On 8/9/2010 9:52 AM, Pat wrote:
I think that usage is not particularly scientific but more
colloquial. Deane answer, below, is more the scientific view. Also,
we must remember that "good person" couldn't possibly apply to those
that are not "Homo Sapiens", yet evolution applies to ALL species.
Thus, even if I train my dog to have perfect "Western" table manners,
it's still not a 'good person'--might be a great dog and a helluva
canine, but not a good person. And, of course, table manners are no
show of evolution despite the fact that there are people who display
them who feel that they are "a product of better breeding"; whereas,
in truth, it might just be better 'training' (i.e., table manners is
little more than 'stupid human tricks' and certainly doesn't
demonstrate whether or not a person is 'good' or have any bearing on
their evolution). As an aside to this and to link them together in a
sideways kind of way, I suppose the habit that Englishmen have of
'holding the knife with the right hand' whether or not the individual
is using it, MAY actually BE good evolution, as it affords them a
better chance at defending themselves if attacked whilst eating!!
I think this thread has covered habit, habitat and now habituation :),
and I agree often walking and talking like one may be a sign, but then
what is this 'duck' anyways?
Surprise a southpaw might keep the knife in the right for more practical
reasons, one might want to reserve the greatest asset to flexible use,
in a split second how many people will drop a knife for one of the
dozens of other effective weapons at a dinner table. Well the thought
crossed my mind recently when I wondered why I was cutting awkwardly
with my right. I switched for ease but was annoyed at the fact this gave
away tactical information. After consideration I decided it is best to
keep a hot cup of coffee at the table, glass plates, and preferably a
table/chairs with wooden legs and not bolted to the floor. There's large
numbers of people around, all pretending to be caught up in little
table-worlds, conspicuous consumption at it's best. Worst of all, I
can't lick my plate. :( I should stand up before leaving and do that
sometime just to see what it feels like, would I feel the cruching
anxiety of people judging me or would I feel free? I could think to
myself I feel free of judgement, while the onlookers would say look what
society is devolving into. My secret is while most people would think
this doglike behavior, I have pride in it, I remember how little most
know of dogs (people, or reality) or what it is like to starve like one.
Nothing directed at you personally Pat, just ranting somewhat in context.
