[email protected] wrote:
> I have yet to see any information of any professionally made horn that is  
> designed to have the 8th partial on any side of the horn to be out of  tune.

I don't think anyone designs a horn with any note deliberately out of 
tune (at least not deliberately *wildly* out of tune).


> Apparently I'm a poor communicator - because what I mean to say is that the 
>  8th partial is naturally in tune, and if you tune both of those on both 
> sides  you will usually have the best results.

The 8th partial is only "naturally" in tune in a "natural" harmonic 
series. E.g. the vibrations of a string or a perfect resonating tube. 
The horn is no such beast. Its complex combination of conical and 
cylindrical sections makes it quite likely to have out of tune partials. 
I believe the horn makers take a fundamentally out-of-tune design and 
try to make it back in tune.

I'd say most of the horns I've played have had especially "out of tune" 
5th partials on the F horn: the harmonic series says they should be 
quite flat (16 cents), but most horns only play that note somewhat flat 
(about 8 cents). I think that may be a design principle in place, or 
just dumb luck. Or it could be that I have equal temperament so 
ingrained in my ear from playing the piano since I was 5 years old that 
I naturally play the 5th partial a bit higher than the horn would like 
me to.


> Which horn makers out there are making their C's on the F side and high  
> Bb's on the Bb side out of tune? Can anyone name one?

All of 'em! I promise I can play the 8th partials out of tune on any 
horn you hand me. ;-)


> I still can't believe that trying to suggest a very objective, all-purpose  
> tuning method has been met with such animosity and controversy. 

The reliability of your method isn't really being questioned so much as 
how "objective" it is. I don't believe there really anything fundamental 
that forces a horn's 8th partial to always be perfectly in tune with the 
rest of that same horn's harmonic series. Too many variables. It's 
probably close though. I tend to believe the 6th partial is pretty close 
too.

If you're confident that you can play every note dead center in the slot 
where it belongs and you're confident that the 8th partial is going to 
have those slots perfectly in tune, by all means tune that way. In 
theory, I believe it's somewhat more complicated than that.

In practice, I think it's much simpler: play a couple of notes in a 
comfortable range--6th partials are fair game if your horn doesn't play 
them wildly sharp--get the slides pulled to a place where you can 
reasonably play in tune, then listen and play in tune. That third space 
c' might need to be sharp sometimes (third of an A minor triad) or flat 
sometimes (seventh of a D7) so it's really all relative anyway.

Greg

_______________________________________________
post: [email protected]
unsubscribe or set options at 
https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org

Reply via email to