Re: [apple-crop] Liquid Lime Sulfur?

2016-04-08 Thread Vincent Philion
Hi! I frankly don’t know. I’m assuming it’s related to volume. i/e Dilute vs concentrate ? Dilute rates result in more phytotoxicity than concentrate. This is “known”, but I’m not sure we always account for that when experiments are run with a “gun”. All else being equal, results at 250 L/ha are

Re: [apple-crop] Liquid Lime Sulfur?

2016-04-07 Thread David A. Rosenberger
I’m surprised that your graphic (and I think I heard the same from Marc Trapman) suggests that in Europe they recommend using LLS only on wet leaves whereas the old info from Burrell suggested that it should NOT be applied to wet leaves. Any explanation? > On Apr 7, 2016, at 5:31 PM, Vincent Ph

Re: [apple-crop] Liquid Lime Sulfur?

2016-04-07 Thread Vincent Philion
Hi! I heard at the Hudson Valley RIMpro meeting last month that bicarbonate is used in Europe during rainfall That would seem to necessitate repeated applications during an infections period. Does it have no after-infection value? In replicated tests over the years, we saw value in using bicarb

Re: [apple-crop] Liquid Lime Sulfur?

2016-04-07 Thread David Kollas
Vincent: What can you tell us about the experience with bicarbonate? I think I heard at the Hudson Valley RIMpro meeting last month that bicarbonate is used in Europe during rainfall to kill what has impinged on foliage, but not entered the leaf interior yet. That would seem to necessit

Re: [apple-crop] Liquid Lime Sulfur?

2016-04-07 Thread Vincent Philion
Hi Dave, I use the European data on LLS. I never dug deeper. My interest in LLS was mostly to compare it to Bicarbonate for organic growers. Maybe it can achieve more kickback (?) I just know the bulk of organic European growers stick with the 250DH criteria. Vincent > I thought that I had rea

Re: [apple-crop] Liquid Lime Sulfur?

2016-04-07 Thread Vincent Philion
Hi! Normal only in the context of Organic Production only! Part of the phytotoxicity is avoided by using a much reduced rate in summer. I meant to say it’s not a rescue treatment for anyone. it’s either ’normal’ (organic) or completely forgotten (IPM). I would also say that LLS is quickly bein

Re: [apple-crop] Liquid Lime Sulfur?

2016-04-07 Thread David Kollas
I was surprised by Vincent’s comment that liquid lime sulfur is a “normal” choice for post-infection in his area. My recollection is that its use quickly went out of favor when ferbam and captan became available, mostly because of reduced photosynthetic ability of LLS-damaged leaves. Maybe the

Re: [apple-crop] Liquid Lime Sulfur?

2016-04-07 Thread David Doud
LLS was out of favor here before I started spraying, but I do have some references and dad used to talk about it - from 1944 ‘Spray Chemicals’ - “The disadvantages are that liquid lime-sulfur is very disagreeable to use owing to its causticity. Also this causticity is blamed for subsequent fol

Re: [apple-crop] Liquid Lime Sulfur?

2016-04-07 Thread David A. Rosenberger
Art Burrell, working in the Champlain Valley of NY where spring temperatures are often cool, would agree with you. The sentences after the section that I quoted in the previous post says: “We have a period up to 60 or 70 hours, after the start of theinfection period, during which a heavy appli

Re: [apple-crop] Liquid Lime Sulfur?

2016-04-07 Thread Vincent Philion
If you worry about Captan phytotoxicity, then you should also worry about LLS being phytotoxic under the same conditions. Liquid lime sulfur is a ’normal’ (ie not emergency) choice for post infection (kickback). However, I wouldn’t trust it 96 hours after beginning of rain, unless the temperatur

Re: [apple-crop] Liquid Lime Sulfur?

2016-04-07 Thread David A. Rosenberger
Sorry if this is a duplication: I tried attaching Art Burrell’s discussion of sulfur sprays with the following message, but I think that made the message size too large for this list-serve. I can only reprint what Dr. Art Burrell said in 1945 at the 90th Annual Meeting of the New York State Hor