Hello list members, William, I respect the physics behind your method, and have no quarrel with it. If it works for you, great; if it could help others play in tune, even better.
In 1863, Herman von Helmholz (sp?) wrote of this in his seminal book, "On the Sensations of Tone as a Physiological basis for the Theory of Music" and even invented a device (I believe it was called a 'resonator') to show the 'high points' of various tones, or pitches. It's "heavy reading" for a non-scientist like myself, but, he discusses sensory physiology as well as some of the physics of acoustics to which you refer. I'm a bit surprised that in the course of the discussion on tuning here, no one has referred to him; to the best of my knowledge, he was the first person to prove, via acoustics as well as physiology, the difference between a chromatic (C-C#) and a diatonic (C-Db) semitone. However, Greg's point is well-taken: despite claims to the contrary, no horn is perfect, and tuning is truly relative-- at best, a compromise. All discussion of partials is moot, especially when a player cannot hear (perceive) that they are out of tune, due to a lack of ear training. What is of critical importance is that players are able adjust, so that everyone is in tune with the first oboe in their orchestra/ensemble-- 'right' or 'wrong'. When the conductor is about to step on to the podium, the time for a horn player to be referring to the Korg/Strobo-Conn, (or whatever make your tuner may be) and stubbornly refusing to adjust pitch because the two red lights are not on, is long past! Happy practising! Sincerely, martin bender On 20-Nov-09, at 12:52 PM, [email protected] wrote: > So it boils down to choosing a 6th partial between 8th on the Bb > side? > > Something tells me 9 times out of 10 (maybe 99 out of 100) that the > 8th > partial will be closer than the 6th. > > So I give that my method isn't as objective as I'd like it to be - > but I > don't see any advantage of using 6th over 8th for tuning since 9 > times out of > 10 the 6th will be sharper than the 8th and will flatten everything > else. > > -William > > > In a message dated 11/20/2009 12:37:41 P.M. Eastern Standard Time, > [email protected] writes: > > The reliability of your method isn't really being questioned so > much as > how "objective" it is. I don't believe there really anything > fundamental > that forces a horn's 8th partial to always be perfectly in tune > with the > rest of that same horn's harmonic series. Too many variables. It's > probably close though. I tend to believe the 6th partial is pretty > close > too. > > If you're confident that you can play every note dead center in the > slot > where it belongs and you're confident that the 8th partial is going > to > have those slots perfectly in tune, by all means tune that way. In > theory, I believe it's somewhat more complicated than that. > > In practice, I think it's much simpler: play a couple of notes in a > comfortable range--6th partials are fair game if your horn doesn't > play > them wildly sharp--get the slides pulled to a place where you can > reasonably play in tune, then listen and play in tune. That third > space > c' might need to be sharp sometimes (third of an A minor triad) or > flat > sometimes (seventh of a D7) so it's really all relative anyway. > > _______________________________________________ > post: [email protected] > unsubscribe or set options at > https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/embee%40magma.ca > _______________________________________________ post: [email protected] unsubscribe or set options at https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org
