Re: [talk-au] Question about using NSW Speed Zone Data in OSM

2024-02-19 Thread Bob Cameron
Hi Mark Although not anywhere conclusive I made a Mapillary capture outbound on Woore Street Wilcannia 5/2022 that shows what are likely to be the dual 50/100 transition signs (smudges) well before the changeset. Might be useful.. Bob On 19/2/24 20:19, Mark Pulley wrote: I haven’t done any

Re: [talk-au] Nowra bridge help

2023-12-15 Thread Bob Cameron
Correct! On 15/12/23 12:49, Graeme Fitzpatrick wrote: Bob So the western bridge is now northbound & the "middle" bridge is south? Thanks Graeme On Fri, 15 Dec 2023 at 08:06, Bob Cameron wrote: Wonder if someone might fix this one. Don't want to stuff it

[talk-au] Nowra bridge help

2023-12-14 Thread Bob Cameron
Wonder if someone might fix this one. Don't want to stuff it up https://www.openstreetmap.org/edit#map=17/-34.86388/150.60252 The main crossing over the Shoalhaven River on Princes Hwy The eastern/old span is no longer in use and gated at the northern end. Both "new" spans are in use one way

Re: [talk-au] Maranda or Maranoa Road

2023-12-10 Thread Bob Cameron
Hi Nev The Mapillary imagery at the eastern end at Carnarvon Hwy; https://www.mapillary.com/app/user/bob3bob3?lat=-27.124729889167=149.06543468617=17%5B%5D=bob3bob3=2018-12-01=894202007803486=photo=0.7498372203522408=0.5576487643887181=2.5378590078328984

Re: [talk-au] Overpass question

2023-11-04 Thread Bob Cameron
that are data complete. Cheers On 17/10/23 18:04, Andrew Davidson wrote: On 17/10/23 04:58, Bob Cameron wrote:> Ways only? Because the output data/list format is different. Nodes are arranged by objects per co-ordinate, whereas ways are by an ID that includes a nodes list, with a separate

Re: [talk-au] Overpass question

2023-10-16 Thread Bob Cameron
On 16/10/23 20:55, Warin wrote: No expert ... Question: why only get the node when you can have the whole thing? I think that just adds complexity? Ways only? Because the output data/list format is different. Nodes are arranged by objects per co-ordinate, whereas ways are by an ID that

[talk-au] Overpass question

2023-10-11 Thread Bob Cameron
A question for an overpass expert. I am cleaning up a lot of the parking tags I have created so they follow the same rules etc. I have successfully generated a text list of nodes where I can cut/paste the co-ords into the ID editor to research/fix as needed. This was done with a gpsbabel

Re: [talk-au] Filling in blank space (Was Re: Tagging towns by relative importance, not just population size)

2023-10-01 Thread Bob Cameron
A lady served me a burger and coffee at Windorah Roadhouse. I think I remember the supermarket also had some limited fast food. I had a sit down feed at the pub in a prior visit. Was eaten alive by mozzies at Stonehenge (Qld) pub. The visitors centre there (also a RTC and small supermarket)

Re: [talk-au] Filling in blank space (Was Re: Tagging towns by relative importance, not just population size)

2023-10-01 Thread Bob Cameron
suits most? (This having been mentioned in prior posts) Bob On 1/10/23 17:02, Graeme Fitzpatrick wrote: Good to hear from you, Bob. As somebody who spends a lot of time out in remote places, what's your thoughts on the concept? Thanks Graeme On Sun, 1 Oct 2023 at 15:45, Bob Cameron wrote:

Re: [talk-au] Filling in blank space (Was Re: Tagging towns by relative importance, not just population size)

2023-09-30 Thread Bob Cameron
I managed (to buy) a coffee in Windorah two years ago..  That has to count for something.. They have spent a lot on the campsite too. Newish amenities and hot showers for $5/n in 5/21. Cheers Bob On 1/10/23 10:31, Graeme Fitzpatrick wrote: Oh look - Windorah is there, so it must be

Re: [talk-au] New MapRoulette Challenges - Add Highways & Isolated

2023-03-16 Thread Bob Cameron
Just a thought Salim You might like to add street imagery and GPS tracks based on that as an extra data source. This has a date stamp that much of the overhead imagery does not. Cheers Bob On 17/3/23 02:55, Salim Baidoun wrote: Hello Australia community, We are releasing a challenge

Re: [talk-au] Tagging Trucks (hgv) "Use low gears"

2023-01-21 Thread Bob Cameron
Some Mapillary "data rich" slow vehicle locations. (ie for checking/testing sign recognition) - Dorrigo mountain - Waterfall Way. (Just west/north of Thora) NSW - Bendemeer to Moonbi - New England Hwy NSW - Black Mountain south - New England Hwy NSW On 22/1/23 15:01, Andrew Harvey wrote:

[talk-au] Links in Australian_Data_Sources - Western Australia

2022-11-21 Thread Bob Cameron
Dian? https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Australian_Data_Sources Just noticed that some of the Main Roads links for WA are coming up 404. eg Speed Limits, Speed Zones, Control of Access & Road Stopping Places. Some still work. I did not check them all. I get the impression that searching

[talk-au] Dogleg Drive Warialda NSW - Restricted vehicle Road Route.

2022-11-07 Thread Bob Cameron
I wonder if someone with better knowledge on primary etc routes/relations/sources might tackle this. Was in Warialda NSW recently and noted that the HGV bypass barrier (east of town) near the washdown facility has been removed, but didn't think to check the formal route from there north. I

Re: [talk-au] Tagging fire stations

2022-10-10 Thread Bob Cameron
Hi Y'all. (So lived in Texas in a past life..) Possibly also worth noting - Many a rural/remote site has an ill defined block boundary. Some are tucked in corners of rec reserves and some are even on private land. (which affects road access tags) - Naming (on signs etc) may be problematic.

[talk-au] OSM Attribution Q

2022-08-14 Thread Bob Cameron
I likely have this wrong, but worth a question. Looking at petrolspy.com.au website for Theodore Qld and note that the sport and rec ground shows a remarkable similarity to the changes/updates I did 10 months ago, right down to the service road loop around the RV dump. In addition the

Re: [talk-au] Adding river crossings to Guidelines "road quality / 4wd-only"?

2022-08-10 Thread Bob Cameron
I'd like to see some ford node vs way and culvert detail Dian. Took me a while to understand it all, so may help a newbie. eg a section of road (as a ford way - often concrete) has to be joined to the crossing stream. If there is a "low water level" pipe/culvert that is an additional tunnel.

Re: [talk-au] Adding river crossings to Guidelines "road quality / 4wd-only"?

2022-08-10 Thread Bob Cameron
The Gregory River Doomadgee Road crossing near Tirranna Springs Qld has a "not on foot" warning sign as the water over the causeway runs very fast. Hard to know if it's a legal direction though. On 10/8/22 20:58, Adam Steer wrote: A little note to the discussion - the foot/ animal traffic

Re: [talk-au] Well I bought an L1/L5 Mouse GPS

2022-06-23 Thread Bob Cameron
One of the cross checks I do is to use a bidirectional Mapillary track layer. I'd suggest fairly good for road centering in open places (ie no phase delay GPS reflections). No good for non covered cross street positioning of course. Bob On 23/6/22 11:45, Alex Sims wrote: Hi, I’ve now got

Re: [talk-au] Tagging suggestions please - parking formal vs informal

2022-04-29 Thread Bob Cameron
lso adding capacity:hgv based on a drive in/out 20x4m block. I also add the presence (or not) of a rubbish bin! What makes a park formal being signage or obvious ground/area works. The distinction is sometimes a bit grey. Will be a one by one fix of my past efforts! Cheers On 20/4/22 18:32,

Re: [talk-au] Country homesteads?

2022-04-27 Thread Bob Cameron
Hi Phil Well they are all scattered plus/minus the road I travelled/captured on in the last week or two. Tnx On 27/4/22 17:44, Phil Wyatt wrote: Hi Bob, I have changed all the South Australian locations for you. I checked a few random locations and they all looked to be placed within a

Re: [talk-au] Country homesteads?

2022-04-25 Thread Bob Cameron
So I'll ask some assistance from a mass edit guru here... I'd like to change all my own landuse:farm nodes to place:farm, leaving all child keys as they are. Since I only use ID is there anyone can help do this? Does it require any kind of formal control? Oh and I have found that DCS base

Re: [talk-au] Country homesteads?

2022-04-21 Thread Bob Cameron
Remote areas and larger farms generally have been troubling me too Graeme. I make no distinction about numbers of people, just a landuse=farm node. (so I copied a very prolific mapper!) Recently I noted that landuse:farm has been deprecated and to use landuse:farmland, but that complains about

[talk-au] Tagging suggestions please - parking formal vs informal

2022-04-20 Thread Bob Cameron
Only about regional areas, not urban There are well used informal parks everywhere. Many used by trucks as rest areas. Some are tiny, some are huge, some are gravel pits, some are the NHVR green dot things.. Some councils even setup bins in them. I'd like a way to tag any informal area. No

Re: [talk-au] Wiki Clean Up Progress Update

2022-04-18 Thread Bob Cameron
Good stuff Dian! I don't know how widespread the problem is, but Garmin GPS navigation devices see no road surface tag as sealed. This can create routing stress for the driver and possibly safety issues. Might be worth mentioning that it's far better to default tag new roads in non urban

[talk-au] Tagging guidelines points - rest/parking/camping/hgv

2022-04-15 Thread Bob Cameron
Sorry I cant see where to add these points to the wiki, nor see the edit evolution. No doubt I'll see some disagreements, but anyway! - Regarding "No Camping" signs within the rest area category. (Although it could apply to any location) It seems a bit long winded and not really useful for

[talk-au] Precedence of alt naming

2022-04-06 Thread Bob Cameron
This might have been covered before.. What is the consensus on precedence of alt_names, more for roads and waterways. Example, I sometimes come across (NSW) creek name formal signs that are quite different from what is shown on the DCS overlays. Is the primary name the "on the ground" one

Re: [talk-au] Recommended CB radio channel for road

2022-03-22 Thread Bob Cameron
As I understand it the ACMA license database POI is waiting for a waiver. A query of that will yield all repeater licenses, site locations (lat/lon/elev etc) . I actually use it to populate my navigation GPS The general rule for emergency use is to try all the lower half repeaters

Re: [talk-au] Recommended CB radio channel for road

2022-03-21 Thread Bob Cameron
Keep in mind to also not run afoul with legislation. That might seem to be about emergency use (UHF 5/35) or telemetry (UHF 22-23), but using simplex on the input frequencies of UHF repeaters (31-38 & 71-78) that one is within the operational range of is not allowed. Many contract roadwork

Re: [talk-au] 2377 occurrences of fixme="unknown type of water crossing"

2022-02-23 Thread Bob Cameron
Would you mind elaborating? With the stream under a road (way) as tunnel and the default culvert; The road over the top has either a node or way ford Or is the road/way flood_prone yes Or is the stream culvert section additionally ford yes Tnx On 23/2/22 19:08, Warin wrote: Where these are

Re: [talk-au] Information source question - sorry kind of lengthy.

2022-02-13 Thread Bob Cameron
Finally got around to doing these changes. 10 ways were affected The signs at Willow Tree and just out of Merriwa only say that there is no access to the other town. I doesn't say where the actual closure is, so I relied on my pre closure drive Mapillary imagery. I vaguely remember that

Re: [talk-au] Information source question - sorry kind of lengthy.

2022-02-02 Thread Bob Cameron
Thanks for the feedback everyone. - There are indeed numerous sources that say the road is closed, for more than one year. - To avoid routing yes I could pick a likely spot and make in Access:No - Livetraffic also have a text view that is end points specific, so any Google Maps issue are

[talk-au] Information source question - sorry kind of lengthy.

2022-02-02 Thread Bob Cameron
MR358 or Coulsons Creek Road between Willow Tree and Merriwa NSW is closed for repair of major slippage as it crosses the Liverpool Ranges. "Livetraffic" (Traffic for NSW govt site) says not reopening until late 2023. A reference on that to a local govt site is devoid of any current

[talk-au] NSW Spatial Services offline

2021-12-13 Thread Bob Cameron
Note msg on their website https://www.spatial.nsw.gov.au/ Basically anything DCS in the OSM ID map overlays died late Mon afternoon. Also mentions holiday closure 27/12 to 10/1. ___ Talk-au mailing list Talk-au@openstreetmap.org

Re: [talk-au] Gas mining area - road access tags

2021-11-16 Thread Bob Cameron
Farm tracks too could be access=private. While the well head can be a small area, the actual mining lease can be large.   The large area could be mapped with layer=-1,-2,-3,-4 or -5. But what source are you going to use for the area? My general workflow is more about driven road features

[talk-au] Gas mining area - road access tags

2021-11-16 Thread Bob Cameron
Would it be a fair statement to say that gas mining areas are all private access? eg. around Condamine Qld there are a lot of them that often co-exist with farmland. Are the mining area leases "well area" only or cover a wider area? The concern is that with many service roads crossing

Re: [talk-au] Way errors in Quilpie Qld

2021-10-03 Thread Bob Cameron
Thanks Andrew, looks excellent. I did record 2 full GPX tracks for all streets. Would you like me to send them to you at your gmail acct for a cross check? I also covered the laneway and access to the railway station from the Brolga Street side and Murana Road on the other. I have dashcam

Re: [talk-au] Way errors in Quilpie Qld

2021-10-02 Thread Bob Cameron
Wow, what a changeset! Bing was 2010-2012. The Maxar Premium seems the most recent. Whatever the case with the buildings, the roads tend to be used as anchors for many features. I guess the opinion I am looking for is that if a formal source can't be found/used, will my GPS run tomorrow (plus

[talk-au] Way errors in Quilpie Qld

2021-10-02 Thread Bob Cameron
I am currently near this nice quiet place and am leaving shortly. https://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=16/-26.6176/144.2666 I note that there is a fairly large discrepancy between some of the roads and the public GPS traces. The main E-W highway is also split, but not in OSM. Imagery and GPS

Re: [talk-au] Audible fences

2021-08-01 Thread Bob Cameron
there is the quite loud high frequency sound and no road shoulder at the barrier. Since they are becoming more and more common I'd like to see the consensus placed in the Aus taglines wiki Cheers On 1/8/21 5:32 pm, Warin wrote: On 31/7/21 8:59 am, Bob Cameron wrote: Info only barrier=fence sensory

[talk-au] Audible fences

2021-07-30 Thread Bob Cameron
Info only barrier=fence sensory=audible ie the squeaking screeching fences that supposedly replace cattle grids. I asked for input some months ago on how to map. With the recent ID editor update there is now a warning that a fence has to be a line, even though it is placed on the road.

Re: [talk-au] Roads in Industrial Estates: Residential, Unclassified or Service?

2021-07-28 Thread Bob Cameron
Task Manager (ctrl-alt-del and select) will show process/ram hogs. sort by cpu usage then memory, grab the process name and search on it... 4GB may be a little light too.. If your hard drive flogs (swaps) a lot that may be worth a look. G'luck! On 28/7/21 3:22 pm, Graeme Fitzpatrick wrote:

Re: [talk-au] Victorian Vicmap Address Import Proposal

2021-05-24 Thread Bob Cameron
Hi Andrew Wonder if you might add the following to your later communications with NHVR. Not pressing, just an inclusion. As I understand it formal heavy vehicle rest area locations are more a state database system. The "three green dot" informal rest areas however were/are a NHVR

Re: [talk-au] Snapping Major regional roads to GPS traces

2021-05-15 Thread Bob Cameron
Thanks all for your comments; - Yes I am aware of multipath phase errors, HDOP and VDOP problems etc. My imagery camera also has excessive averaging and interpolation, so I not only upload its trace but also that from a separate roof mounted GPS sender unit. - Re old traces. I can "cheat" a

[talk-au] Snapping Major regional roads to GPS traces

2021-05-14 Thread Bob Cameron
Just checking if this is an okay thing to do. ie moving a major road so it is centred on GPS traces - assuming there enough data for accuracy (eg bidirectional, multi trace etc) The traces are probably more accurate than overhead imagery. Other features placed relative to roads will also need

Re: [talk-au] Camp_sites discussion WOOPS

2021-04-23 Thread Bob Cameron
Woops Sent the last rather than just saving the draft Pls ignore ___ Talk-au mailing list Talk-au@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-au

Re: [talk-au] Fwd: Camp_sites discussion

2021-04-22 Thread Bob Cameron
Hi Graeme Admitting ashamedly that I like nothing better than my OSM mkgmap Garmin GPS device come up with any overnight viable stopping place nearby.. This of course makes me biased, so I apologise for that... On 22/4/21 11:05 am, Graeme Fitzpatrick wrote: On Wed, 21 Apr 2021 at 18:46, Bob

[talk-au] Camp_sites discussion

2021-04-21 Thread Bob Cameron
I wanted to ask for ideas and discussion related to tourism:camp_site. Noting that there is also a wiki on this; https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:tourism%3Dcamp_site Some general things. (Much from my own experience) - Do we need to be extensive in our data detail given that there are

Re: [talk-au] Audible stock control fences - mapping

2021-04-20 Thread Bob Cameron
it was horribly expensive, but one station owner had recouped his expense (sheep not attacked) after about 18 months. The audible/screamers sections on roads were very low cost in comparison. Cheers On 19/4/21 4:05 pm, Bob Cameron wrote: Opinions/ideas please On a substantial number of roads I

Re: [talk-au] Aus tagging guidelines on highway surface tags

2021-01-30 Thread Bob Cameron
Ian/all I have been boldly marking paved and no-tag as asphalt, causeways/fords/bridges as concrete (etc) as a result of examining my own Mapillary imagery, sometimes dovetailing that with the DCS data. These are not only regional highways, but backroads and most of small towns. I actually

Re: [talk-au] How to map around blocked roads

2020-12-04 Thread Bob Cameron
I don't know sorry. Given that it is located in a large pasture rural area I would expect that it would never be enforced. Farm workers will drive by the easiest route. As I understand it when a rural road is closed it is often handed back to the owner of the surrounding or adjacent land,

[talk-au] How to map around blocked roads

2020-12-03 Thread Bob Cameron
I don't do a lot of mapping, so thought I'd better check. Where a road has been closed by a barrier, but people have driven around it, making their own road. Example - Far left of this frame, intersection of Eyre Highway and (unsealed) Cows Head Corner Rd, SA - south side of Eyre.

Re: [talk-au] Re-tag rural residential roads to unclassified?

2020-10-01 Thread Bob Cameron
For interest Ian. I am in that council area right now doing Mapillary stuff as I travel. Heading roughly from Daysdale to Jerilderie via Oakland on Monday if you'd like me to check anything! The current imagery wont be uploaded for a month or so. Bob On 2/10/20 2:43 pm, Little Maps wrote:

[talk-au] OSM automation projects? (Road surface)

2020-01-29 Thread Bob Cameron
This is just a being inquisitive question. Today I marked paved (was unpaved) route from Laggan to Taralga NSW after I drove it. I note that the underlying map (LPI?) actually showed the sections paved. Am I correct in assuming that there as a first pass project that marked paved roads from

Re: [talk-au] Question re tagging unpaved vs paved roads

2019-12-29 Thread Bob Cameron
:52 AM, Bob Cameron wrote: Hi The tagging guidelines don't quite seem to over this. I'd like to do it correctly. When a road is unpaved we use the surface=unpaved tag, the default (no tag) being paved. When an unpaved road is (roadwork) paved, should the tag be deleted or changed to paved? Thanks

[talk-au] Question re tagging unpaved vs paved roads

2019-12-29 Thread Bob Cameron
Hi The tagging guidelines don't quite seem to over this. I'd like to do it correctly. When a road is unpaved we use the surface=unpaved tag, the default (no tag) being paved. When an unpaved road is (roadwork) paved, should the tag be deleted or changed to paved? Thanks

Re: [talk-au] New imageries in AU

2019-11-08 Thread Bob Cameron
I don't know how useful/relevant this will be, but I am about 3 weeks from starting an upload of around 1.3TB Mapillary layer dashcam images. (4K size, at around 2FPS road speed) These are mainly sealed country roads (not a lot of urban data) around the continent. Where a town/village is

Re: [talk-au] What data is useful - request for ideas

2019-05-07 Thread Bob Cameron
Hi Phil My old 1280x720 was setup for a rear quarter view for traffic sign capture. I was advised that the angle and shutter raster delay (slant) made detection problematic so I don't upload. I will however give it a try at 90 degrees. It's a USB webcam On 8/5/19 9:44 am, Phil Wyatt wrote:

Re: [talk-au] What data is useful - request for ideas

2019-05-07 Thread Bob Cameron
Thanks Andrew I capture at 2fps with a BlackVue (via 30fps mp4). That was unfortunately a hard choice to do with the cost of the Internet connection. 5fps would have been nicer. Road name signs are then problematic not only from the framerate perspective, but that compression artefacts glug