There are a lot of papers on acoustic properties of tubes/cones/etc. and the best way to determine a lot of this is with fancy integration using multivariable calculus. Much like a falling body has independent parameters (drop a bullet while firing one from a gun and they hit the ground at the same time) - the same with acoustic properties in a pipe. Now, the frequency of any standing wave is always derived by the length of the tube only. This is the same if it is a cone or curve or ess or any shape imaginable (that doesn't have a hole in it except at the end). This is determined simply because frequency is a product of wavelength and time, and wavelength is only effected by how long the standing wave is. The standing wave will be the same wavelength whether it's a cone, tube, pear, whatever. What does change is the acoustic pressure - and this could possibly cause feedback on your lips that you could very well notice. Generally, acoustic pressure lessens as the tube gets wider - so it is inversely proportional to the width of the pipe. Now direction could have something to do with it in a curved pipe, but recall that if you take a garden hose of specific length, it's fundamental is the same no matter what shape you bend it. One can find out through integration that this is so. But what you have to remember is that if a pipe or loop of tubing is sitting and not doing anything it has a standing fundamental and a harmonic series - and it is measurable and does not change. That tube is going to have an in tune harmonic series (in tune with itself) and will have 2^n harmonics where they will match equal temperament (due to the octave ratio of 2:1). Where the difference comes in is our ability to match the frequency of our lips. Our lips when buzzing create many overtones and extra frequencies mixed in and when we go higher or lower we are missing the harmonic of the instrument. Thus, when we buzz as clearly as we can to match the natural harmonic we will get the purest tone we can get. The only way the partials could possibly shift is changing it from an open pipe to a closed pipe (and we do that by sticking our hand in the bell). This is also why stopping the horn really changes the fundamental harmonic series of the horn - and why putting our hand in the bell somewhat gives it that 'notchiness' we need in the high range. As for changes in diameter - it cannot effect the harmonic series unless you interfere with the length of the tubing or close it off so that the standing wave is returned. There will be a difference between playing it (subjective to lip pressure, person, etc.) and sticking an inducted frequency into the pipe to check the response/resonance with an oscilloscope. People aren't accurate, machines are - and so I'd trust a machine in these matters. Per the C2 (I assume you mean 2nd space bass clef), it's going to be perfect on the F side open, and on Bb side with 1 and 3 you're really taking a second partial with a combination fingering and I see no other way that that could be anything but slightly sharp due to the combination fingering - UNLESS it's a compensating horn - then it would be in tune because it compensates for the combination. As for thinking too much - this really isn't that complicated and is covered in the first semester of college level Physics. To me, knowing this sort of thing isn't making things complicated - it's greatly simplifying them. Maybe that's where our perspectives differ. By the way, as for A being universal - even if you were to change A to something strange like 400 or 500Hz, then the rest of the note frequencies are easily calculate able such that one could still tune to an F and an E or whatever you want and it would work fine (equal temperament) - I have an excel spreadsheet which can do that as well as compute harmonics and pitch tendencies. -William In a message dated 11/19/2009 2:02:39 P.M. Eastern Standard Time, [email protected] writes:
William, the theory is just valid for 1005 normal circumstances, ideal circumstances. Why do partials shift if the lead pipe is changed in diameter at some section, or if the horns bore is changed when the tube leaves the valve section, some dramatic changes. Why does the overall intonation change very much with different hand positions or more extreme: hand in the bell verse hand out of the bell ? Theory is good & helpful but "practica" is different, very different. I played professionally for about 50 years on first horn mostly, but on low horn occasionally to help some coplleagues out for a gig. And the written c2 (2nd space) is in tune on most F- & Bb-sides. You even can wiggle on the thumb valve while playing this note, but no change in the notes intonation, required the horn is well built horn of the upper quality class. A horn student has many other problems than to care about the maths regarding intonation. And a horn student has different problems than to care about which muscle to involve in the playing. Too much thinking around is the greatest problem for many players, as they lack the most basic instructions, so things work automatically, bypassing the brain. So the brain ids free & can act as a superb supervisor. That is reality, even the acoustic/math matter is very interesting. _______________________________________________ post: [email protected] unsubscribe or set options at https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org
