Two things:
 
Where did I say you wouldn't tune each side independently?
 
Where did I say I would tune it before I played it?
 
I don't mean to be rude - but I don't recall saying either of those things  
and maybe I'm just a bad communicator.
 
-William
 
 
In a message dated 11/21/2009 9:36:54 A.M. Eastern Standard Time,  
[email protected] writes:



In a message dated 11/20/2009 1:18:05 P.M. Eastern Standard  Time,  
[email protected] writes:

Message:   16
Date: Fri, 20 Nov 2009 11:18:59 EST
From:   [email protected]
Subject: Re: [Hornlist] I'll stick to Physics  regarding  intonation
To: [email protected]
Message-ID:   <[email protected]>
Content-Type: text/plain;   charset="US-ASCII"

I have yet to see any information of any   professionally made horn that is 
 
designed to have the 8th partial  on  any side of the horn to be out of  
tune.
KB: Are there  amateur or student made horns that are designed for  that?   
Hmmm?  That could explain a lot of problems I've  heard!



Apparently I'm a poor communicator - because what I mean  to  say is that 
the 
8th partial is naturally in tune, and if you  tune both of  those on both 
sides  you will usually have the  best  results.
KB: IMHO, that's a good start, but if you use the  "American System" of  
fingerings on the double horn, you should tune  each side independently.   
You 
will still be needing your ears  and your right hand to make adjustments,  
though, as you  play.



Hardly anyone has the ability to see what the harmonics  are  truly doing 
on 

their instrument - the lips and hands and  ears aren't  objective enough to 
 
know.

KB: A good ear  gives you the objective ability to play in tune without  
mechanical  help.  "Hardly anyone" is not true.  Good musicians have  good  
ears. 
Good horn players have good chops and know what to do with   their right 
hand.  Put that together and you have a sizeable group  of  people, at 
least 
from my experience.


So  to me  it's safe to assume the 8th should be in tune and to tune the 
Horn   
from there.

KB: Yes, if you do that independently on both sides but  you may have other 
 
partials that require you to come up with  compromise in your slide  
settings.


Tuning a 6th partial  (or anything else) stacks the odds against  you  
greatly.   What's  the other option? Picking a partial besides 8? If you do 
then  you'll 
more  than likely shift the entire harmonic series sharp or  flat except 
for 

the  note you tuned. If you tune 8, then you'll  likely have more  notes in 
tune and a  few of the problem  harmonics flat or  sharp.
KB : You can start there, too, if you  wish.  The 6th is usually a good  
partial.  I wouldn't use  the 7th, though, except if you are going to play  
everything stopped  and then, you would want the instrument to play flat.   
Some  
notes will still be out, though. 


W: Which horn makers out  there are making their C's on the F side and  
high 

Bb's on the Bb  side out of tune? Can anyone name one?

KB: I'll venture it's those  amateur and student horn makers you refer to  
above.   


W: I still can't believe that trying to suggest a very  objective,  
all-purpose  
tuning method has been met with  such animosity and  controversy.  
You don't want to guess what  the harmonics of your new  horn are going to  
do, do you?  Without electronic equipment, you will  truly never know. At 
least  
if  you get the 8th in tune you'll have  better odds of knowing  how the 
2nd, 
4th, and  16th fare, etc. 

KB: William,  you've answered your own question here.  I don't really  
think  
there is animosity in the responses, there is certainly none in   mine.  
You've chosen a controversial subject so you should be  prepared for  
disagreement and questioning.  You also come  across as someone who has  
"found the 
answers" and "should be  revered."  The last paragraph above  shows this.  
I can  
pick up any horn and in a few minutes of playing, using  my ear, tell  you 
what partials are in/out of tune with each other.  I can   then use an 
electronic tuner or computer to verify my findings if I  so  choose.  That 
means 
that my skill and experience shows you  to be wrong  in your statement:

1: Every horn is different.   You cannot tune a horn before you play  it, 
except in a general way  if you know the make and model.   I've  play 
tested 16  
Elkhart Conns in a sitting.  They all played  differently.   I've play 
tested 8 Alexander 103's in a sitting.  They  all  played differently.  
This is 
due to manufacturing processes and   "little" problems, not design.  A 
simple 
mistake in the end cut of  a  tapered tube, like the lead-pipe, or a solder 
gob in a joint can  effect  intonation.  You don't know that ahead of time. 
  
What you might  know ahead of time are the general characteristics of  the 
8D 
(flat in the upper  register on the B side but a sharp high C,  etc.) but I 
have played 8D's that  were noticeably better in that  regard.

2: "You don't want to guess what the harmonics of your new horn  are going  
to  
do, do you?" comes across as sophomoric  at  best.  How on God's Green 
Earth 
do you know ahead of time  before you  play what the intonation of the 
particular instrument  is?

3: Your saying that "Without electronic equipment, you will truly  never  
know." is pure BULLSHIT!  Musicians have done this for  centuries!

The combination of empirical and scientific methods is what  leads to  
knowledge in the subject.  The collaboration of  musicians and technicians  
is 
what has given us improved instruments,  from day one.  

W: At  least with my system I can pick up any  horn and won't have to guess 
how   
to tune  it.

KB:  Please come visit me at my shop.  I'll give you a  brand new  Lawson, 
8D #320440, a Holton 179, a Yamaha 667V with a  Lawson pipe on it,  a stock 
Yamaha 668ii and an Alex 103 and anything  else that might be  around that 
day. 
You can tune them before you  play them.  We can  measure what happens on 
the Korg tuner and  the computer.  You might learn  something in the 
process.   
I might, also.

Best wishes,

Kendall  Betts




_______________________________________________
post:  [email protected]
unsubscribe or set options at  
https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/valkhorn%40aol.com


_______________________________________________
post: [email protected]
unsubscribe or set options at 
https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org

Reply via email to