> There are a lot of papers on acoustic properties of tubes/cones/etc. and
> the best way to determine a lot of this is with fancy integration using
> multivariable calculus.
>
> Much like a falling body has independent parameters (drop a bullet while
> firing one from a gun and they hit the ground at the same time) - the same
> with  acoustic properties in a pipe.
>
> Now, the frequency of any standing wave is always derived by the length of
> the tube only.

Not true. Look up 'end effects' and their diameter and frequency dependence.

Here's a good web-page on the the acoustics of brass instruments:

http://www.phys.unsw.edu.au/jw/brassacoustics.html

> But what you have to remember is that if a pipe or loop of tubing is
> sitting and not doing anything it has a standing fundamental and a
> harmonic
> series - and it is measurable and does not change. That tube is going to
> have an
>  in tune harmonic series (in tune with itself) and will have 2^n harmonics
> where  they will match equal temperament (due to the octave ratio of 2:1).

When in doubt, do an experiment. If you get the chance to play a conch or
a shofar, you will find that it has a very strange concept of the harmonic
series. It's a while since I played a funnel and hosepipe, but I don't
remember its intonation as being particularly good either.

On the website I linked to, you will see objective (acoustic impedance)
measurements of a trombone, showing that its first harmonic is well out of
tune.

> Where the difference comes in is our ability to match the frequency of our
> lips. Our lips when buzzing create many overtones and extra frequencies
> mixed in  and when we go higher or lower we are missing the harmonic of
> the
> instrument.  Thus, when we buzz as clearly as we can to match the natural
> harmonic we will  get the purest tone we can get.

Look up mode locking. I suspect this might be what you're referring to
when you talk about the inherent in-tuneness of brass instruments.

Mode-locking causes the partials within a given note to be in tune with
each other, but it is certainly not true that individual notes will always
follow the harmonic series perfectly.

Kit

_______________________________________________
post: [email protected]
unsubscribe or set options at 
https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org

Reply via email to