Dear kaza If I recall correctly, your query was "Can PIO deny me information to a RTI request filed u/s 6 for minutes of proceedings of its Councils / Boards / Committees etc. on the ground that the P/A has already previously published u/s 4(1)(b)(viii) that these documents are not open to the public"
The identical issue came up in http://cic.gov.in/CIC-Orders/WB-07082008-04.pdf Mr H held (very correctly) "4(1)(b)(viii) does not give the public authority a right to exempt information from disclosure which is only possible u/s 8(1) and 9 of the Act" TIP: google is one of the best search engines on the planet. entering advanced search terms like "4(1)(b)(viii) site:cic.gov.in" will resolve many such problems member have. Sarbajit An image of the "bombed out" Marriot Hotel Islamabad I linked to in a previous mail was censored out by Yahoo. This is a test. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/huff-wires/20080921/as-pakistan/images/1ac951d9-e2e4-4db8-b16c-27b68e3586c6.jpg On 11/28/08, kaza rajasekhar <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > Dear friend, > > Thank you for responding to my doubt regarding proactive disclosure in RTI. > I am not totally clear about it but i have to put my question clearly to you > for you to answer me. > So, i will soon give a detailed question of my doubts. > Anyway, sorry for my delay in sending in my thanks to you. > Thank you again. > > Rajasekhar > > Kaza raja >
