In a message dated 11/20/2009 1:18:05 P.M. Eastern Standard Time, [email protected] writes:
Message: 16 Date: Fri, 20 Nov 2009 11:18:59 EST From: [email protected] Subject: Re: [Hornlist] I'll stick to Physics regarding intonation To: [email protected] Message-ID: <[email protected]> Content-Type: text/plain; charset="US-ASCII" I have yet to see any information of any professionally made horn that is designed to have the 8th partial on any side of the horn to be out of tune. KB: Are there amateur or student made horns that are designed for that? Hmmm? That could explain a lot of problems I've heard! Apparently I'm a poor communicator - because what I mean to say is that the 8th partial is naturally in tune, and if you tune both of those on both sides you will usually have the best results. KB: IMHO, that's a good start, but if you use the "American System" of fingerings on the double horn, you should tune each side independently. You will still be needing your ears and your right hand to make adjustments, though, as you play. Hardly anyone has the ability to see what the harmonics are truly doing on their instrument - the lips and hands and ears aren't objective enough to know. KB: A good ear gives you the objective ability to play in tune without mechanical help. "Hardly anyone" is not true. Good musicians have good ears. Good horn players have good chops and know what to do with their right hand. Put that together and you have a sizeable group of people, at least from my experience. So to me it's safe to assume the 8th should be in tune and to tune the Horn from there. KB: Yes, if you do that independently on both sides but you may have other partials that require you to come up with compromise in your slide settings. Tuning a 6th partial (or anything else) stacks the odds against you greatly. What's the other option? Picking a partial besides 8? If you do then you'll more than likely shift the entire harmonic series sharp or flat except for the note you tuned. If you tune 8, then you'll likely have more notes in tune and a few of the problem harmonics flat or sharp. KB : You can start there, too, if you wish. The 6th is usually a good partial. I wouldn't use the 7th, though, except if you are going to play everything stopped and then, you would want the instrument to play flat. Some notes will still be out, though. W: Which horn makers out there are making their C's on the F side and high Bb's on the Bb side out of tune? Can anyone name one? KB: I'll venture it's those amateur and student horn makers you refer to above. W: I still can't believe that trying to suggest a very objective, all-purpose tuning method has been met with such animosity and controversy. You don't want to guess what the harmonics of your new horn are going to do, do you? Without electronic equipment, you will truly never know. At least if you get the 8th in tune you'll have better odds of knowing how the 2nd, 4th, and 16th fare, etc. KB: William, you've answered your own question here. I don't really think there is animosity in the responses, there is certainly none in mine. You've chosen a controversial subject so you should be prepared for disagreement and questioning. You also come across as someone who has "found the answers" and "should be revered." The last paragraph above shows this. I can pick up any horn and in a few minutes of playing, using my ear, tell you what partials are in/out of tune with each other. I can then use an electronic tuner or computer to verify my findings if I so choose. That means that my skill and experience shows you to be wrong in your statement: 1: Every horn is different. You cannot tune a horn before you play it, except in a general way if you know the make and model. I've play tested 16 Elkhart Conns in a sitting. They all played differently. I've play tested 8 Alexander 103's in a sitting. They all played differently. This is due to manufacturing processes and "little" problems, not design. A simple mistake in the end cut of a tapered tube, like the lead-pipe, or a solder gob in a joint can effect intonation. You don't know that ahead of time. What you might know ahead of time are the general characteristics of the 8D (flat in the upper register on the B side but a sharp high C, etc.) but I have played 8D's that were noticeably better in that regard. 2: "You don't want to guess what the harmonics of your new horn are going to do, do you?" comes across as sophomoric at best. How on God's Green Earth do you know ahead of time before you play what the intonation of the particular instrument is? 3: Your saying that "Without electronic equipment, you will truly never know." is pure BULLSHIT! Musicians have done this for centuries! The combination of empirical and scientific methods is what leads to knowledge in the subject. The collaboration of musicians and technicians is what has given us improved instruments, from day one. W: At least with my system I can pick up any horn and won't have to guess how to tune it. KB: Please come visit me at my shop. I'll give you a brand new Lawson, 8D #320440, a Holton 179, a Yamaha 667V with a Lawson pipe on it, a stock Yamaha 668ii and an Alex 103 and anything else that might be around that day. You can tune them before you play them. We can measure what happens on the Korg tuner and the computer. You might learn something in the process. I might, also. Best wishes, Kendall Betts _______________________________________________ post: [email protected] unsubscribe or set options at https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org
