I have yet to see any information of any professionally made horn that is  
designed to have the 8th partial on any side of the horn to be out of  tune.
 
Apparently I'm a poor communicator - because what I mean to say is that the 
 8th partial is naturally in tune, and if you tune both of those on both 
sides  you will usually have the best results.
 
Hardly anyone has the ability to see what the harmonics are truly doing on  
their instrument - the lips and hands and ears aren't objective enough to  
know.
 
So to me it's safe to assume the 8th should be in tune and to tune the Horn 
 from there.
 
Tuning a 6th partial (or anything else) stacks the odds against you  
greatly.
 
What's the other option? Picking a partial besides 8? If you do then you'll 
 more than likely shift the entire harmonic series sharp or flat except for 
the  note you tuned. If you tune 8, then you'll likely have more notes in 
tune and a  few of the problem harmonics flat or sharp.
 
We're talking 8th partial.
 
Which horn makers out there are making their C's on the F side and high  
Bb's on the Bb side out of tune? Can anyone name one?
 
I still can't believe that trying to suggest a very objective, all-purpose  
tuning method has been met with such animosity and controversy. 
 
You don't want to guess what the harmonics of your new horn are going to  
do, do you? Without electronic equipment, you will truly never know. At least 
if  you get the 8th in tune you'll have better odds of knowing how the 2nd, 
4th, and  16th fare, etc. 
 
At least with my system I can pick up any horn and won't have to guess how  
to tune it.
 
-William
 
 
In a message dated 11/20/2009 6:09:22 A.M. Eastern Standard Time,  
[email protected] writes:

On Thu,  Nov 19, 2009 at 17:54,  <[email protected]> wrote:
> I  completely completely disagree.
>
> On every horn I've ever played  the 6th partial C on the Bb horn is never 
in
>  tune with the F  side C. It CANT be.
>
> The 8th partial is NEVER going to be out  of tune. It can't be because the
> frequency of a standing wave is  determined by LENGTH and never by  shape 
or
> curls or whatever in  any tubing.

Anyone playing tuba will have encountered instruments that  completely
fly in the face of your statements. ;)

To put it  extremely bluntly, it is purely a combination of luck,
coincidence and  expert craftmanship that a complex system of twisting
tubes of varying  diameter like a brass instrument produces anything
approaching a harmonic  series.

I leave it to others better versed in physics and English to  explain
the details, but there are enough books and websites around that  try
to explain the basics of the complex accoustics involved. Look  for
stuff like bell effect and mouthpiece effect. These will explain  for
instance that for every single harmonic the final node will be in  a
different place inside the bell. Hence your claim that because of  the
length of the instrument the 8th partial cannot be out of tune is  not
true. Get the shape of the instrument wrong and you can create  all
sorts of weird disharmonic series.

Michiel van der  Linden
_______________________________________________
post:  [email protected]
unsubscribe or set options at  
https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/valkhorn%40aol.com

_______________________________________________
post: [email protected]
unsubscribe or set options at 
https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org

Reply via email to