Re: [Finale] [OT] plural of rubato = rubati?

2011-03-25 Thread Giovanni Andreani
In Italian rubato is indeed a past participle of the verb rubare, which means stolen. However, as a musical term, here in Italy, it is not treated as a verb and not pluralized, the same way one wouldn't pluralize glissando, rallentando, allegro, moderato, etc. Nouns like instrument names are

Re: [Finale] [OT] plural of rubato = rubati?

2011-03-25 Thread Darcy James Argue
Hi Jef, If you expect consistency from language, you'll be constantly disappointed. In English, we regularize foreign loan-words unless we belong to a lexical community which puts a premium on using the appropriate foreign endings, as a kind of status-within-the-group signifier. (Classical

Re: [Finale] [OT] plural of rubato = rubati?

2011-03-25 Thread Mark D Lew
On Mar 24, 2011, at 7:44 PM, Darcy James Argue wrote: Regularization of foreign loan-words happens over time regardless of lexical category. Irregular forms have to be in frequent use and/ or have to signify status within a lexical community in order to be preserved -- which is why, for

Re: [Finale] [OT] plural of rubato = rubati?

2011-03-25 Thread Andrew Levin
Darcy wrote: Even 20 years ago, celli was not uncommon It was about twenty years ago (OK, 30) that I played under a conductor for whom English was *not* his first language, though he was quite competent in it. He would often look to his right and ask something of the cellis. :-) Andrew Levin

Re: [Finale] [OT] plural of rubato = rubati?

2011-03-25 Thread John Howell
At 10:06 AM -0700 3/25/11, Mark D Lew wrote: Alumnus and syllabus mean in English roughly the same as what they meant in Latin. As do the feminine alumna and the plural alumni, which are still universally used and understood. Syllabi is commonly used in the academy, although it ALMOST

Re: [Finale] [OT] plural of rubato = rubati?

2011-03-25 Thread Christopher Smith
On Fri Mar 25, at FridayMar 25 12:24 PM, Darcy James Argue wrote: Even 20 years ago, celli was not uncommon, but now only the insufferably pretentious would use that term. I dunno, I hear conductors say, Violas and celli all the time, which makes me giggle at the inconsistency. But maybe

[Finale] Re: [OT] plural of rubato = rubati?

2011-03-25 Thread gplwf9j
Adding, hu geeb uh fahk? Expletives deleted, isn't it time we moved beyond the egotistical false pride of insisting that expressions be in Italian? Or that dynamics be in abbreviated Italian with extended greater than or less than signs? This is not an attack on the Italians or on time-honored

Re: [Finale] Re: [OT] plural of rubato = rubati?

2011-03-25 Thread Lawrence Yates
Yes it's about communication - we could all use our own languages and that would communicate well to those who speak our language but what about those who don't speak our language? Maybe we could invent a new language that we could all learn so that we could all understand all the instructions?

Re: [Finale] Re: [OT] plural of rubato = rubati?

2011-03-25 Thread Christopher Smith
On Fri Mar 25, at FridayMar 25 5:37 PM, gplw...@letterboxes.org wrote: isn't it time we moved beyond the egotistical false pride of insisting that expressions be in Italian? Or that dynamics be in abbreviated Italian with extended greater than or less than signs? I don't happen to think

RE: [Finale] [OT] plural of rubato = rubati?

2011-03-25 Thread dalvin boone
John, I disagree. RO-dee-oh is an American pronunciation of a Spanish (Mexican) word. There are many examples of such borrowed words that are not commonly pronounced as they would be in Mexico or Spain: Animas as in the Animas River; Santa Fe, Santa Rosa, Amarillo, Lamesa, Tucumcari, chile

Re: [Finale] [OT] plural of rubato = rubati?

2011-03-25 Thread MSO
I would have to agree with Dalvin re: the pronunciation of RO-dee-oh. There's nothing ignorant about it. Y'ever been out west? Regional pronunciation does not connote ignorance; after all: the word has been virtually re-defined as a uniquely Western US event over a century-and-a-half. Not

Re: [Finale] [OT] plural of rubato = rubati?

2011-03-25 Thread Aaron Rabushka
...but it is sometimes neVAYduh, MO (with either mizzuREE or mizzurUH trailing along) Aaron J. Rabushka arabus...@austin.rr.com - Original Message - From: MSO m...@sti.net To: finale@shsu.edu Sent: Friday, March 25, 2011 9:16 PM Subject: Re: [Finale] [OT] plural of rubato = rubati?