Korea Herald: Gap between richest, poorest widening

2000-09-09 Thread Stephen E Philion
Gap between richest, poorest widening Korea Herald 09/10/2000 by Cho Young-sam Staff reporter Adding fuel to concerns regarding a widening income gap, the National Statistical Office (NSO) reported yesterday that those in the top tenth percentile of income earners earned 9 times as much

Re: Re: Re: A slight advantage of poverty (was Re: Random thoughts on Big Brother, adv

2000-09-09 Thread Nestor Miguel Gorojovsky
En relación a [PEN-L:1475] Re: Re: A slight advantage of povert, el 8 Sep 00, a las 7:43, Jim Devine dijo: At 10:26 PM 09/07/2000 -0700, you wrote: --Governments that throw people out of helicopters into the South Atlantic have no business ruling anybody, let along waging war to increase

Re: Re: Hume the Postmodern Grin without a Cat(was Re: pomoistas)

2000-09-09 Thread Ted Winslow
Michael Hoover quotes Louse Antony on Hume: Hume's 'skeptical solution' to his own problem amounted to an abandonment of the externalist hopes of his time. Belief in induction, he concluded, was a custom, a tendency of mind ingrained by nature, one of a 'species of natural instincts, which

from SLATE: George W.'s slogan

2000-09-09 Thread Jim Devine
George W. Bush [one of the major candidates for the US presidency] just started campaigning under the banner of a new slogan, "Real Plans for Real People," the [Washington POST] notes. Today's Papers can't help but notice the similarity to the Beef Council's old slogan, "Real Food for Real

Re: Re: Imperialist progressivism (was Re: Thatcher and nationalism)

2000-09-09 Thread Nestor Miguel Gorojovsky
En relación a [PEN-L:1484] Re: Imperialist progressivism (was R, el 8 Sep 00, a las 9:16, Michael Perelman dijo: The debate on the Falklands/Malvinas is troubling. I thought the outcome meant that Thatcher triumphed politically, while the junta had to face political defeat, eventually.

Re: Re: Canada, Australia, Argentina

2000-09-09 Thread Nestor Miguel Gorojovsky
En relación a [PEN-L:1490] Re: Canada, Australia, Argentina, el 8 Sep 00, a las 10:22, Bill Burgess dijo: However, by the mid 1980s the US-controlled share of all non-financial industres in Canada declined to levels below the post-WW2 buildup (the US share has risen slightly since then, as

(Fwd) RV: SEAMOS LIBRES Y LO DEMÁS NO IMPORTA NADA

2000-09-09 Thread Nestor Miguel Gorojovsky
To gauge who San Martín (and Sergeant Cabral) were, I am sending a small quotation from an excellent Marxist biography of our Libertador, that has just appeared (this year we commemorate the 150th anniversary of his death in exile, exile due precisely to the same interests that made the Disco

Allende, copper, Chavez, oil, CIA

2000-09-09 Thread Nestor Miguel Gorojovsky
En relación a [PEN-L:1529] Re: Re: pomo or the economy?, el 8 Sep 00, a las 17:29, Michael Perelman dijo: On Democracy Now today, Juan Gonzalez suggested that the money for Colombia may be in part a preparation to "Allende" Chavez. Certainly. It is quite obviously thus. But this time they

RoboCop

2000-09-09 Thread Jim Devine
At 11:46 AM 09/09/2000 -0300, you wrote: Remember _Robocop_, I insist. A good movie, portraying a science fictional world in which Detroit's public services have been totally privatized. One of my favorite bits is when the TV news show ("give us three minutes and we'll give you the world")

Re: Re: Re: Canada, Australia, Argentina

2000-09-09 Thread Rob Schaap
Bill, Paul and Nestor are very much on to something, I think. Australia, too, consciously nourished its (relative) independence, largely through mutually constitutive ties between Australia's government and bourgeoisie - ensuring that the latter would not serve as a compradorial local elite for

Re: RoboCop

2000-09-09 Thread Rob Schaap
Sez Jim, The good news in RoboCop is that there's hope: another great scene has the ultra-high-tech robot trying to fight RoboCop (the good guy), almost winning, chasing our hero into the stair-well, where it turns out that the high-tech machine can't go down stairs! Not a new idea,

Economics and Literature

2000-09-09 Thread Ted Winslow
Wouldn't a truly scientific approach to economics include the study of literature as a source of insight into economic motivation? It seems to me that such study plays an important role in the economics of Marx and Keynes. Marx, for instance, often points to Shakespeare as a source of insight

Re: Re: Re: Hume the Postmodern Grin without a Cat(was Re: pomoistas)

2000-09-09 Thread Ken Hanly
By following custom or the tendency of mind whereof he speaks. Hume is not denying that he and everyone else uses induction, only that one cannot justify it in the way that some philosophers believe. The best we can do is explain it. It is hardly a "sceptical solution" but an explanation that

Re: Re: Re: Canada, Australia, Argentina

2000-09-09 Thread phillp2
Nestor and Bill, Let me reiterate my main point which I take you both would either agree with or at least accept as a reasonable argument. The first world war consolidated industrial capitalism in Canada and the governing elite was firmly under control of industrial capital which no longer

Re: Re: Re: Hume the Postmodern Grin without a Cat (was Re: po...

2000-09-09 Thread JKSCHW
In a message dated 9/9/00 10:46:42 AM Eastern Daylight Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: How could Hume reach this conclusion without employing induction? Oh, he admits--he insists!--that we cannot but employ it. He just thinks we cannot justify that employment in the face of his skeptical

Re: Economics and Literature

2000-09-09 Thread JKSCHW
In a message dated 9/9/00 12:53:40 PM Eastern Daylight Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Marx, for instance, often points to Shakespeare as a source of insight into capitalist motives in general and into the money-making and money-loving motives in particular. There is an excellent book by

Re: Re: Economics and Literature

2000-09-09 Thread Michael Perelman
One of the German professors here -- not a radical at all -- uses Marx as an example of the best in German writing -- not of medium grade. [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Marx is a medium rank master of the German language, not as great as Heine or Lessing, but in the neighborhood of Nietzsche.

Re: Re: Re: Re: anti-Pomo babble

2000-09-09 Thread Stephen Cullenberg
At 02:06 PM 9/8/00 -0400, you wrote: [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Yoshie, do you get extra hazard pay for reading these people? Are these people any worse than most of the economics literature, which is all too often obscure, abstract, remote from reality, and apologetics for the status quo? Doug

Re: Re: anti-Pomo babble

2000-09-09 Thread Louis Proyect
People might be interested to know that Jack Amariglio, David Ruccio and I have a forthcoming edited volume from Routledge on the topic Doug mentions. The book's title is _Postmodernism, Economics and Knowledge_ and includes contributions from a large number of folks who have written and

Re: Re: Economics and Literature

2000-09-09 Thread Doug Henwood
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Marx is a medium rank master of the German language, not as great as Heine or Lessing, but in the neighborhood of Nietzsche. Nietzsche is a wonderful read, at least in translation. What's with this "medium rank" business? Doug

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: anti-Pomo babble

2000-09-09 Thread Doug Henwood
Stephen Cullenberg wrote: While the book deals mainly with economics, folks might also be interested in another event where many people broadly influenced by postmodernism (and many who are not) will be coming together to discuss and debate Marxism. The Marxism 2000 conference sponsored by

Re: Re: Re: Re: Canada, Australia, Argentina

2000-09-09 Thread Nestor Miguel Gorojovsky
En relación a [PEN-L:1553] Re: Re: Re: Canada, Australia, Argen, el 9 Sep 00, a las 12:17, [EMAIL PROTECTED] dijo: Nestor and Bill, Let me reiterate my main point which I take you both would either agree with or at least accept as a reasonable argument. Dear Phillip, I do not consider

Re: Re: Re: Re: Hume the Postmodern Grin without aCat(was Re: pomoistas)

2000-09-09 Thread Ted Winslow
Ken Hanly wrote: Reason is not capable of really questioning induction since reason is powerless against such a natural instinct. How then is Hume able to question induction? Ted -- Ted WinslowE-MAIL: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Division of Social Science VOICE:

Re: Re: Re: Re: Canada, Australia, Argentina

2000-09-09 Thread Nestor Miguel Gorojovsky
En relación a [PEN-L:1553] Re: Re: Re: Canada, Australia, Argen, el 9 Sep 00, a las 12:17, [EMAIL PROTECTED] dijo: It is for this reason or in this context that I say the Canadian economy is dependent. And I agree that this is a very different form of dependency that Frank argues for

Re: Re: Re: Re: Canada, Australia, Argentina

2000-09-09 Thread Nestor Miguel Gorojovsky
En relación a [PEN-L:1549] Re: Re: Re: Canada, Australia, Argen, el 10 Sep 00, a las 3:37, Rob Schaap dijo: Australia, too, consciously nourished its (relative) independence, largely through mutually constitutive ties between Australia's government and bourgeoisie - ensuring that the latter

Re: Re: Re: anti-Pomo babble

2000-09-09 Thread Michael Perelman
Louis, you know better than to say something that is so provocative. Louis Proyect wrote: People might be interested to know that Jack Amariglio, David Ruccio and I have a forthcoming edited volume from Routledge on the topic Doug mentions. The book's title is _Postmodernism, Economics

autism and exchange-value

2000-09-09 Thread Brian Milani
Hello All, I'm Brian, a new PEN list reader in Toronto. Apologies for some digression--I've just gotten caught up reading the last week's digests. I'm certainly not opposed to pomo-bashing, but my greater concern is the economic autism discusssion. Without wanting to diminish

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Hume the Postmodern Grin without aCat(was Re: pomoistas)

2000-09-09 Thread Carrol Cox
Ted Winslow wrote: Ken Hanly wrote: Reason is not capable of really questioning induction since reason is powerless against such a natural instinct. How then is Hume able to question induction? This reason/passion/[appetite] metaphysics had its origins in Plato's attack on Athenian

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Hume the Postmodern Grin without aCat(was Re: pomoistas)

2000-09-09 Thread Ken Hanly
He doesn't really. He questions justifications of it. Cheers, Ken Hanly - Original Message - From: Ted Winslow [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Saturday, September 09, 2000 2:07 PM Subject: [PEN-L:1562] Re: Re: Re: Re: Hume the Postmodern Grin without aCat(was Re:

Re: Re: Economics and Literature

2000-09-09 Thread Jim Devine
At 01:54 PM 09/09/2000 -0400, you wrote: Marx is a medium rank master of the German language, not as great as Heine or Lessing, but in the neighborhood of Nietzsche. The canard that he is turgid and unreadable is just that, a duck. Marx's reputations as a turgid writer seems to arise from four

Re: pomo or the economy?

2000-09-09 Thread Jim Devine
At 01:11 AM 09/09/2000 +, you wrote: Will Goldilocks meet the Three Bears now, Jim D.? hey, inflation driven by high oil prices might be a _good_ thing, because it might prevent asset-price deflation and the resulting debt-deflation depression! Inflation is one way to get rid of

Re: autism and exchange-value

2000-09-09 Thread Jim Devine
Brian wrote: ... I think a big reason why there is such a feeling that economics itself is disembodied is the profession's overwhelming preoccupation with exchange-value as opposed to use-value. That is, economics tends to be more concerned with manipulating money than figuring out what the

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Hume the Postmodern Grin without aCat(was Re: pomoistas)

2000-09-09 Thread Jim Devine
At 03:31 PM 09/09/2000 -0500, you wrote: Going down the road of hyperbolic doubt gets you to the malevolent demon and deep questions about whether we might not all be brains in vats. I doubt these questions are of great practical use as preparation for socialist revolution. Isn't that the

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Hume the Postmodern Grin without aCat(was Re: pomoistas)

2000-09-09 Thread Ken Hanly
Well there is the historical hen who always ran out to greet the farmer and received generous amounts of chickenfeed, and using induction figured out that the appearance of the farmer meant chickenfeed. On this inductive basis the hen adopted the practice of rushiing out whenever the farmer

Response to Cullenberg, Amariglio, Ruccio introduction to Postmodernist Economics

2000-09-09 Thread Louis Proyect
CULLENBERG, AMARIGLIO, RUCCIO: "Jameson, it should be noted, is a devotee of the late Belgian Marxist economist, Ernest Mandel (1978), whose book on "late capitalism" serves as the veritable bible for those (mostly cultural critics) who are looking to describe and define, from the left,

Re: Re: Re: Economics and Literature

2000-09-09 Thread JKSCHW
In a message dated 9/9/00 2:28:49 PM Eastern Daylight Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: One of the German professors here -- not a radical at all -- uses Marx as an example of the best in German writing -- not of medium grade. The _best_ in German writing in Goethe, the only writer in

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Hume the Postmodern Grin without a Cat(was...

2000-09-09 Thread JKSCHW
In a message dated 9/9/00 3:15:11 PM Eastern Daylight Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Ken Hanly wrote: Reason is not capable of really questioning induction since reason is powerless against such a natural instinct. How then is Hume able to question induction? Ken misspeaks,

Postmodern Grin without a...

2000-09-09 Thread JKSCHW
In a message dated 9/9/00 5:05:33 PM Eastern Daylight Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Can't we dismiss all these questions about induction and epistemology and ontology in a pragmatic way, i.e., say that our doubts and skepticism are really irrelevant if they don't act as a guide to

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Hume the Postmodern Grinwithout a Cat(was...

2000-09-09 Thread Ted Winslow
Ken misspeaks, Reason can question, but the questioning does not disturb the deeply rooted force of habit that makes us accept induction. Reason is pretty weak, according to Hume, in the face of passion or habit. And was he wrong to think so? --jks If the answer to this question is no he

Re: Response to Cullenberg, Amariglio, Ruccio introduction to Postmodernist Economics

2000-09-09 Thread Jim Devine
Louis P. wrote: I have no idea what this is supposed to do with Marxism. Capitalism is constantly changing, but there is one constant: society is divided into classes; the struggle between classes is the locomotive of history. It doesn't matter particularly whether we are in a "Fordist" or

pragmatism

2000-09-09 Thread Jim Devine
[was: Re: [PEN-L:1574] Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Hume the Postmodern Grin without aCat(was Re: pomoistas) ] Ken wrote: Well there is the historical hen who always ran out to greet the farmer and received generous amounts of chickenfeed, and using induction figured out that the appearance

Re: Re: Response to Cullenberg, Amariglio, Ruccio introduction to Postmodernist Economics

2000-09-09 Thread Louis Proyect
C'mon Louis! Countless Marxists before the "postmodernists," including Lenin, have talked about how the form of capitalism has changed since its start. You may not agree that the distinction between the "Fordist" and "Post-Fordist" economy exists, but there must be something that

Re: Postmodern Grin without a...

2000-09-09 Thread Doug Henwood
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Thus Rorty. Sure, I said as much to Nicole. I was, after all, a student of Rorty's. But the questions keep coming back. Rorty himself cannot just escape them, or won't. If we were really staisfaied with this sort of pragmatic answer, we wouldn't care about the issues.

Re: Re: Postmodern Grin without a...

2000-09-09 Thread Louis Proyect
Forget that stuff. Forget reading. Hell, forget thinking. Better just to make leaflets. Doug Speaking as someone who composed leaflets for demonstrations against the war in Vietnam and against contra funding, I can assure Doug that this requires enormous intellectual concentration. He should

Re: Re: Postmodern Grin without a...

2000-09-09 Thread michael
Please, I already reprimanded Louis. I hope that this will not continue, although Louis's initial note was overly provocative. Forget that stuff. Forget reading. Hell, forget thinking. Better just to make leaflets. Doug -- Michael Perelman Economics Department California State

Leaflets (Re: Re: Re: Postmodern Grin without a...)

2000-09-09 Thread Nestor Miguel Gorojovsky
En relación a [PEN-L:1584] Re: Re: Postmodern Grin without a..., el 9 Sep 00, a las 19:31, Louis Proyect dijo: Forget that stuff. Forget reading. Hell, forget thinking. Better just to make leaflets. Doug Speaking as someone who composed leaflets for demonstrations against the war in

RE: Hume the Postmodern Grin without aCat(was Re: pomoistas)

2000-09-09 Thread Lisa Ian Murray
Do you think the folks who programmed the algorithms for all those special effects in the film were being pragmatists or platonists or constructivists with regards to induction etc.? Or were they merely wage labor? Ian At 03:31 PM 09/09/2000 -0500, you wrote: Going down the road of

Re: Leaflets

2000-09-09 Thread Michael Perelman
I recall after James Rector was killed during the People's Park uprising in Berkeley in the 1960s. Frank Bardake wrote a leaflet about the park that I still keep in my office. It was far more eloquent than any essay that I have seen. Nestor Miguel Gorojovsky wrote: Good leaflets are very

Re: Re: Leaflets

2000-09-09 Thread Nestor Miguel Gorojovsky
En relación a [PEN-L:1588] Re: Leaflets , el 9 Sep 00, a las 20:03, Carrol Cox dijo: Leaflet writing is in fact a literary specialty in its own right, strongly linked with journalism and editorializing. Good leaflets can be excellent editorials in a newspaper, and good editorials in a