Re: [VOTE] Move to Jira (Was: Re: Jira or Bugzilla...)

2005-10-19 Thread Bertrand Delacretaz
Le 13 oct. 05, à 10:42, Pier Fumagalli a écrit : ...I was waiting for a closure on the REQ Fixing really old bugs thread before proposing a timeline, it definitely makes sense to wait for the cleanup to be complete Peter's idea of doing the cleanup in Jira makes a lot of sense [1], I

Re: [VOTE] Move to Jira (Was: Re: Jira or Bugzilla...)

2005-10-19 Thread Pier Fumagalli
On 19 Oct 2005, at 07:46, Bertrand Delacretaz wrote: Le 13 oct. 05, à 10:42, Pier Fumagalli a écrit : ...I was waiting for a closure on the REQ Fixing really old bugs thread before proposing a timeline, it definitely makes sense to wait for the cleanup to be complete Peter's idea of

Re: [VOTE] Move to Jira (Was: Re: Jira or Bugzilla...)

2005-10-19 Thread Bertrand Delacretaz
Le 19 oct. 05, à 19:45, Pier Fumagalli a écrit : ...There is a flag Closed for bug entry on Bugzilla, which is settable on a per-product basis, I think that will prevent anyone to post new bugs, but we can't put in a MOVED_TO_JIRA state (that requires changes in the database, AFAIK), so

Re: [VOTE] Move to Jira (Was: Re: Jira or Bugzilla...)

2005-10-19 Thread Pier Fumagalli
On 19 Oct 2005, at 19:20, Bertrand Delacretaz wrote: Le 19 oct. 05, à 19:45, Pier Fumagalli a écrit : ...There is a flag Closed for bug entry on Bugzilla, which is settable on a per-product basis, I think that will prevent anyone to post new bugs, but we can't put in a MOVED_TO_JIRA state

Re: [VOTE] Move to Jira (Was: Re: Jira or Bugzilla...)

2005-10-16 Thread Jeff Turner
On Fri, Oct 14, 2005 at 05:09:50PM +0200, Bertrand Delacretaz wrote: Le 14 oct. 05, à 16:01, Bertrand Delacretaz a écrit : ...I don't know if jira is as good as bugzilla for mass operations (i.e. set all open issues which were entered before Sept 1st to LATER / P5), I'll check as soon

Re: [VOTE] Move to Jira (Was: Re: Jira or Bugzilla...)

2005-10-14 Thread Bertrand Delacretaz
Le 13 oct. 05, à 23:41, Pier Fumagalli a écrit : ...Regarding the bugs themselves, I can write a simple script closing all moved bugs with a link to the new bug in Jira as a comment (of course, after the data-transfer is complete).. Sounds good, and combined with the search by bugzilla issue

Re: [VOTE] Move to Jira (Was: Re: Jira or Bugzilla...)

2005-10-14 Thread Peter Hunsberger
On 10/14/05, Bertrand Delacretaz [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Le 13 oct. 05, à 23:41, Pier Fumagalli a écrit : ...Regarding the bugs themselves, I can write a simple script closing all moved bugs with a link to the new bug in Jira as a comment (of course, after the data-transfer is complete)..

Re: [VOTE] Move to Jira (Was: Re: Jira or Bugzilla...)

2005-10-14 Thread Bertrand Delacretaz
Le 14 oct. 05, à 15:46, Peter Hunsberger a écrit : Following this thread, I wonder if if might not work well to combine the move to Jira with the so called bug amnesty? You'd e-mail everyone with an open bug that it was being moved to the new system and if they where still interested in

Re: [VOTE] Move to Jira (Was: Re: Jira or Bugzilla...)

2005-10-14 Thread hepabolu
Bertrand Delacretaz wrote: Let me reformulate, I like the idea: a) move issues to jira first, set bugzilla readonly b) do the cleanup in jira, which will send the emails to people with links to jira c) people go to jira to confirm or close the issue. The issue includes a backlink to the old

Re: [VOTE] Move to Jira (Was: Re: Jira or Bugzilla...)

2005-10-14 Thread Peter Hunsberger
On 10/14/05, Bertrand Delacretaz [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Le 14 oct. 05, à 15:46, Peter Hunsberger a écrit : snip/ a) move issues to jira first, set bugzilla readonly b) do the cleanup in jira, which will send the emails to people with links to jira c) people go to jira to confirm or

Re: [VOTE] Move to Jira (Was: Re: Jira or Bugzilla...)

2005-10-14 Thread Bertrand Delacretaz
Le 14 oct. 05, à 16:01, Bertrand Delacretaz a écrit : ...I don't know if jira is as good as bugzilla for mass operations (i.e. set all open issues which were entered before Sept 1st to LATER / P5), I'll check as soon as it is back... I've checked - there are nice bulk operations, but at

Re: [VOTE] Move to Jira (Was: Re: Jira or Bugzilla...)

2005-10-14 Thread Pier Fumagalli
On 14 Oct 2005, at 02:08, Jeff Turner wrote: It's not possible to directly keep IDs, but it's fairly easy to find Jira issues by their old Bugzilla ID. On the Jira front page, there is a 'Search by Bugzilla ID' box: http://issues.apache.org/jira/ Eg. searching for bug 8017 gets you to the

Re: [VOTE] Move to Jira (Was: Re: Jira or Bugzilla...)

2005-10-14 Thread Pier Fumagalli
On 14 Oct 2005, at 15:58, Peter Hunsberger wrote: The only downside is that people need to create an account jira first, before they can confirm or close their issues. But I agree that it's good to expose people to the new system. If they care enought about the issue, then they'll need a

Re: [VOTE] Move to Jira (Was: Re: Jira or Bugzilla...)

2005-10-13 Thread Bertrand Delacretaz
Le 11 oct. 05, à 12:43, Pier Fumagalli a écrit : Ok, there we go, here's the vote... [ ] +1 Yes please, let's move all our bugs to Jira... +1 BUT - I'm going to start a vote about http://wiki.apache.org/cocoon/BugzillaIssuesCleanup, to do a big cleanup in the next two weeks, so it would

RE: [VOTE] Move to Jira (Was: Re: Jira or Bugzilla...)

2005-10-13 Thread Arje Cahn
Ok, there we go, here's the vote... [X] +1 Yes please, let's move all our bugs to Jira and set it up to work in the following way: +1 Arjé

Re: [VOTE] Move to Jira (Was: Re: Jira or Bugzilla...)

2005-10-13 Thread Pier Fumagalli
On 13 Oct 2005, at 07:14, Bertrand Delacretaz wrote: Le 11 oct. 05, à 12:43, Pier Fumagalli a écrit : Ok, there we go, here's the vote... [ ] +1 Yes please, let's move all our bugs to Jira... +1 BUT - I'm going to start a vote about http://wiki.apache.org/

Re: [VOTE] Move to Jira (Was: Re: Jira or Bugzilla...)

2005-10-13 Thread Bertrand Delacretaz
Le 13 oct. 05, à 10:42, Pier Fumagalli a écrit : ...In the meantime, I'm going to set-up Jira with statuses and workflows. And after the cleanup is done, we can move all outstanding issues over... Cool, thanks. -Bertrand

Re: [VOTE] Move to Jira (Was: Re: Jira or Bugzilla...)

2005-10-13 Thread Vadim Gritsenko
Bertrand Delacretaz wrote: Le 13 oct. 05, à 10:42, Pier Fumagalli a écrit : ...In the meantime, I'm going to set-up Jira with statuses and workflows. And after the cleanup is done, we can move all outstanding issues over... Shouldn't we move *all* issues to Jira - so that fixed/closed

Re: [VOTE] Move to Jira (Was: Re: Jira or Bugzilla...)

2005-10-13 Thread Bertrand Delacretaz
Le 13 oct. 05, à 16:51, Vadim Gritsenko a écrit : Bertrand Delacretaz wrote: Le 13 oct. 05, à 10:42, Pier Fumagalli a écrit : ...In the meantime, I'm going to set-up Jira with statuses and workflows. And after the cleanup is done, we can move all outstanding issues over... Shouldn't we

Re: [VOTE] Move to Jira (Was: Re: Jira or Bugzilla...)

2005-10-13 Thread Joerg Heinicke
On 13.10.2005 08:14, Bertrand Delacretaz wrote: +1 BUT - I'm going to start a vote about http://wiki.apache.org/cocoon/BugzillaIssuesCleanup, to do a big cleanup in the next two weeks, so it would be better to wait until this is done. I expect to start the vote tonight or tomorrow morning

Re: [VOTE] Move to Jira (Was: Re: Jira or Bugzilla...)

2005-10-13 Thread Bertrand Delacretaz
Le 13 oct. 05, à 22:53, Joerg Heinicke a écrit : ...You introduce another problem with this process: Current owners got sent a bugzilla mail about closure of their bug. If they want to reopen it later they don't know where to do it... There must be a way to find issues in jira later based on

Re: [VOTE] Move to Jira (Was: Re: Jira or Bugzilla...)

2005-10-13 Thread Joerg Heinicke
On 13.10.2005 23:11, Bertrand Delacretaz wrote: ...You introduce another problem with this process: Current owners got sent a bugzilla mail about closure of their bug. If they want to reopen it later they don't know where to do it... There must be a way to find issues in jira later based on

Re: [VOTE] Move to Jira (Was: Re: Jira or Bugzilla...)

2005-10-13 Thread Pier Fumagalli
On 13 Oct 2005, at 22:30, Joerg Heinicke wrote: On 13.10.2005 23:11, Bertrand Delacretaz wrote: ...You introduce another problem with this process: Current owners got sent a bugzilla mail about closure of their bug. If they want to reopen it later they don't know where to do it... There

Re: [VOTE] Move to Jira (Was: Re: Jira or Bugzilla...)

2005-10-13 Thread Joerg Heinicke
On 13.10.2005 23:41, Pier Fumagalli wrote: Logins are copied from Bugzilla with the issues they're associated with (which is cool, but that means that if you registered with a different email address from Bugzilla, I'll have to go in and merge the accounts). But for users, that's totally

Re: [VOTE] Move to Jira (Was: Re: Jira or Bugzilla...)

2005-10-13 Thread Jeff Turner
On Thu, Oct 13, 2005 at 11:11:12PM +0200, Bertrand Delacretaz wrote: Le 13 oct. 05, à 22:53, Joerg Heinicke a écrit : ...You introduce another problem with this process: Current owners got sent a bugzilla mail about closure of their bug. If they want to reopen it later they don't know

Re: [VOTE] Move to Jira (Was: Re: Jira or Bugzilla...)

2005-10-12 Thread Jorg Heymans
Pier Fumagalli wrote: Ok, there we go, here's the vote... call me old fashioned but i like bugzilla. For some reason we are not able to maximize on its features while projects more complex than Cocoon obviously are. In the end I guess i'm in favour of anything that will get us to care more

[VOTE] Move to Jira (Was: Re: Jira or Bugzilla...)

2005-10-11 Thread Pier Fumagalli
Ok, there we go, here's the vote... [ ] +1 Yes please, let's move all our bugs to Jira and set it up to work in the following way: Statuses (workflow running accordingly): - OPEN - REOPENED - CLOSED - WAITING FOR FEEDBACK

Re: [VOTE] Move to Jira (Was: Re: Jira or Bugzilla...)

2005-10-11 Thread Leszek Gawron
Pier Fumagalli wrote: Ok, there we go, here's the vote... [X] +1 Yes please, let's move all our bugs to Jira and set it up to work in the following way: Statuses (workflow running accordingly): - OPEN - REOPENED - CLOSED -

Re: [VOTE] Move to Jira (Was: Re: Jira or Bugzilla...)

2005-10-11 Thread Carsten Ziegeler
Pier Fumagalli wrote: Ok, there we go, here's the vote... [X] +1 Yes please, let's move all our bugs to Jira and set it up to work in the following way: Carsten -- Carsten Ziegeler - Open Source Group, SN AG http://www.s-und-n.de http://www.osoco.org/weblogs/rael/

Re: [VOTE] Move to Jira (Was: Re: Jira or Bugzilla...)

2005-10-11 Thread Ralph Goers
Pier Fumagalli wrote: Ok, there we go, here's the vote... [ ] +1 Yes please, let's move all our bugs to Jira and set it up to work in the following way: Statuses (workflow running accordingly): - OPEN - REOPENED - CLOSED

Re: [VOTE] Move to Jira (Was: Re: Jira or Bugzilla...)

2005-10-11 Thread Ugo Cei
Il giorno 11/ott/05, alle ore 12:43, Pier Fumagalli ha scritto: [X] +1 Yes please, let's move all our bugs to Jira and set it up to work in the following way: Ugo -- Ugo Cei Tech Blog: http://agylen.com/ Open Source Zone: http://oszone.org/ Wine Food Blog:

Re: [VOTE] Move to Jira (Was: Re: Jira or Bugzilla...)

2005-10-11 Thread Reinhard Poetz
Pier Fumagalli wrote: Ok, there we go, here's the vote... [X] +1 Yes please, let's move all our bugs to Jira and set it up to work in the following way: Cocoon Part: - Sitemap components - Generic components - Components and Roles

Re: [VOTE] Move to Jira (Was: Re: Jira or Bugzilla...)

2005-10-11 Thread Pier Fumagalli
On 11 Oct 2005, at 14:03, Reinhard Poetz wrote: Pier Fumagalli wrote: Ok, there we go, here's the vote... [X] +1 Yes please, let's move all our bugs to Jira and set it up to work in the following way: Cocoon Part: - Sitemap components - Generic

Re: [VOTE] Move to Jira (Was: Re: Jira or Bugzilla...)

2005-10-11 Thread Gianugo Rabellino
On 10/11/05, Pier Fumagalli [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Ok, there we go, here's the vote... [ ] +1 Yes please, let's move all our bugs to Jira and set it up to work in the following way: +1 Ciao, -- Gianugo

Re: [VOTE] Move to Jira (Was: Re: Jira or Bugzilla...)

2005-10-11 Thread hepabolu
Gianugo Rabellino wrote: On 10/11/05, Pier Fumagalli [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Ok, there we go, here's the vote... [ ] +1 Yes please, let's move all our bugs to Jira and set it up to work in the following way: +1 +1 Helma

Re: [VOTE] Move to Jira (Was: Re: Jira or Bugzilla...)

2005-10-11 Thread David Crossley
Pier Fumagalli wrote: Ok, there we go, here's the vote... 0 ... i don't care which issue tracking system we use. -David

Re: [VOTE] Move to Jira (Was: Re: Jira or Bugzilla...)

2005-10-11 Thread Joerg Heinicke
Pier Fumagalli pier at betaversion.org writes: [X] -1 No, I want to keep using Bugzilla because ... I'm much more used to it. But I will probably also learn to use Jira if the community decides to switch, what it looks like at the moment. Jörg

Re: [VOTE] Move to Jira (Was: Re: Jira or Bugzilla...)

2005-10-11 Thread Vadim Gritsenko
Pier Fumagalli wrote: Ok, there we go, here's the vote... [ ] +1 Yes please, let's move all our bugs to Jira and set it up to work in the following way: +0.5 :-) My take on parts: Cocoon Part: - Java Classes - Generic Components -