Re: [geo] Re: for Geoe E group Bright Water the movie

2011-04-27 Thread Stephen Salter
Hi All Michael Hayes asks about how bubbles could be deployed. One possibility would be for a pair of wind-driven vessels to sail side by side at, say, a kilometre separation, attached to each other by a buoyant, streamlined tether. The chord of the tether would be about 100 mm. In plan

Re: [geo] Re: for Geoe E group Bright Water the movie

2011-04-27 Thread Andrew Lockley
Stephen, This technology is already used for towing hydrophone streamers in geophys, but it doesn't work quite like you suggest. There's no need for two boats, and instead there's a paid of towed hydrofoils behind one boat, with the support line tensioned between them. The low mass of the

Re: [geo] Re: for Geoe E group Bright Water the movie

2011-04-27 Thread Michael Hayes
Thank you both for the insight. Yes, I do now recall the dual boat tether concept and I have some working back ground in towing a long array of gear. From a pilot's point of view, I can see an advantage of the dual boat/tether over the towed array. In that, turning would be easier as well as

Re: [geo] Re: for Geoe E group Bright Water the movie

2011-04-27 Thread Mike MacCracken
Another approach to the bubble generation effort, and one Russell has suggested, is to take advantage of existing ships (of order 1000 to 10,000 commercial ships at sea on a given day) and to put bubble generators on them‹perhaps doing so in a way that reduces their hull friction to make up for

Re: [geo] Re: for Geoe E group Bright Water the movie

2011-04-27 Thread Michael Hayes
I have played with the idea of designing a prop which incorporates ultrasonic cavities to produce bright water. But, the modeling is beyond my capabilities. If it can be shown to the boat owners that such a prop would generate more thrust by breaking up the cohesion of the water just forward of

Re: [geo] Re: for Geoe E group Bright Water the movie

2011-04-27 Thread Stephen Salter
Andrew I did think about paravanes on a single ship as you suggest but thought that we could avoid the drag of the paravane by making two systems as long as the paravane that you would have chosen, joining them together and throwing away the two paravanes. Two boats is OK if the wake is

Re: [geo] Re: for Geoe E group Bright Water the movie

2011-04-27 Thread Andrew Lockley
Hi Stephen I think your concerns about pumping energies are misplaced. The mass of air pumped would be pretty low as the bubbles are so small, so there won't be big displacements, frictional losses, etc. My guess is that the energy to overcome ship drag and the energy to form the bubbles will

Re: [geo] Re: for Geoe E group Bright Water the movie

2011-04-27 Thread Michael Hayes
Here is a short overview article which points to a possible use for bright water if a long lasting variant can be developed. Agulhas leakage fueled by global warming could stabilize Atlantic overturning circulation: study

Re: [geo] Re: for Geoe E group Bright Water the movie

2011-04-27 Thread Michael Hayes
I ask for your patients! -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups geoengineering group. To post to this group, send email to geoengineering@googlegroups.com. To unsubscribe from this group, send email to geoengineering+unsubscr...@googlegroups.com. For more

Re: [geo] Re: for Geoe E group Bright Water the movie

2011-04-27 Thread Michael Hayes
Sorry, the message did not send right. Let me try it again. Here is a patent concerning a possible means for producing Stable (long life) Bright Water. http://www.patents.com/us-5531980.html http://www.patents.com/us-5531980.htmlHere are key passages; 'The tensides or surfactants which are

Re: [geo] Re: for Geoe E group Bright Water the movie

2011-04-26 Thread Michael Hayes
Please help me understand the mechanics of Bright Water deployment. I have spent many months living on the Bering Sea (in winter) and have piloted 150ft fishing vessels in that area for countless hours. I have watched the sea continually produce white caps for as far as I could see for days and

Re: [geo] Re: for Geoe E group Bright Water the movie

2011-04-18 Thread John Nissen
Hi Mike and Andrew, This is an interesting discussion. What about *direct* cooling of the ESAS (East Siberian Arctic Shelf - which includes the East Siberian Sea), to try to reduce methane emissions? We have to consider all possible methods of reducing emissions here, since there is enough

Re: [geo] Re: for Geoe E group Bright Water the movie

2011-04-18 Thread Andrew Lockley
I agree. This is an ideal area to test bright water, as it is isolated and traditionally ice covered. It's also possibly ideal for sulphate aerosols (due to the low tropopause and short residency time for particulates as a result of the brewer dobson circulation). However, it is not certain that

Re: [geo] Re: for Geoe E group Bright Water the movie

2011-04-17 Thread Andrew Lockley
mmacc...@comcast.net *Date:* April 16, 2011 8:37:24 PM MDT *To:* Geoengineering Geoengineering@googlegroups.com *Cc:* Russell Seitz (2) russellse...@gmail.com *Subject:* *Re: [geo] Re: for Geoe E group Bright Water the movie* *Reply-To:* mmacc...@comcast.netmmacc...@comcast.net Hi Andrew—On your

Re: [geo] Re: for Geoe E group Bright Water the movie

2011-04-17 Thread Mike MacCracken
) russellse...@gmail.com Subject: Re: [geo] Re: for Geoe E group Bright Water the movie Reply-To: mailto:mmacc...@comcast.net mmacc...@comcast.net Hi Andrew‹On your objection about the biology of bright water, I¹d like to better understand your concern. How do you think the effect of the bubbles

Re: [geo] Re: for Geoe E group Bright Water the movie

2011-04-17 Thread rongretlarson
@googlegroups.com, Russell Seitz russellse...@gmail.com Sent: Sunday, April 17, 2011 2:01:37 AM Subject: Re: [geo] Re: for Geoe E group Bright Water the movie Hi Thanks for the +ve reception to my comments. @Mike: Sometimes numeric analysis is the best way to investigate, and sometimes it's not. I

[geo] Re: for Geoe E group Bright Water the movie

2011-04-16 Thread Andrew Lockley
Russell, My comments below relate to your 'brightwater' proposal. Out of courtesy, I've removed the thread - so I'm not re-posting your comments without consent. If bubble residency times are high, induced densities can be low. If residency times are low, you'll have to greatly increase local

Re: [geo] Re: for Geoe E group Bright Water the movie

2011-04-16 Thread Ron Larson
Sent from my iPad On Apr 16, 2011, at 8:37 PM, Mike MacCracken mmacc...@comcast.net wrote: Hi Andrew—On your objection about the biology of bright water, I’d like to better understand your concern. How do you think the effect of the bubbles on a clear day would compare to the effects of a

Re: [geo] Re: for Geoe E group Bright Water the movie

2011-04-16 Thread rongretlarson
Geoengineering@googlegroups.com Cc: Russell Seitz (2) russellse...@gmail.com Subject: Re: [geo] Re: for Geoe E group Bright Water the movie Reply-To: mmacc...@comcast.net Hi Andrew—On your objection about the biology of bright water, I’d like to better understand your concern. How do you

[geo] Re: for Geoe E group Bright Water the movie

2011-04-15 Thread Andrew Lockley
To clarify my comments, as asked: I don't doubt that the technique is possible, but I am not convinced of its practicality or ecosystem impact. A localized change in albedo may have serious consequences for ecosystems, and the less long lived the bubbles are, the more expensive the process and