Re: [EXTERNAL] Joining black carbon steel with stainless steel piping

2022-03-03 Thread AKS-Gmail-IMAP via Sprinklerforum
If you are coming up into a building with the water service to a double check the local potable water protection regulations typically do not allow black steel prior to the double check. I would have expected the majority of their unit installations to not connect to black steel piping. I bet

Re: Sprinkler in elevator pit.

2022-02-25 Thread AKS-Gmail-IMAP via Sprinklerforum
Wire cage elevators in industrial settings are often unenclosed. The original question, “What constitutes an “enclosed” shaft?”, I think is a question asking, “Is not a shaft enclosed by definition?”. That makes sense to me. In certain circumstances building codes require a shaft of specific

Re: 8 inch sprinkler pipe fall from factory ceiling

2022-02-24 Thread AKS-Gmail-IMAP via Sprinklerforum
The are lots of things interesting about this, including how long ago the event was, but in my opinion the description lacks some details and requires one to guess as to what the conditions were and to guess as to the piping arrangement, which of course is critical to this event since it is

Re: swimming pool

2022-02-04 Thread AKS-Gmail-IMAP via Sprinklerforum
That is the preferred way to set the AHJ agreement, in distributed meeting minutes of course, because the other way it may be set, “provide NFPA 13 coverage for the deck area only”, means some sprinklers have to be installed beyond the pool edge to satisfy the application density transition

Re: ESFR obstruction shift

2022-01-18 Thread AKS-Gmail-IMAP via Sprinklerforum
How I see this, when the distance between sprinklers varies, the more demanding distance is what drives the required minimum discharge pressure. The shorter distance gets over discharged but the longer distance gets the application called for in the design. So these sprinklers need to be

Re: Group of Pipe Obstruction

2021-12-16 Thread AKS-Gmail-IMAP via Sprinklerforum
One should realize what happens when a continuous deluge of water, ie fire sprinkler flow, encounters a piping group or an electrical conduit group, especially level piping groups. The water flows on the piping surface and then drops off the pipe at the pipe’s bottom. What hits the top drops

Re: Paint Booth Duct Protection

2021-12-02 Thread AKS-Gmail-IMAP via Sprinklerforum
The Mechanical code standards for exhaust ducts carrying flammable and hazardous materials is where fire suppression requirements can be encountered. These would apply if the jurisdiction follows that mechanical code. Be sure to follow that up. > On Dec 2, 2021, at 11:48 AM, Jerry Van Kolken

Re: Best Common Practices

2021-11-08 Thread AKS-Gmail-IMAP via Sprinklerforum
The architect has it backwards. The contract documents are where it needs to be in writing that the fire sprinkler protection system must be designed and installed in a specific manner. That specific manner must be explicitly stated in the fire protection documents or be the unambiguous

Re: Seismic joint detail

2021-10-19 Thread AKS-Gmail-IMAP via Sprinklerforum
l movement specifically. The > language of 9.3.3.2 is confusing, with reference made to open and closing of > the joint and also to, "...movement relative to the separation in the other > two dimensions..."What "other two dimensions", time and space? > >

Re: Seismic joint detail

2021-10-19 Thread AKS-Gmail-IMAP via Sprinklerforum
If we are referring to the six flexible coupling seismic separation assembly that every contractor finds an alternative, make a sizable wager with the structural engineer that the assembly provides vertical movement. Make sure the winnings cover the cost of six ½” pvc fittings and a four foot

Re: Fire Pump Backflow

2021-08-25 Thread AKS-Gmail-IMAP via Sprinklerforum
“Not any back flow” is being too loose with terms. Temperature differences alone will circulate water with the tank. Basically you have a fire pump in the domestic water system. All the piping materials and components in the system and connected to the system up to and including the double

Re: Clean Agent System

2021-08-24 Thread AKS-Gmail-IMAP via Sprinklerforum
You are right. I would assume these are smoke rated spring loaded dampers that are building powered open, preferably on an emergency circuit if someone was thinking. Therefore they would power fail closed. The clean agent release panel would just interrupt the power to the dampers. It is very

Re: Material Prices !!

2021-08-05 Thread AKS-Gmail-IMAP via Sprinklerforum
My hogwash radar alarm went off. So I checked. People in the fire sprinkler protection business did time combing through code and standards books. I cannot apologize for checking. US Antitrust laws comprise three acts. One is The Sherman Anti-Trust Act. It is all about conspiracy in restraint

Re: Sprinklers in stairways

2021-06-24 Thread AKS-Gmail-IMAP via Sprinklerforum
I’ve never seen a wood framed 3 hour fire rated shaft assembly or partition. A quick look at a USG Fire-Resistant Assembly catalog does not list one. This stairwell may not end up being built as you describe. Out of curiosity, can you tell us how this shaft is constructed and provide a tested

Re: [EXTERNAL] Fire Pump Sprk & Fire Flow Demand

2021-04-23 Thread AKS-Gmail-IMAP via Sprinklerforum
't change whether the hydrant supply is completely independent our > routed through a bypass. > > Steve > > -Original Message- > From: Sprinklerforum [mailto:sprinklerforum-boun...@lists.firesprinkler.org] > On Behalf Of AKS-Gmail-IMAP via Sprinklerforum &g

Re: [EXTERNAL] Fire Pump Sprk & Fire Flow Demand

2021-04-23 Thread AKS-Gmail-IMAP via Sprinklerforum
First of all to answer the question about what happens when a pump upstream of the operating fire pump system is also drawing water and the fire pump system has an open and flowing bypass system one just needs to go back to basic hydraulics. Where the fire pump discharge piping joins back to

Re: [EXTERNAL] Standpipe Testing

2021-04-16 Thread AKS-Gmail-IMAP via Sprinklerforum
Mark's way to explain what is going on is very good in my one half cent’s worth. Scot’s reasoning does have its uses. For example when using it one would arrive at the same supervisory air compressor choice indicated by a manufacturer’s selection table. But there is a needed correction! The P1

Re: IEBC and NFPA 14

2021-04-02 Thread AKS-Gmail-IMAP via Sprinklerforum
I think this depends on exactly what you are asking. Perhaps you have not read through the IEBC enough times. I believe the IEBC instructs code officials as to what codes to require when alterations are made to existing buildings. In other words it is not a code to now apply to existing

Re: Metal Mesh Ceiling tile replacement

2021-03-04 Thread AKS-Gmail-IMAP via Sprinklerforum
This is where your client, who might actually be the Architect on this project, needs an architectural justification to go with a different ceiling or a thin noncumbustible “sound” batting placed on the ceiling panels. How you plant such a seed is not easy because sometimes the Engineer is not

Re: MORE ACTIVITY WEIGHING IN

2021-02-16 Thread AKS-Gmail-IMAP via Sprinklerforum
5 lbs/sf collateral load is likely the low bid metal building design. This loading is intended to include ALL the MEPF and Arch. loads on the structure. The sprinkler contribution to the 5 lbs/sf is maybe 1.5 lbs/sf. This loading gets used for sizing the main structural elements. Depending on

Re: potential freezing in ESFR system

2020-12-22 Thread AKS-Gmail-IMAP via Sprinklerforum
It is and has been surprising to me when fire protection contractors ask the pipe freezing question or when they ask piping support questions in context with approval by local AHJ of any kind. The reason for the surprise is because contractors have ready access to materials, labor and space to

Re: Diesel Fuel Tank - Leak Protection

2020-11-21 Thread AKS-Gmail-IMAP via Sprinklerforum
Make sure there are no electrical conduits or similar leading down through the floor to another space that is at a lower elevation. Stuff happens despite what others may claim. It is not unlike, "there is nothing to burn”. I’ve seen an installation, not a diesel fire pump but an emergency power

Re: Window Sprinklers

2020-08-25 Thread AKS-Gmail-IMAP via Sprinklerforum
If you are referring to Tyco WS sprinklers, then you do see that it is not listed when there is a horizontal mullion but you also see in its installation details that there is no maximum distance indicated for the “ceiling” to the sprinkler. Yup, go look at. One other aspect to this is that

Re: Heads Under Conveyors

2020-08-12 Thread AKS-Gmail-IMAP via Sprinklerforum
Regarding heads above the conveyor, which I know is not the question, I knew an airline baggage manager that opened his forehead skin up on a pendent sprinkler that happened to be above a newly installed baggage conveyor. He had cleared a baggage jam and was riding the belt on his knees the

Re: [EXTERNAL] Unsprinklered Parking Garage

2020-06-11 Thread AKS-Gmail-IMAP via Sprinklerforum
First of all, just in case you do not know, you'll probably loose the maintenance contract if you take this question to the local AHJ without asking your client about doing that. The answer, BTW, is yes to your question "Would it be required if this building were being constructed now?". The

Re: NFPA 13, 2013 ed - hangers and pressures above 100psi

2020-05-29 Thread AKS-Gmail-IMAP via Sprinklerforum
All the listed flexible drop installation hardware restrain the sprinkler, but not necessarily to the ceiling. Some have gripping hardware supported by threaded rod “from the structure above". The gripping hardware is useful when the architect has some new fangled, odd ceiling design that does

Re: Dust Collection

2020-05-22 Thread AKS-Gmail-IMAP via Sprinklerforum
On May 22, 2020, at 2:49 PM, Sprinkler Academy - C Bilbo via Sprinklerforum wrote: > > . for the record a micron is about the thickness of a sheet of paper. > No way. Is not a micron a millionth of a meter? A meter is about 39 inches. That means an inch is slightly more than 25641

Re: [EXTERNAL] Anybody hit this wall?

2020-02-17 Thread AKS-Gmail-IMAP via Sprinklerforum
The elephant in the corner is the required containment if there is that building code requirement. How that is accomplished is a function of the fire protection application rate. There could be a pretty big oops going on. > On Feb 17, 2020, at 1:12 PM, Prahl, Craig/GVL via Sprinklerforum >

Re: Shell Spaces and Bushed Outlets

2020-02-04 Thread AKS-Gmail-IMAP via Sprinklerforum
If it were not a shell space and had the same design would you have used 3/4” outlets? How much of the future could the Standard reasonably expect to predict? The bigger question is should a shell space design be favorable for sprinkler adaptation or should it be sacrificial. This question is

Re: standpipe horizontal exit calculation question

2020-01-24 Thread AKS-Gmail-IMAP via Sprinklerforum
Such construction is difficult to reconcile on the FP side when the design team, including the structural team, is told the structure between building A and building B is essentially a third structure and the two buildings are to be built such that one side can burn and fall away without

Re: Fire Pump NFPA 20

2020-01-23 Thread AKS-Gmail-IMAP via Sprinklerforum
I think you guys are too literal when interpreting the original question because there has been no mention regarding the electrical controller when the pump is electric. Perhaps someone should also clarify that aspect. > On Jan 23, 2020, at 1:01 PM, Prahl, Craig/GVL via Sprinklerforum >

Re: Storage Tank High Level Sensor

2020-01-18 Thread AKS-Gmail-IMAP via Sprinklerforum
I am just curious regarding the conditions so here are some questions. When you write “electronic water sensor”, do you mean a fully electronic sensor of some sort or is the sensor actually a float actuating a mechanical switch? Are the low and high level sensors surrounded by a something to

Re: Mech. Platform above ceiling

2019-09-06 Thread AKS-Gmail-IMAP via Sprinklerforum
Use the standard that applies to a transition boundary between two different application densities. You are transitioning between the application above the mechanical platform to the zero application above the remaining ceiling cavity space. > On Sep 6, 2019, at 1:05 PM, Bobby via

Re: N 1.85 graph

2019-08-30 Thread AKS-Gmail-IMAP via Sprinklerforum
But the flow axis for a N1.85 is not a logarithmic scale. When plotting more than two points on an N1.85 graph you are essentially trying to eyeball a best fit to a 1.85 power water supply curve. If you are cook-booking, i.e. you don’t really know what this N1.85 is actually doing, then you

Re: [EXTERNAL] Re: Captive Aire Systems

2019-08-16 Thread AKS-Gmail-IMAP via Sprinklerforum
It is definitely a challenge to get down to the details for these systems to determine the implications for “supply its water from the automatic sprinkler system”. I don’t think the system nuts and bolts details are easily available online for inquiry. I have seen the installation and controls

Re: Fire Alarms

2019-08-13 Thread AKS-Gmail-IMAP via Sprinklerforum
The home base will be NFPA 72. Here is one important notion to remember. Throughout the NFPA 72 standard are common words that the average lay person would take for granted they already know what the words mean but in fact have very specific meanings in NFPA 72. For example the word “alarm” is