  on 
the Bb horn though - and that's a much better way to tune (and you get a  
perfect fourth). That's the trick to tuning both sides of the horn to each  
other. You don't play the same note - you play the same key and get the keys to 
 
match.
 
I've perused some of your blogs and you do have some correct information  
there - but we must all remember that the study of acoustics has thousands of 
 peer-reviewed papers and textbooks out there and it would behoove all of 
us to  be familiar with the math/science behind it.
 
Lest, we will become wrapped up in arguing over subjective terms rather  
than relating them to measurable objective terms.
 
-William



In a message dated 11/19/2009 2:33:58 P.M. Eastern Standard Time,  
[email protected] writes:

So while  in strict terms you are correct to say they are not the same,
in practice  they are close enough, and tuning to the 6th partial if
going to be good  enough for most purposes.


_______________________________________________
post: [email protected]
unsubscribe or set options at 
https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org

Reply via email to