Re: [EVDL] Do EVs make green sense?

2023-01-11 Thread Lee Hart via EV
Mark Laity-Snyder via EV wrote: John,  YOU ROCK dude! That is hardcore. I guess it makes sense though if you are living in a city.  I have been out in the sticks for too long and have gotten used to having to commute. I also totally agree with our Fearful leader/servant Dave when he says -

Re: [EVDL] Do EVs make green sense?

2023-01-11 Thread Mark Laity-Snyder via EV
John,  YOU ROCK dude! That is hardcore. I guess it makes sense though if you are living in a city.  I have been out in the sticks for too long and have gotten used to having to commute. I also totally agree with our Fearful leader/servant Dave when he says - EVs can be zero energy if you have

Re: [EVDL] Do EVs make green sense?

2023-01-06 Thread John McIntire via EV
There is no such thing as an environmentally friendly "green" automobile. ICEV, EV or something in between, they are all detrimental to life on earth. Like ice cream, just pick your favorite flavor and go with it. >From my perspective of 40 years as a mechanic certified by ASE repairing cars,

Re: [EVDL] Do EVs make green sense?

2023-01-06 Thread EV List Lackey via EV
These EV naysayers are eternal. They were around when I first started following EVs around 1967, they were a plague in the 1990s when they attacked the GM Impact (notably the infamous Carnegie-Mellon lead study), and they're still spreading their lying, agenda-driven propaganda today.

Re: [EVDL] Do EVs make green sense?

2023-01-05 Thread Steves via EV
Well then he’s wrong about solar panels. I went to a talk years back by Steven Chu who had headed up the department of Energy. Many interesting, candid, anecdotes, but, specifically, on PV he said how everyone was complaining that China was competing with us on panels due to low labor costs in

Re: [EVDL] Do EVs make green sense?

2023-01-05 Thread Peter Gabrielsson via EV
He's definitely interesting to listen to but keep in mind that he is selling a book or 3. His analysis seems a bit simplistic but makes for great sound bites. In one video he claims solar panels will get more expensive due to labor cost increasing, and according to him you just can't automate

Re: [EVDL] Do EVs make green sense?

2023-01-05 Thread Michael Ross via EV
*"Where do you think these idiots get their information about how much energy it takes to build a car...or the "carbon footprint"? * I know that people do try hard to put this sort of data in order and analyze it. In the case of prominent geographers and demographers they have teams of

Re: [EVDL] Do EVs make green sense?

2023-01-05 Thread Steves via EV
I agree - I can’t imagine a huge difference between cars, unless perhaps it is one of the newer cars that is designed to be low c02 in manufacturing and highly recyclable. Even then I wonder how much better they are. Let’s face it, the only ‘green’ car is the one that is not built. -Steve >

Re: [EVDL] Do EVs make green sense?

2023-01-05 Thread Lawrence Winiarski via EV
Where do you think these idiots get their information about how much energy it takes to build a car...or the "carbon footprint"?   If you are actually trying to measure "energy" you need to be able to isolate what you are actually measuring. Where do you draw the line about how much energy

Re: [EVDL] Do EVs make green sense?

2023-01-05 Thread Peter C. Thompson via EV
On 1/4/23 1:35 PM, John Lussmyer via EV wrote: Just one of the many issues to point out: On 1/4/2023 12:29 PM, Michael Ross via EV wrote: The carbon footprint of Teslas is not good when you correctly factor in the manufacturing footprint. Do the same calcs for a Gas car - which makes the EV

Re: [EVDL] Do EVs make green sense?

2023-01-05 Thread Lee Hart via EV
Michael Ross via EV wrote: I am trying to understand if Zeihan has an agenda... what does it take to make the unique aluminum alloy that Tesla has crafted to make body parts that are not steel... certainly the availability of lithium is not good. Nor is it good for cobalt, or nickel... if

Re: [EVDL] Do EVs make green sense?

2023-01-05 Thread paul dove via EV
Tesla didn't invent using aluminum and they are not the only ones. https://www.motortrend.com/features/15-automotive-aluminum- warriors/ Money is what drives the world. If people are buying EV's they will solve all the problems to provide a product. On Thursday, January 5, 2023 at

Re: [EVDL] Do EVs make green sense?

2023-01-05 Thread Michael Ross via EV
I am trying to understand if Zeihan has an agenda. His expertise is understanding geography and demographics. Knowing what ingredients go into making the world go around, and details like, what does it take to make the unique aluminum alloy that Tesla has crafted to make body parts that are not

Re: [EVDL] Do EVs make green sense?

2023-01-04 Thread (-Phil-) via EV
Zeihan seems spot on with most of his information, and I listen to him often, but he doesn't know everything. He posits that Teslas are only status symbols and there are superior EVs on the market. The Vinfast SUV that's somewhere close to 50% the range of a Model Y is telling. I've spent a lot

Re: [EVDL] Do EVs make green sense?

2023-01-04 Thread Steves via EV
Haven’t read the article, but perhaps he assumes virgin aluminum, which is very energy intensive. However even if virgin aluminum is used, 90% of big scrap (like car) aluminum is recycled, so that energy is essentially reclaimed out the back end. One has to read this kind of stuff very

Re: [EVDL] Do EVs make green sense?

2023-01-04 Thread Michael Ross via EV
Zeihan says ICE looks a lot better and leans on the aluminum in the Tesla bodywork. I wonder about this, but don't know how to evaluate it. On Wed, Jan 4, 2023 at 4:36 PM John Lussmyer via EV wrote: > Just one of the many issues to point out: > > On 1/4/2023 12:29 PM, Michael Ross via EV wrote:

Re: [EVDL] Do EVs make green sense?

2023-01-04 Thread John Lussmyer via EV
Just one of the many issues to point out: On 1/4/2023 12:29 PM, Michael Ross via EV wrote: The carbon footprint of Teslas is not good when you correctly factor in the manufacturing footprint. Do the same calcs for a Gas car - which makes the EV look far better.

[EVDL] Do EVs make green sense?

2023-01-04 Thread Michael Ross via EV
That subject is a bit of a troll, but I would like to have some conversation about whether EVs really make green sense or even profitable manufacturing sense. This is a short YouTube video by Peter Zeihan. Entitled EV's Not-so-little Dirty Secret(s) https://youtu.be/Qf85EuQKWeQ or search on