Re: [OSM-talk] Historic Mapping needs help Now!

2009-08-18 Thread Stephen Hope
I am hoping in a couple of weeks to map the grounds at a festival that occurs yearly in the same spot. This is not so much historical data, as data that's only true for three weeks a year. The rest of the time, it's just fields, with a few items (some toilets, etc) that stay in place year round.

Re: [OSM-talk] OSM status POIs?

2009-08-13 Thread Stephen Hope
I've seen todo=job used for this purpose. And todo tags show up in a number of verification tools, so it will be brought to people's attention. Stephen 2009/8/14 Morten Kjeldgaard m...@bioxray.au.dk: I realized when mapping today that it would be very useful to have a set of OSM status POIs

Re: [talk-au] Basic search, first attempt

2009-08-12 Thread Stephen Hope
Hopetoun, Vic and WA, both towns. I got into trouble with this once, because I'd only ever heard of the Vic one, and one of our clients was talking about the WA one, so I arranged for a meeting in the wrong state. Not quite as bad as the French firm that tried sending a package to me in Austria,

Re: [talk-au] Basic search, first attempt

2009-08-12 Thread Stephen Hope
Yeah, that's correct. Sorry, I didn't mean to use it as a reference in that way, but a quick run through of the list in name order will give you an idea of how many duplicates there are, and how big the problem is likely to be. It's interesting to have a quick look in postcode order as well -

Re: [OSM-talk] GPS Accuracy under Forest Canopy

2009-08-10 Thread Stephen Hope
I've done some rain-forest hiking, and I've noticed similar results. If you really want to see some wandering tracks, try hiking along the base of some cliffs, in dense forest. I have noticed that the errors do seems to be less the faster I'm moving. If I stand in one place for a while, the path

Re: [talk-au] Cycleway/footway/path

2009-08-10 Thread Stephen Hope
Umm, not the case at all. Highway= comes from the old english use, where highway means way/path/track you use to get somewhere. These days we assume roads and cars, but that's not the way it was originally designed. Stephen 2009/8/10 John Smith delta_foxt...@yahoo.com: To play devils advocate

Re: [OSM-talk] Business listings

2009-07-27 Thread Stephen Hope
2009/7/28 John Smith delta_foxt...@yahoo.com: In Australia in Telstra won a lawsuit against people OCR'ing the street directory and selling white/yellow pages on CD. For all intents and purposes Telstra owns the copyright on all Australian White/Yellow page directories and now Telstra is a

Re: [talk-au] maxheight/height

2009-07-27 Thread Stephen Hope
No, you're wrong here. Maxheight is an element of the way that goes under the bridge. It is caused by the bridge, but it is not part of the bridge. It is the road under the bridge that has the limitation, not the bridge. Divided roads often have different max heights on each side, but it is one

Re: [talk-au] slightly diff tag watch

2009-07-26 Thread Stephen Hope
'Seventh-day Adventist' is the official name, but commonly abbreviated to Adventist or SDA. Technically, an adventist is someone who believes in the (soon) second coming of Christ (the Advent), so most Christian faiths can be called adventists. However, it's usually applied to a number of

Re: [talk-au] I just saw Nambour....

2009-07-23 Thread Stephen Hope
While we're talking about the Sunshine coast area, is anybody going to the Muster this year? It wouldn't hurt to map the campgrounds and festival while they're there - most of the year it's just a few empty fields. Stephen 2009/7/24 John Smith delta_foxt...@yahoo.com: --- On Thu, 23/7/09,

Re: [OSM-talk] Same physical road, diff maxspeed.

2009-07-22 Thread Stephen Hope
I'm sure somebody somewhere has used a tag like max_speed_opposite or something like that, but the closest I've actually seen to a recomendation is this http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Relations/Proposed/Segmented_Tag Look at the discussion tab for more info. I don't knwo how widely this is

Re: [OSM-talk] Same physical road, diff maxspeed.

2009-07-22 Thread Stephen Hope
Yeah, you're right - this is more what I was thinking of seeing, but the relationship is the one that came up when I searched. I don't understand the wiki search results sometimes. Try this page. I think the one I listed earlier is not the best option.

Re: [OSM-talk] 'Distance to feature' maps?

2009-07-14 Thread Stephen Hope
Good luck changing their minds. We have a similar rule near here - no bad winters or wild animals, but some kids were supposed to walk across a major multi-lane highway that had no crossing at all for vehicles for several km each way, but they were within a 1km circle of the school, so no

Re: [talk-au] Junctions (to name or not to name)

2009-06-28 Thread Stephen Hope
This is most definitely a problem with Gosmore. The fact is, most roundabouts do not have names, and artificially giving them one to make a renderer (or routing program) happy is tagging for the renderer. Even if a roundabout did have a name, I'd be happier if the routing software just said turn

Re: [OSM-talk] [Tag] Ref in link

2009-06-24 Thread Stephen Hope
What is your suggested ref for links that are an entrance, not an exit? And can you give an example of what you mean by an exit ref? Where I come from, some exits have numbers, but the number is associated with the highway ref, so you'd still need that as well. 2009/6/25 Xav x...@nainwak.com:

Re: [talk-au] school zones

2009-06-22 Thread Stephen Hope
How accurate are you wanting to go? To be truly accurate, you're going to need to take weekends and school holidays into account as well. Actually, on a serious note, I'd love to have a routing algorithm that avoids schools during child dropoff and pickup hours when possible. I don't mind the

Re: [talk-au] Hi all ...

2009-06-17 Thread Stephen Hope
I've ever used Potlatch-I was nervous about having an editor that was always live - no 'edit-check-save' cycle. I understand that has recently changed, but the point is it's not that hard to use some of the other options. Stephen 2009/6/17 Dan O'Hara oha...@homemail.com.au: As a total newbie to

Re: [talk-au] Hi all ...

2009-06-17 Thread Stephen Hope
Sorry- that should be _Never_ used potlatch 2009/6/18 Stephen Hope slh...@gmail.com: I've ever used Potlatch-I was nervous about having an editor that was always live - no 'edit-check-save' cycle. I understand that has recently changed, but the point is it's not that hard to use some

Re: [talk-au] Data Error - Junctions ?

2009-06-17 Thread Stephen Hope
2009/6/18 Rick Peterson ausr...@iinet.net.au: Background: I was having a look at my local area with Keepright and spotted a couple of dead ended one ways. On close inspection in Potlatch, I see that the junctions have not been formed correctly. The layout of the streets, street names etc all

Re: [talk-au] Causeways

2009-05-25 Thread Stephen Hope
2009/5/25 Liz ed...@billiau.net: Something else I can't work out how to tag is a jetty, the thing that juts out into water and boats tie up to. But after 8 years of drought here, perhaps I needn't worry too much. Just be grateful you're not trying to teach English to some-one who speaks

Re: [OSM-talk] Highways tagging vs Polygon

2009-05-21 Thread Stephen Hope
2009/5/22 Richard Bullock rb...@cantab.net: Am I missing something, or can we not just assume that e.g. each highway=residential has a speed limit consistent with urban areas in that country - unless explicitly tagged otherwise Actually, that wouldn't work where I live in Australia. Each

Re: [OSM-talk] zones for motorway/in town/outof town?

2009-05-20 Thread Stephen Hope
In my part of Australia, we have a speed limit that applies to every non-rural street that is not specifically signed as being another speed - basically case (b) below. The wording used in the law is built up area. (In practice, the test for a built up area seems to be does it have street

Re: [talk-au] Rivers

2009-05-20 Thread Stephen Hope
To get imagery in Josm, you need to use the WMS menu at the top to add an imagery layer. You may need to set it up first with some plug-ins. It is certainly possible, though. Stephen 2009/5/20 Delta Foxtrot delta_foxt...@yahoo.com: I tried JSOM briefly the other day but the entire

Re: [OSM-talk] coastline accuracy?

2009-04-29 Thread Stephen Hope
There are large parts of tropical coastlines where the coast is marked as the outside edge of mangrove swamps. These are covered with water most of the time, and adjacent to the sea, so are below the high tide line, but are considered to be part of the land. You can't take a boat through them,

Re: [OSM-talk] best GPS for trekking

2009-04-16 Thread Stephen Hope
Make sure you test it in the cold though, as noted before, recharchable batteries especially tend to work worse in cold weather. Doesn't mean they won't work, just that you'll get maybe half the life out of them. If you are going to use good alkaline batteries, don't expect them to be easily

Re: [OSM-talk] What is amenity=food_outlets in map features?

2009-03-29 Thread Stephen Hope
I'm guessing a food court. That's the term I've always heard, anyway. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Food_court Stephen 2009/3/29 Ulf Lamping ulf.lamp...@googlemail.com: Hi! Someone added amenity=food_outlets to the map features and even after reading the comment An area with several food

Re: [OSM-talk] highway=cyclefootway

2009-03-27 Thread Stephen Hope
OK, so while we're talking about this, there are a number of paths near me. Nice smooth concrete, about 2m wide. They run through parks, and there are signs on the park as a whole that say No motorised vehicles. These paths are marked with a sign that has a pedestrian and a bicycle, and another

Re: [OSM-talk] Cloudmade: We are the Wikipedia of maps

2009-03-11 Thread Stephen Hope
And you can't always blame the journalists, either. Once they send their copy in, the editors can have a go at it as well. I've seen perfectly good and factual articles become very inaccurate as the editors try and make it fit in half the space with bit of cut and paste. You'd think these days the

Re: [OSM-talk] Wiki: chriscf vandalism

2009-01-31 Thread Stephen Hope
What I like about the tag voting system is the discussion. The discussion pages around a tag proposal are often quite useful - often more so than the main page on the tag. The number of times a tag proposal has been improved from the original proposal after discussion suggests that any system

Re: [talk-au] Adelaide out of copyright street directory

2009-01-18 Thread Stephen Hope
2009/1/18 Liz ed...@billiau.net: Important matter on copyright duration I realised only very recently that we haven't been reading the rules correctly and published material - the street directory, the paper map, expires after 25 years at midnight on the next New Years Eve Published

Re: [OSM-talk] Temporary Items, overlays, changes

2009-01-07 Thread Stephen Hope
No, don't delete them if they may be of historical value (or if they come back again). Tag them with something so they don't show in the current day maps. We already have historical tagged items - things that don't currently exist. (US Civil war battlesites, etc). There is a festival near me

Re: [OSM-talk] Which entry level budget garmin

2009-01-06 Thread Stephen Hope
I didn't give it because I didn't remember, and it isn't what he's looking for. It was the testing of the snap-to road functions and the track-logging I remembered. It is a Mio PDA, model 7nn (720, 730?). I can't look it up right now because I loaned it to somebody for the Christmas holidays,

Re: [OSM-talk] Which entry level budget garmin

2009-01-05 Thread Stephen Hope
It's not hard to test. When I was unsure if my device was doing this or not, I set it to snap to road, and then took it for a little walk along the edge and then cut some corners in a park, then looked at the tracks. For my specific device (not a Zumo), I discovered that the on screen and main

Re: [OSM-talk] Some more shops and amenities for the map features page ...

2008-12-21 Thread Stephen Hope
2008/12/21 D Tucny d...@tucny.com: What makes an optician's a shop whereas a dentist is an amenity? NHS? Opticians selling sunglasses? Because an opticians tend's to look a shop, and I can go in, buy something (new frame, glasses case, cleaning materials) without an appointment or seeing an

Re: [talk-au] Major road cleanup

2008-12-21 Thread Stephen Hope
I'm a little confused. Everywhere I've seen a park on the side of the road like that, it has used the same nodes, but not the same way. Splitting the way should not effect the park at all, except if you add nodes, in which case you'll need to add them to the park way as well. Or am I thinking of

Re: [OSM-talk] Seasonal Roads?

2008-12-10 Thread Stephen Hope
Start using it - the ultimate test of tag in OSM is whether it is used or not. However, if people are actively discussing it, try and get a consensus first. Stephen 2008/12/11 Colin McGregor [EMAIL PROTECTED]: So, what can I do to help advance the cause of getting a seasonal tag (be the

Re: [talk-au] What gives with roundabouts?

2008-12-10 Thread Stephen Hope
There is no problem adding a turning circle to courts as long as they have one. Before the turning circle tag was rendered, I saw the occasional mini-roundabout used as a turning circle, because it made the map look right. Stephen 2008/12/11 [EMAIL PROTECTED]: +1 I completely agree with all

Re: [talk-au] Mapnik rendering of AU cities

2008-12-04 Thread Stephen Hope
I'm not positive, but I think that the very low zoom views don't actually get a lot (any?) of their data from the live OSM data. Rather they do, but they are only updated on very occasionally. There is just too much data to be continually recreating tiles that large from the main database. The

Re: [OSM-talk] Edit war on the wiki map features

2008-12-01 Thread Stephen Hope
Where you have the sign post for 4WD only, is that an access restriction or a suggestion? I.E. If you go on that road with a motorbike, or a 2wd vehicle, could you face prosecution? Or would you just be considered a bit foolish? It's a warning, not a restriction. I regularly take my 2WD

Re: [OSM-talk] Turn restriction docs

2008-11-30 Thread Stephen Hope
As well as You can't do this and You must do this we need You may do this (that normally you can't). Where I live, you can't do a U-turn at traffic lights unless there's a sign that says you can. If we try and mark this by putting relations at every light banning U-turns, we'll just end up with

Re: [OSM-talk] Contraflow bus lane

2008-10-26 Thread Stephen Hope
]: Stephen Hope [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Not all PSV's are buses. What else? Matthias ___ talk mailing list talk@openstreetmap.org http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk ___ talk mailing list

Re: [OSM-talk] Turn restrictions vs allowances?

2008-10-22 Thread Stephen Hope
We have a similar thing here in Queensland, Australia. You can't do a U-turn at any traffic lights unless there is a sign specifically saying that you can. I think this is the same across the whole country, but I'd have to check. There are no signs saying you can't at the other lights, you're

Re: [OSM-talk] Contraflow bus lane

2008-10-22 Thread Stephen Hope
Not all PSV's are buses. 2008/10/23 Matthias Julius [EMAIL PROTECTED]: Shaun McDonald [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Usually psv for public service vehicle is used for access restrictions. I missed that. It would have been too easy to call a bus bus, I guess ;-) Should we rename bus_stop to

Re: [talk-au] Edits in and around Mt Barker, SA

2008-10-20 Thread Stephen Hope
2008/10/21 Kim Hawtin [EMAIL PROTECTED]: - Are the rail and road under passes right? I have set them as tunnels, because it makes more sense than the freeway being a bridge, how ever what do other folks use? Without actually looking at what you've done - I've done both. If the underpass

Re: [OSM-talk] [Tagging] - RFC -Motorway_linkimpliesoneway=??

2008-10-08 Thread Stephen Hope
2008/10/9 Matthias Julius [EMAIL PROTECTED]: This leads to a nightmare. Those rules would need to be implemented in every tool that works with OSM data (and cares about oneway properties). It's a nightmare we're probably going to have to address at some point if we want to do good routing.

Re: [OSM-talk] [Tagging] - RFC - Motorway_link impliesoneway=??

2008-10-02 Thread Stephen Hope
Bad assumption. This may be the case in parts of Europe and the USA, but certainly not in most parts of the world. 2008/10/3 Matthias Julius [EMAIL PROTECTED]: Trunk roads are probably mostly oneway, too ... ___ talk mailing list

Re: [talk-au] GPS recommendation

2008-09-11 Thread Stephen Hope
I hadn't heard of that one before. Do you have any idea how long it operates as a GPS on battery? The GPS I have now is a multifunction device - it goes for hours without the GPS on, but turn the GPS on and it dies quickly. It is going to be used in the car with power, the one I'm looking to

Re: [talk-au] boxes around cities

2008-09-02 Thread Stephen Hope
Yeah - look to see if they have a notes tag. Are these the Yahoo coverage boxes you are talking about? I noticed the one for Adelaide appeared a few months ago and confused me until I realised that's what it was for. -- ___ Talk-au mailing list

Re: [OSM-talk] mailing list behavior

2008-09-01 Thread Stephen Hope
2008/9/2 Sascha Silbe [EMAIL PROTECTED]: There's no way OSM could change that default, it's up to your MUA vendor. The buttons you're currently using are reply (with an implied to author) and reply to all, not reply (default) and reply (alternative). The only thing OSM can do is to trick your

Re: [OSM-talk] Is it land or sea: how to map a swamp?

2008-07-08 Thread Stephen Hope
The northern coast of Australia has many Mangrove marshes at river mouths, some of them extending many kilometres away from the dry shore line. PGS shows these areas as sea, because they are not dry land - and that is were the coastlines would have been imported from. Note that being submerged

Re: [OSM-talk] Wide roads and traffic signals

2008-06-25 Thread Stephen Hope
If you can't cross from one side to another anywhere, then it should be marked as two separate ways. When you have a twoway road connect to one of these, it will connect to each side, with a little crossing piece in the middle. When you have two such roads connect, then it will look like a hash

Re: [OSM-talk] pronunciation tag

2008-06-23 Thread Stephen Hope
2008/6/24 Michal Migurski [EMAIL PROTECTED]: I'd also take issue with your rendering of Divisadero - it's a lot like Sepulveda in in LA, apparently the wrong pronunciation is the right pronunciation. =) That's a whole other can of worms. Is the right pronunciation: - The way the locals

Re: [OSM-talk] difference between waterway=canal and waterway=drain

2008-05-14 Thread Stephen Hope
What is your definition of an artificial waterway? Dug and designed by man? Made of non-natural materials? Near me a few years ago was an open marshy field that was fed by a stream, with a stream exiting. Now the developers have put houses up in the field. They brought in dirt and raised the

Re: [OSM-talk] area topology

2008-05-13 Thread Stephen Hope
Says who? The boundary of the forest IS the road. :) This is one of religious discussions - both sides KNOW they are right, and no amount of discussion is going to change things. Unless we have a central decision making force of some sort lay down the law, (in OSM - hah!) you'll continue to

Re: [OSM-talk] Mapping distant objects by triangulation.

2008-05-12 Thread Stephen Hope
In theory, yes. In practice, maybe. You would find that if you did a third measuring line, it probably wouldn't intersect where the first two did. Small errors at the measuring end cause massive errors at the other end. Even the guys with the specialist measuring equipment working on a

Re: [OSM-talk] Rocky beaches

2008-04-14 Thread Stephen Hope
Also, if you are in an area with extensive coastal swamps (mangroves for example) be aware that the PGS data usually traces the land side of the swamp. This makes sense, looking at the statement below, but the mangrove swamps can extend for many kilometres to sea, and I wouldn't want to sail

Re: [talk-au] Sydney cycle routes

2008-03-18 Thread Stephen Hope
In the Brisbane Metro area, Pine Rivers shire (soon to be part of Moreton Bay) has maps available of bike routes. I looked at one to see how many there would be to map in the region. From what I can tell, they've marked every wide footpath on the map, as well as shared walkways through parks

Re: [talk-au] Number of lanes?

2008-03-10 Thread Stephen Hope
A number of people seem to misread the lanes tag as total lanes on the road, not lanes in each direction. A case could be made that it should be total lanes, as that would allow for asymmetric roads to be modelled. I suspect that a lot of the lanes=1 tags really mean that it is a narrow, unmarked

Re: [OSM-talk] Raw GPS layer

2008-02-22 Thread Stephen Hope
This would be good. But even better, let me select a portion of a track log and upload it. My track logs tend to be a nightmarish tangle, with possibly hours of stuff before, after and during the interesting bits. I can use them because I was there, and know where I went, when and why (this is

Re: [talk-au] Test trace how many points on a road

2008-02-18 Thread Stephen Hope
There is (was?) a simplify way command available in JOSM, but you need to add one of the plugins first. Stephen On 18/02/2008, Paul Zagoridis [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi Greg Ah I did it on Potlatch -- sorry about that. Regards Paul Greg Harper wrote, On 17/2/08 3:32 PM: Where

Re: [OSM-talk] Place of worship: wayside crosses

2008-02-03 Thread Stephen Hope
Christoph, There was some discussion about this on the list last month, (in a thread that started by talking about the Icon tag), and there is now a proposed tag as wayside_cross (there is also wayside_shrine). http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/index.php/Proposed_features/wayside_cross Wayside

[OSM-talk] JOSM upload failure

2008-01-03 Thread Stephen Hope
the nodes that uploaded last time? Is there some rule that says you can't have two nodes in the same place? Stephen Hope ___ talk mailing list talk@openstreetmap.org http://lists.openstreetmap.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/talk

<    1   2