2009/11/19  <[email protected]>:

> If we were never using equal temperament, then we would never have 'flat'
> and 'sharp' pitches (but we'd be stuck to keys). However, we are using equal
>  temperament and these do NOT match the harmonic series:
>
> Harmonic Series (Fundamental * N Standing Waves)
> Equal Temperament (2^(1/12) * n - 1) for all notes n to infinity
>


No, they are not the same. But an equal temperament perfect 5th is
only out from a just intonation 3:2 perfect 5th by a couple of cents.

I've wriiten a fair bit on my blog about tuning
http://jonathanhornthoughts.blogspot.com/2009/05/tuning-your-horn.html
http://jonathanhornthoughts.blogspot.com/2009/05/more-on-tuning.html
http://jonathanhornthoughts.blogspot.com/2009/07/how-flat-is-that-open-e-on-f-side.html
http://jonathanhornthoughts.blogspot.com/2009/07/just-intonation-vs-equal-temperament.html

Pulling out the main tuning slide by 1mm (therefore increasing the
overall tube length by 2mm) affects the pitch on the F side by about a
cent, and affects the Bb side by a bit more than a cent. Most people
(deliberately or unintentionally) can bend the pitch by a good deal
more than that just with the lip!

So while in strict terms you are correct to say they are not the same,
in practice they are close enough, and tuning to the 6th partial if
going to be good enough for most purposes.

And as for dealing in equal temperament, I think you'll find that
tuning in an orchestra is far more complex than merely assuming equal
temperament is in use. Of course, in a piano concerto, the piano can
do nothing apart from equal temperament, but at other times you
shouldn't assume it is in use.

That means the tuning of notes can vary from key to key, so you need
to listen carefully to the tuning and be ready to adjust every note
you play, even though you started out in tune with the oboe's A.

Regards
Jonathan West
_______________________________________________
post: [email protected]
unsubscribe or set options at 
https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org

Reply via email to