Re: [Talk-ca] Mapping buildings in Canada by 2020

2017-11-23 Thread Tim Elrick
There are in fact, quite some German based mappers, mapping in Canada. So, you are right: let's just get more active mappers - worldwide; it is, however, still easier to activate them locally. I will pass on your positive experience with JOSM to my group for the next event. Cheers, Tim Am

Re: [Talk-ca] Mapping buildings in Canada by 2020

2017-11-23 Thread john whelan
>I would have to run a query now to find out if the relative number of active mappers is higher in one country than the other, but that's not my point. But how do you determine where a mapper lives and don't forget many armchair mappers map in a different location to where they live. JOSM and

Re: [Talk-ca] Mapping buildings in Canada by 2020

2017-11-23 Thread Tim Elrick
Hi John, Thanks for your feedback and background information. I think, we are on the same page. I am concerned with quality too, while mapping should remain enjoyable. We shied away from JOSM for newbies because it seemed more technical to my groups members. I personally like JOSM better, and

Re: [Talk-ca] Mapping buildings in Canada by 2020

2017-11-23 Thread john whelan
The issue is the quality of the mapping, nothing else. I attended one of these geoweek events and we used JOSM with the building_tool plugin. The mapping of buildings was accurate even though 75% of the mappers had never used JOSM before. There was no formal validation done but I verified each

[Talk-ca] Mapping buildings in Canada by 2020

2017-11-22 Thread Tim Elrick
Hello all, As you know Open Mapping Group McGill (OMG McGill) organized one of the mapathons last week for the town of Williams Lake, BC. For the turnout please turn to Julia's website published earlier today on the list. As a mentor of the group I might be the 'director' of this event according

Re: [Talk-ca] Mapping buildings in Canada by 2020

2017-11-21 Thread Julia C
Hello everyone! I am Julia Conzon, username Noznoc. I am currently *interning* at Mapbox until the end of November. My involvement in BC2020 came from my past work at Statistics Canada on the Crowdsourcing project and my interest in VGI. *I am not a representative for Mapbox (Mapbox is only

Re: [Talk-ca] Mapping buildings in Canada by 2020

2017-11-20 Thread Pierre Béland
Bonjour Charles, Je suis en contact avec le responsable de McGill. Effectivement, dans leurs cas ils prévoient réviser le travail avec les étudiants. Par contre dans le cadre de Mapathons, il est important de prévoir en général de bien sopporter les nouveaux contributeurs. Il me semble important

Re: [Talk-ca] Mapping buildings in Canada by 2020

2017-11-20 Thread Charles Basenga Kiyanda
Bonjour Pierre, Juste quelques précisions car j'ai été impliqué dans une de ces activités. Dans le cas de Williams Lake (projet 91), il a été utilisé pour un mapathon d'un nouveau groupe (Open Mapping Group McGill). C'est un nouveau groupe, mais qui me semble très bien organisé. Il ya eu trois

Re: [Talk-ca] Mapping buildings in Canada by 2020

2017-11-20 Thread Pierre Béland
John Je t'ai informé précédemment que je constatais pour Calgary des doublons d'adresse, celle-ci était ajoutée à la fois sur l'immeuble principal et le garage. Et vérifiant rapidement, j'ai vu des cas similaires à Ottawa. Je n'ai cependant pas analysé plus en détail la qualité des éditions

[Talk-ca] Mapping buildings in Canada by 2020

2017-11-20 Thread john whelan
>BC2020 *is not a StatCan project*. That comment came from Bjenk's old boss. I note that Pierre has identified some data quality issues from maperthons that appear to be associated with this. Is anyone organising this or is it just a dream in the air? In Ottawa we got some high quality mapping