Re: [CGUYS] MIT's futuristic, networked bus stop design

2009-05-28 Thread Eric S. Sande
For mass transit to work and not be a net drain it has to be survivable at a market price. Yep. In DC we have a world-class system, in some ways, at a lowball price. Nice trains, which are SRO in the rush hour, nice environmentally friendly buses, and low prices. Yet the city is still jammed

Re: [CGUYS] MIT's futuristic, networked bus stop design

2009-05-28 Thread Paul Cannon
I kind of scratched my head when the bike locker rates seemed to double when I had to renew this year. Of course, the savings are mythical save 5$ parking (and receive health benefits) but the money saved tends to go more bike swag. I enjoy the 1.5 mile ride to the station, I tend to skip

Re: [CGUYS] MIT's futuristic, networked bus stop design

2009-05-28 Thread db
Why not? Automobiles/ road systems were subsidized for decades in the US as were the railroads earlier and as is your cellphone now. Europe and other countries just don't BS as much about the nature of things / what it takes to make transport systems work and economies go around. They more

Re: [CGUYS] MIT's futuristic, networked bus stop design

2009-05-28 Thread Rev. Stewart Marshall
We do with oil what we do with most things. We only look just past our nose and see ho much it costs me. My in-laws in Canada have been paying higher gasoline costs for years. My relatives in Germany pay exorbitant prices for oil as compared to us. Part of the reason behind this is

Re: [CGUYS] MIT's futuristic, networked bus stop design

2009-05-28 Thread b_s-wilk
For mass transit to work and not be a net drain it has to be survivable at a market price. Yep. In DC we have a world-class system, in some ways, at a lowball price. Nice trains, which are SRO in the rush hour, nice environmentally friendly buses, and low prices. Yet the city is still

Re: [CGUYS] MIT's futuristic, networked bus stop design

2009-05-28 Thread Rev. Stewart Marshall
Betty that is key to making it work. Make ares where Cars cannot travel. Make public transport simple and easy and you would be surprised how it works. The Europeans have us beat when it comes to most transportation ideas. Part of our problem stems back to Americas individualism and short

Re: [CGUYS] MIT's futuristic, networked bus stop design

2009-05-28 Thread John Settle
Rev. Stewart Marshall wrote: Anyone will tell you that if you increase your volume you increase your profit. Well, maybe anyone at GM or Chrysler would but see where they wound up. If a business continues to sell a product or service that costs $10.00 to produce for $9.00, no matter how

Re: [CGUYS] MIT's futuristic, networked bus stop design

2009-05-28 Thread John Settle
Rev. Stewart Marshall wrote: Again because they aim only at the lower income. No! If you sell something that costs $10.00 to produce for $9.00 to someone who makes $250,000 a year you still lose a Dollar. The same if selling the product to someone who makes $3,000 a year. No matter what the

Re: [CGUYS] MIT's futuristic, networked bus stop design

2009-05-28 Thread Rev. Stewart Marshall
That is called dumb business, but it was not just there fault. There were a lot of things that caused that. I lived in an area with a Goodyear plant a few years ago and they had some mighty rounds with their unions. They had to support more retirees than active workers and pay full benefits

Re: [CGUYS] MIT's futuristic, networked bus stop design

2009-05-28 Thread db
And we will be flirting with bankruptcy in the US ... as we are now ... until we start looking at real costs and what we are spending on subsidies. No one ... not an individual nor a nation ... can plan, budget or save until you readily know what you are spending for what... db Rev.

Re: [CGUYS] MIT's futuristic, networked bus stop design

2009-05-28 Thread Matthew Taylor
Yes, many cities have roads paid for by tax dollars that the citizens are not allowed to freely use. How is this consistent with principals of liberty? What you call subsidy I call hiding from the taxpayer the true cost of the service delivered, convincing them they are getting a bargain

Re: [CGUYS] MIT's futuristic, networked bus stop design

2009-05-28 Thread b_s-wilk
Betty that is key to making it work. Make ares where Cars cannot travel. Make public transport simple and easy and you would be surprised how it works. The Europeans have us beat when it comes to most transportation ideas. Part of our problem stems back to Americas individualism and short term

Re: [CGUYS] MIT's futuristic, networked bus stop design

2009-05-28 Thread Rev. Stewart Marshall
I am not sure what schools you are talking about but around here they are required to take at least 4 years of history/government/economics around here. Current affairs was also a requirement (It was kind of cool having my son ask for the newspaper and not seeing him turn to the comics

Re: [CGUYS] MIT's futuristic, networked bus stop design

2009-05-28 Thread b_s-wilk
Yes, many cities have roads paid for by tax dollars that the citizens are not allowed to freely use. How is this consistent with principals of liberty? They're called pedestrian zones. Or public transit zones. Reduces pollution. Makes downtowns more user friendly. You have the liberty to walk

Re: [CGUYS] MIT's futuristic, networked bus stop design

2009-05-28 Thread Eric S. Sande
It's sort of scary how often I almost sort of agree with you. Public transportation, public education, they have tangible benefits even though I don't ride buses currently or have children in school. But I have no problem paying for them because there are valid social reasons for doing so.

Re: [CGUYS] MIT's futuristic, networked bus stop design

2009-05-28 Thread tjpa
On May 27, 2009, at 8:25 PM, Matthew Taylor wrote: Nothing they can do to increase ridership will help so long as they operate under a model that has them loose money on each rider. You can't make it up in volume. Missing the big picture (once again). The point of public transportation

Re: [CGUYS] MIT's futuristic, networked bus stop design

2009-05-28 Thread tjpa
On May 28, 2009, at 1:12 AM, Matthew Taylor wrote: Not at all true in the DC metro area where I live or the NY metro area where I grew up. Lots of people commute on the trains and busses Mayor Bloomberg rides the subway to work and he is worth $billions.

Re: [CGUYS] MIT's futuristic, networked bus stop design

2009-05-27 Thread db
Nice gadget ... too bad that in times of increased ridership because of gas prices/ economy and funding issues, most city bus systems are facing budget shortfalls and service cutbacks... Expensive gee wiz bus tech gadgets ... will that help or make the $ problem worse? Honest question ...

Re: [CGUYS] MIT's futuristic, networked bus stop design

2009-05-27 Thread t.piwowar
On May 27, 2009, at 1:01 PM, b_s-wilk wrote: Bus stop 2020: A team at MIT has designed a bus stop of the future. Many of the commentators shared my first thought. The one I liked best was even a step ahead... Maybe they should incorporate some kind of lightning zapper device to shoot

Re: [CGUYS] MIT's futuristic, networked bus stop design

2009-05-27 Thread Rev. Stewart Marshall
It depends. In many foreign countries public transportation is the backbone of getting from one place to the next. I know in Europe it is frequently used and well respected. The problem here is that it is not always well thought out, tends to be restricted time wise, and is not available in

Re: [CGUYS] MIT's futuristic, networked bus stop design

2009-05-27 Thread t.piwowar
On May 27, 2009, at 6:01 PM, db wrote: Expensive gee wiz bus tech gadgets ... will that help or make the $ problem worse? The bus stop near my house has a small scrolling display that shows arrival times for the next few buses. It has been in service for over a year and still working.

Re: [CGUYS] MIT's futuristic, networked bus stop design

2009-05-27 Thread db
Some university techies implemented an ingenious add-on for Seattle's Bus Metro here (called One Bus Away) that allows you to place a call or SMS text to a totally automated system, where you indicate the bus stop # by voice or SMS and it reports back by voice or text when and which buses will

Re: [CGUYS] MIT's futuristic, networked bus stop design

2009-05-27 Thread Rev. Stewart Marshall
The more customer service oriented they make it the better it is. The ones in Portland work exceptionally well and tell you where you want to go. Same with St. Louis. Came in to airports at both and got to where I needed to be with no problems. Stewart At 05:37 PM 5/27/2009, you wrote:

Re: [CGUYS] MIT's futuristic, networked bus stop design

2009-05-27 Thread Matthew Taylor
Nothing they can do to increase ridership will help so long as they operate under a model that has them loose money on each rider. You can't make it up in volume. Matthew On May 27, 2009, at 6:01 PM, db wrote: Nice gadget ... too bad that in times of increased ridership because of gas

Re: [CGUYS] MIT's futuristic, networked bus stop design

2009-05-27 Thread Rev. Stewart Marshall
Volume does help. The problem I see that they need to correct is a view of public transportation as ill suited to anyone with an income over the poverty level in some cities. Anyone will tell you that if you increase your volume you increase your profit. Most public transportation does not

Re: [CGUYS] MIT's futuristic, networked bus stop design

2009-05-27 Thread Matthew Taylor
No, volume hurts most public transit because the cost to serve additional passengers is greater than the revenue received from those passengers. Yes, you can make a bit more if you are filling mostly empty busses and train cars, but when you need to expand service to need greater demand

Re: [CGUYS] MIT's futuristic, networked bus stop design

2009-05-27 Thread Rev. Stewart Marshall
Again because they aim only at the lower income. If they aimed at a higher income they would make money. That is what I meant about neighborhoods not served. In Europe their public transportation does not just aim at one socio economic strata. It serves all. In Canada (One I am again