Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-28 Thread Rod Hynes
On Wed, Feb 26, 2014 at 1:07 PM, Sahar Massachi sa...@brandeis.edu wrote: For those of us who aren't hip to the latest developments in Psiphon or circumvention - is there an easy primer as to how Psiphon works, and is different from traditional VPN's? The best I could find was this design

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-26 Thread Adam Fisk
I just wanted to quickly add my strong support for the notion that having a variety of tools is essential to this fight. Lantern's up and running in Iran and China right now, for example, but that could change at any moment, and users need alternatives. China dropped the hammer on us on Dec 12th I

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-25 Thread Adam Pritchard
I thought I should chime in with some info about Psiphon's recent blockage in Iran... On February 14, we had about 840K Android + 620K Windows unique users (on that day; the total for the preceding week was about 3m, as Collin said). This is almost the high water mark for us. On February 15, we

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-25 Thread Griffin Boyce
Adam Pritchard wrote: I would advise against getting too comfortable/confident/hubristic... One might not want to suggest that one is unblockable. I like Tor a lot, but obviously nothing is unblockable. Iran's targeting of Tor around the attempted revolution is but one data point -- every

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-25 Thread Fereidoon Bashar
I would actually argue against that, at least with Iranian users, rely on one particular tool. From what we have seen from our many communications with users, they rely and use any number of tools they can get their hands on and their choice is dependent on which one works better on a given day.

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-25 Thread Sahar Massachi
For those of us who aren't hip to the latest developments in Psiphon or circumvention - is there an easy primer as to how Psiphon works, and is different from traditional VPN's? The best I could find was this design document:

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-25 Thread Collin Anderson
On Sun, Feb 23, 2014 at 9:43 AM, Nathan of Guardian nat...@guardianproject.info wrote: That is the reason I promote Tor. It is 100% free, run by volunteers, doesn't require a credit card or registered account, and has group of Farsi-literate community support staff (like Nima) ready to help.

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-25 Thread Andrew Lewman
On Tue, Feb 25, 2014 at 03:41:09PM -0500, a.pritch...@psiphon.ca wrote 7.6K bytes in 0 lines about: : So, yeah, Iran dropped the hammer on us. Welcome to the club! ;) -- Andrew pgp 0x6B4D6475 -- Liberationtech is public archives are searchable on Google. Violations of list guidelines will

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-25 Thread Andrew Lewman
On Tue, Feb 25, 2014 at 04:18:17PM -0500, grif...@cryptolab.net wrote 1.3K bytes in 0 lines about: : replacement. This feels like a user education issue. Users need to : know that there are multiple options -- eg when Psiphon works but : Lantern doesn't, or when Tor with a bridge doesn't

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-25 Thread Collin Anderson
On Tue, Feb 25, 2014 at 5:38 PM, Andrew Lewman liberationt...@lewman.uswrote: Idle curiosity, what percent of Iranian Internet users use a proxy (or don't go naked on the Internet)? 1%? 5%? 50%? I tend to cite the Iranian chief of police's about 20 to 30 percent of (Iranian internet) users

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-25 Thread Nathan of Guardian
On 02/25/2014 04:42 PM, Fereidoon Bashar wrote: Here is one example of an Iranian Android user's list of tools https://twitter.com/2iitter/status/435499775971328001 That's an amazing tweet and image. Many thanks for sharing. -- Liberationtech is public archives are searchable on Google.

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-25 Thread Nathan of Guardian
On 02/25/2014 03:41 PM, Adam Pritchard wrote: One might not want to suggest that one is unblockable. One does not simply suggest, that one is unblockable... I was more referring to my own personal experience working within the Tor community, and their human+organizational response to

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-23 Thread Amin Sabeti
​Guys, we are talking about massive audience not activists or journalists! I believe we should care more about massive audience not activists because they can find someone to help them. For instance, they have lots of friends outside the country to buy VPN or other commercial circumvention tools

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-23 Thread Nathan of Guardian
On February 23, 2014 2:11:26 AM EST, Collin Anderson col...@averysmallbird.com wrote: On Sat, Feb 22, 2014 at 9:35 PM, Nathan of Guardian nat...@guardianproject.info wrote: I just hope that the Tor is slow meme, along with other famous ones like PGP is hard and No one cares about privacy,

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-23 Thread Andrés Leopoldo Pacheco Sanfuentes
Right on the money, Nathan! There was a time when the web browser was considered a thin-client alternative to fat client-server apps. Unfortunately, not anymore! But there's hope on the mobile web, with its proliferation of apps with better bandwidth-aware features. On the other hand, the Tor

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-23 Thread Nathan of Guardian
On February 23, 2014 8:30:25 AM EST, Amin Sabeti aminsab...@gmail.com wrote: ​Guys, we are talking about massive audience not activists or journalists! I believe we should care more about massive audience not activists because they can find someone to help them. For instance, they have lots of

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-23 Thread Andrew Lewman
On Sun, Feb 23, 2014 at 01:30:25PM +, aminsab...@gmail.com wrote 6.9K bytes in 0 lines about: : don't care about NSA/ GCHQ surveillance. : : It would be better to think as a general user not someone who is activist : and support freedom of expression. There are entire communities of users

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-23 Thread Andrew Lewman
On Sun, Feb 23, 2014 at 08:40:59AM -0600, alps6...@gmail.com wrote 10K bytes in 0 lines about: : On the other hand, the Tor web site is a bit too much smoke and mirrors : promoting it as a solution for the masses, when clearly it is not practical : for that use. Maybe Bill Gates gave them a

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-23 Thread Andrew Lewman
On Sun, Feb 23, 2014 at 02:11:26AM -0500, col...@averysmallbird.com wrote 3.4K bytes in 0 lines about: : download started out reasonably fast, after a few seconds it seems probably : that my connection was throttled down. Whereas without Tor, my throughput : averaged 84.81 Kbps, with it is

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-22 Thread Amin Sabeti
Hi, The important point that we must not forget is the first priority for users in Iran is access. It means users would like to check their FB Twitter accounts. Therefore, TOR is not feasible solution for them because they have not high speed internet connection. Cheers, A On 22 February

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-22 Thread Brian Conley
Amin, Do Iranians ever attempt checking the mobile versions of these sites? In my experience even in low bandwidth environments, if you are patient, the mobile sites work much better. Perhaps this is a combination of lack of awareness and lack of patience. I understand Iranian youth and folks

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-22 Thread Collin Anderson
Nariman, None of the tools are safe, since the users in question are finding servers and credentials through word of mouth and on public sites without attribution for where their data is going. Even if the other side is not malicious, I've seen a fair amount of those vendors require or encourage

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-22 Thread Nariman Gharib
Ok, I think I should explain more about this question and just Collin told me the answered which I looking for that. 1st the reason I didn't add Tor to the list , because I knew that already Tor is safe, BUT it isn't use widely in Iran, as Amin said, one of the problem is Internet Speed. Today I

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-22 Thread Amin Sabeti
On 22 February 2014 19:17, Brian Conley bri...@smallworldnews.tv wrote: Amin, Do Iranians ever attempt checking the mobile versions of these sites? In my experience even in low bandwidth environments, if you are patient, the mobile sites work much better. Unfortunately, TOR is famous as a

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-22 Thread Brian Conley
In-line Amin, Do Iranians ever attempt checking the mobile versions of these sites? In my experience even in low bandwidth environments, if you are patient, the mobile sites work much better. Unfortunately, TOR is famous as a slow tool in Iran! I haven't checked with users inside the

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-22 Thread Collin Anderson
On Sat, Feb 22, 2014 at 2:58 PM, Brian Conley bri...@smallworldnews.tvwrote: Sure, and for 25,000 users apparently Tor works at least some of the time. We need to understand why tor(and other products) work for these individuals why it doesn't work for others. This is the only way we can

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-22 Thread Nima Fatemi
Nariman Gharib: Today I asked my friend who works at Manoto Tv which is a popular satellite tv for Iranian based London, to they asked their audience on Facebook to test Tor... here the result ( in persian you can use google translate )

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-22 Thread A.Chukin
Nariman, this tool looks potentially useful and include enough configuration flexibility and obfuscation option. http://www.vpngate.net/en/ 23.02.2014 1:38, Nariman Gharib пишет: Ok, I think I should explain more about this question and just Collin told me the answered which I looking for

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-22 Thread Nathan of Guardian
On February 22, 2014 2:38:09 PM EST, Nariman Gharib nariman...@gmail.com wrote: Today I asked my friend who works at Manoto Tv which is a popular satellite tv for Iranian based London, to they asked their audience on Facebook to test Tor... here the result ( in persian you can use google

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-22 Thread Nariman Gharib
Nathan, Thanks about that. I just gave that link to users who didn't know how they can use the Orbot. For the link I'll talk to you directly. Cheers Nariman Sent from my iPhone On Feb 22, 2014, at 11:30 PM, Nathan of Guardian nat...@guardianproject.info wrote: On February 22, 2014

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-22 Thread Pranesh Prakash
Brian Conley bri...@smallworldnews.tv [2014-02-22 14:58:22]: Right, but let's not waste our time on people who don't want to help themselves or check for themselves and only believe rumors. Sure tor works slowly, but as Nathan pointed out, we have hard evidence that Iranians are using Tor:

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-22 Thread Brian Conley
Thanks Collin, my only point is that Tor *does work* inside Iran unless you can dispute those numbers. The only way we can build solutions is with hard evidence not anecdotes about things being slow or as others have bandied about users being only interested in speed or convenience. Clearly Tor

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-22 Thread Brian Conley
Pranesh, Solidarity and voluntary association are exactly about mutual agreements between partners. Aid is about disrespect of your partners believing they are weak and needy or from the other side believing they are bleeding hearts whom you can take advantage of. I'm not talking about top down

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-22 Thread Nathan of Guardian
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 On 02/22/2014 07:36 PM, Pranesh Prakash wrote: A 2012/2013 study by Robinson + Yu (albeit done on a very small sample) on Chinese Internet users showed that speed was amongst the biggest complaints and was the second most important factor while

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-22 Thread fred concklin
fteproxy might be worth looking at: https://fteproxy.org/about On Fri, Feb 21, 2014 at 8:59 PM, Nariman Gharib nariman...@gmail.comwrote: Hi, My name is Nariman Gharib. I'm a researcher in Iran Tech and social media based London. I'm helping Iranian people to bypass the censorship by

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-22 Thread Collin Anderson
On Sat, Feb 22, 2014 at 7:59 PM, Brian Conley bri...@smallworldnews.tvwrote: My goal is not to help every citizen who wants to look at cat videos or porn or share pictures of their lunch with their friends. Lovely. Amin and Nariman's goal seems to be making sure that Iranian public remains

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-22 Thread Nima Fatemi
Collin Anderson: More politely to my friends Nima and Nathan, I am averse to the fact that there is little willingness to engage in an 'if not Tor, then what else?' conversation. In part because in my experience without an answer to 'not-Tor,' people tend to end up in Hotspot Shield or

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-22 Thread Collin Anderson
On Sat, Feb 22, 2014 at 9:35 PM, Nathan of Guardian nat...@guardianproject.info wrote: I just hope that the Tor is slow meme, along with other famous ones like PGP is hard and No one cares about privacy, are continued to be challenged, tested and not accepted as inevitable. Certainly,

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-21 Thread Nima Fatemi
Nariman Gharib: so if anybody can help me to tell me which these tools in below are safe it would be great. I've double checked that Tor works just fine in Iran. This is for both vanilla (normal Tor Browser Bundle) and Pluggable Transports Bundle (including but not limited to obfsproxy).

Re: [liberationtech] Many VPNs and Psiphon are currently blocked in Iran right now

2014-02-21 Thread Nathan of Guardian
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 On 02/21/2014 09:54 PM, Nima Fatemi wrote: Nariman Gharib: so if anybody can help me to tell me which these tools in below are safe it would be great. I've double checked that Tor works just fine in Iran. This is for both vanilla (normal Tor