I purchased Norton Utilities and Drive 10 for Mac.  Both have a 
defragment utility.  Both of these took around 6 hours to complete on 
my dual G4 1.4MHZ, 80GB hard drive.  Both also completely screwed up my 
system to the point of reinstallation.  I have completely given up on 
any of these tools and consider myself to have wasted over $200.00 on 
nothing of any value.

On Oct 26, 2003, at 6:44 PM, Scott at HobbyLink Japan wrote:

>> I've never gotten a complete answer on the value of defragmenting 
>> under
>> OS X either. For the longest time I didn't think there _were_ any
>> utilities to do this in X. Having never defragged my hard disk I 
>> shudder
>> to think of what it looks like at this point.
>
> Tid-Bits did an article a while ago which basically said that with 
> modern
> hard disks, there's no point in defragging.  Generally, the defragging
> process itself takes more time to accomplish than the performance gains
> you'll achieve with it, and with the risk of data loss that accompanies
> it, it's basically worthless.
>
> See <http://db.tidbits.com/getbits.acgi?tbart=07254>
>
> ---
>
> Scott T. Hards
> President
> HobbyLink Japan (www.hlj.com)
>
>


Reply via email to