Re: 3 floppy system for -current releases

2002-08-20 Thread John Hay
This has been committed already, but I'll answer your questions. If you are unhappy with anything, go ahead and change it. At the end I thought it more usefull to have snapshots that complete the building process, than ones that don't. People can test and give feedback on something that exists. >

RE: 3 floppy system for -current releases

2002-08-20 Thread John Baldwin
On 08-Aug-2002 John Hay wrote: > Here is a try at a 3 floppy system. Most people should be able to > install with the first 2 floppies (kern.flp and mfsroot.flp). Just > those that need a driver on the third floppy (drivers.flp) will > need it. > > If this idea is acceptable, we should probably

Re: 3 floppy system for -current releases

2002-08-09 Thread Bob Bishop
Hi, >I think MSDOS installs are pretty rare and NFS ones even rarer (FTP is >easier to setup) > >Survey time! :) I use NFS installs a lot, both with floppies and with pxeboot'd sysinstall. I've never had much luck with FTP installs from a remote server. -- Bob Bishop +44 (

Re: 3 floppy system for -current releases

2002-08-08 Thread Terry Lambert
John Hay wrote: > > > Why?? I disagree. CD9600 can go to the 3rd floppy -- if I am installing > > > from floppy's I am 99.9% chance doing a network install. [ ... ] > Calm down and relax. Which part of my patch removed support for > anything that might be needed during the install? > > ... We

Re: 3 floppy system for -current releases

2002-08-08 Thread Matthew D. Fuller
On Fri, Aug 09, 2002 at 07:20:53AM +0200 I heard the voice of John Hay, and lo! it spake thus: > > I'm wondering if that was because something in our stack was bust or > because of some firewall or other network thing? I'm not sure. This was 4.6.1-RC2, across a local 100mbps LAN. The FTP server

Re: 3 floppy system for -current releases

2002-08-08 Thread Daniel O'Connor
On Fri, 2002-08-09 at 14:50, John Hay wrote: > So should I commit the code and let us tune what go on which floppy > later or should I just sit back and enjoy the ride? I'm not worried > too much because the snaps on ftp.za.freebsd.org is working again. > :-) ... Yes they are non-standard (they us

Re: 3 floppy system for -current releases

2002-08-08 Thread John Hay
Hi Terry, > > Why?? I disagree. CD9600 can go to the 3rd floppy -- if I am installing > > from floppy's I am 99.9% chance doing a network install. > > I have an idea... > > If you only support installing via whatever option wins a vote > as The One True Way, then there'll be a 100% chance tha

Re: 3 floppy system for -current releases

2002-08-08 Thread John Hay
> > > I think MSDOS installs are pretty rare and NFS ones even rarer (FTP is > > > easier to setup) > > > > I've had one recent example here where FTP wouldn't work, but NFS flew. > > Weird but I can appreciate it's possible. I'm wondering if that was because something in our stack was bust or

Re: 3 floppy system for -current releases

2002-08-08 Thread Daniel O'Connor
On Fri, 2002-08-09 at 14:15, Terry Lambert wrote: > David O'Brien wrote: > > Why?? I disagree. CD9600 can go to the 3rd floppy -- if I am installing > > from floppy's I am 99.9% chance doing a network install. > > I have an idea... > > If you only support installing via whatever option wins a

Re: 3 floppy system for -current releases

2002-08-08 Thread Daniel O'Connor
On Fri, 2002-08-09 at 14:25, Matthew D. Fuller wrote: > > I think MSDOS installs are pretty rare and NFS ones even rarer (FTP is > > easier to setup) > > I've had one recent example here where FTP wouldn't work, but NFS flew. Weird but I can appreciate it's possible. I wasn't suggesting removin

Re: 3 floppy system for -current releases

2002-08-08 Thread Matthew D. Fuller
On Fri, Aug 09, 2002 at 02:12:33PM +0930 I heard the voice of Daniel O'Connor, and lo! it spake thus: > > I think MSDOS installs are pretty rare and NFS ones even rarer (FTP is > easier to setup) I've had one recent example here where FTP wouldn't work, but NFS flew. -- Matthew Fuller (M

Re: 3 floppy system for -current releases

2002-08-08 Thread Terry Lambert
David O'Brien wrote: > Why?? I disagree. CD9600 can go to the 3rd floppy -- if I am installing > from floppy's I am 99.9% chance doing a network install. I have an idea... If you only support installing via whatever option wins a vote as The One True Way, then there'll be a 100% chance that th

Re: 3 floppy system for -current releases

2002-08-08 Thread Daniel O'Connor
On Fri, 2002-08-09 at 13:59, David O'Brien wrote: > Why?? I disagree. CD9600 can go to the 3rd floppy -- if I am installing > from floppy's I am 99.9% chance doing a network install. NFSCLIENT > definitely should be on the 1st or 2nd, not 3rd floppy -- again because I > am most likely doing a n

Re: 3 floppy system for -current releases

2002-08-08 Thread David O'Brien
On Thu, Aug 08, 2002 at 08:27:15PM +0300, Ruslan Ermilov wrote: > > +CD9660 cd9660 3 options "ISO 9660 Filesystem" > > +MSDOSFSmsdosfs 3 options "MSDOS filsystem" > > +NFSCLIENT nfsclient 3 options "Network Filesystem Client" > > SYSVSHMsysvsh

Re: 3 floppy system for -current releases

2002-08-08 Thread Michael C. Wu
On Thu, Aug 08, 2002 at 06:32:40PM +0200, John Hay scribbled: | Here is a try at a 3 floppy system. Most people should be able to | install with the first 2 floppies (kern.flp and mfsroot.flp). Just | those that need a driver on the third floppy (drivers.flp) will | need it. | | If this idea is a

Re: 3 floppy system for -current releases

2002-08-08 Thread Terry Lambert
Maxim Sobolev wrote: > > But then everyone needs to boot with 3 floppies. With my way, we can > > hopefully select the optimum so that most people will only need 2 > > floppies, ie the most popular drivers should go on mfsroot.flp. > > Both approaches have its own advantages and disadvantages. IM

Re: 3 floppy system for -current releases

2002-08-08 Thread John Hay
Ruslan, Here is my latest version. It has all the changes you requested and a fix for the case where there isn't a third floppy. John -- John Hay -- [EMAIL PROTECTED] / [EMAIL PROTECTED] Index: usr.sbin/sysinstall/system.c === RC