Re: [WSG] Acronym tag usage

2007-05-16 Thread Sarah Isaacson
On 10/05/07, russ - maxdesign [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: The problem is that the abbr is poorly supported by IE5 and IE6. This means you may have to (1) revert to using the acronym element, or (2) place a span inside your abbr element and style this instead or (3) use JavaScript:

Re: [WSG] Acronym tag usage

2007-05-12 Thread David Hucklesby
On Fri, 11 May 2007 09:54:47 -0600, Dan Dorman wrote: On 5/11/07, Nick Fitzsimons [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: The OED seems pretty clear on the issue: abbreviation, noun: a shortened form of a word or phrase http://www.askoxford.com/concise_oed/abbreviation acronym, noun: a word formed from

Re: [WSG] Acronym tag usage

2007-05-12 Thread Nick Fitzsimons
On 12 May 2007, at 18:11:51, David Hucklesby wrote: If the OED says it, I'll buy it. Thanks, Nick! But be aware that common U.S. practice employs acronym for initialisms[1]. I must agree with the Yanks that inititalism does not roll easily off the tongue! [1]

Re: [WSG] Acronym tag usage

2007-05-11 Thread Nick Fitzsimons
On 11 May 2007, at 10:55:14, Mike at Green-Beast.com wrote: Of course I cannot effectively support this by looking it up on the web because the lines on this have been blurred significantly over time so the dictionaries are of little help. The OED seems pretty clear on the issue:

Re: [WSG] Acronym tag usage

2007-05-11 Thread Nick Fitzsimons
On 11 May 2007, at 09:56:54, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I'm not 100% sure this is the case, but what a screen reader _should_ do is to _read_ an acronym and to _spell out_ an abreviation. Even if that is not yet the case, it seems likely in the future, assuming that we all use the correct

Re: [WSG] Acronym tag usage

2007-05-11 Thread Mike at Green-Beast.com
Michael Brockington wrote: I'm not 100% sure this is the case, but what a screen reader _should_ do is to _read_ an acronym and to _spell out_ an abreviation. Even if that is not yet the case, it seems likely in the future, assuming that we all use the correct elements in the first

Re: [WSG] Acronym tag usage

2007-05-11 Thread Nick Fitzsimons
On 11 May 2007, at 13:10:28, [EMAIL PROTECTED] [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I don't see that this should be the case. For example, Ltd is a common UK abbreviation for the word Limited in the context of a Limited Liability Company, such as HyperGlobalMegaCorp Ltd. Another example would be Mr,

Re: [WSG] Acronym tag usage

2007-05-11 Thread Dan Dorman
On 5/11/07, Nick Fitzsimons [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: The OED seems pretty clear on the issue: abbreviation, noun: a shortened form of a word or phrase http://www.askoxford.com/concise_oed/abbreviation acronym, noun: a word formed from the initial letters of other words (e.g. laser,

Re: [WSG] Acronym tag usage

2007-05-10 Thread Rob Kirton
Craig. Only the first occurrence on each page is advisable -- Regards - Rob Raising web standards : http://ele.vation.co.uk Linking in with others: http://linkedin.com/in/robkirton On 10/05/07, Craig Bailey [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Just how extensive should our use of the acronym tag

RE: [WSG] Acronym tag usage

2007-05-10 Thread David Dorward
-Original Message- Just how extensive should our use of the acronym tag be? For example, if I have a page devoted to explaining what a Metropolitan Statistical Area (MSA) is, should I tag MSA with the acronym tag every single time it's mentioned? Isn't it just an abbreviation

RE: [WSG] Acronym tag usage

2007-05-10 Thread Craig Bailey
Quoting David Dorward [EMAIL PROTECTED]: Isn't it just an abbreviation rather then an acronym? If not, how do you pronounce it? Mesa? Good question. We pronounce it M-S-A. Should I be using the abbreviation tag? -- CRAIG BAILEY [EMAIL PROTECTED] 67 Union St. #2D, Winooski, Vt. 05404.1948

RE: [WSG] Acronym tag usage

2007-05-10 Thread michael.brockington
: [WSG] Acronym tag usage Craig. Only the first occurrence on each page is advisable -- Regards - Rob *** List Guidelines: http://webstandardsgroup.org/mail/guidelines.cfm Unsubscribe

Re: [WSG] Acronym tag usage

2007-05-10 Thread dwain
Craig Bailey wrote: Quoting David Dorward [EMAIL PROTECTED]: Isn't it just an abbreviation rather then an acronym? If not, how do you pronounce it? Mesa? Good question. We pronounce it M-S-A. Should I be using the abbreviation tag? no. msa is an acronym just like ms is an acronym for

Re: [WSG] Acronym tag usage

2007-05-10 Thread Nick Fitzsimons
On 10 May 2007, at 15:46:42, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Since most web pages are skimmed rather than being read in a traditional, linear fashion, it makes sense to use the full tag and attributes on every occasion. The traditional, print-based method was to only expand the abbreviation/acronym on

RE: [WSG] Acronym tag usage

2007-05-10 Thread michael.brockington
be impossible. Regards, Mike -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Nick Fitzsimons Sent: Thursday, May 10, 2007 4:11 PM To: wsg@webstandardsgroup.org Subject: Re: [WSG] Acronym tag usage On the other hand, screen-readers are generally configured

Re: [WSG] Acronym tag usage

2007-05-10 Thread Nick Fitzsimons
On 10 May 2007, at 16:10:55, Nick Fitzsimons wrote: On the other hand, screen-readers are generally configured by default to always read out the expansion of text marked up as an abbreviation (that is, the contents of the title attribute), so using abbr (or the non-standard acronym)

Re: [WSG] Acronym tag usage

2007-05-10 Thread Thierry Koblentz
From: Craig Bailey For example, if I have a page devoted to explaining what a Metropolitan Statistical Area (MSA) is, should I tag MSA with the acronym tag every single time it's mentioned? I'd use the element (abbr) each time MSA appears in the document and would expand the title on its

Re: [WSG] Acronym tag usage

2007-05-10 Thread Mike at Green-Beast.com
Hello Criag, Just how extensive should our use of the acronym tag be? Not very, IMO. We have some food for thought for you at Accessites. http://accessites.org/site/2007/02/dealing-with-acronyms-abbreviations/ Cheers. Mike

Re: [WSG] Acronym tag usage

2007-05-10 Thread Nick Fitzsimons
On 10 May 2007, at 16:08:49, russ - maxdesign wrote: Initialisms are subsets of abbreviations. So theoretically this should be marked up using the abbr element: abbr title= Metropolitan Statistical AreaM.S.A./abbr The problem is that the abbr is poorly supported by IE5 and IE6. This means

Re: [WSG] Acronym tag usage

2007-05-10 Thread Thierry Koblentz
From: Nick Fitzsimons On the other hand, screen-readers are generally configured by default to always read out the expansion of text marked up as an abbreviation (that is, the contents of the title attribute), so using abbr (or the non-standard acronym) repeatedly will force users of such

Re: [WSG] Acronym tag usage

2007-05-10 Thread Stuart Foulstone
Hi, The first time you use the acronym on each page it should be should accompanied with the full name. So this wouldn't need the acromym tag. Further uses of the acronym should be enclosed in the acronym tag. I usually use CSS to give it a dotted underline and change the cursor to a question

RE: [WSG] Acronym tag usage

2007-05-10 Thread David Dorward
-Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Thierry Koblentz Then I think it is a screen-reader issue as I believe there is no point to have this as default setting since documents are supposed to contain the expansion in plain text already...

Re: [WSG] Acronym tag usage

2007-05-10 Thread Nick Fitzsimons
On 10 May 2007, at 16:55:01, Thierry Koblentz wrote: From: Nick Fitzsimons On the other hand, screen-readers are generally configured by default to always read out the expansion of text marked up as an abbreviation (that is, the contents of the title attribute), so using abbr (or the

Re: [WSG] Acronym tag usage

2007-05-10 Thread Dan Dorman
On 5/10/07, David Dorward [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: (and its another initilism mislabelled as an acronym) Actually, that's correct usage of acronym, in terms of both HTML syntax and dictionary definition [1]. It just depends on how one thinks of an acronym. Incidentally, it it strikes me as

Re: [WSG] Acronym tag usage

2007-05-10 Thread Thierry Koblentz
From: David Dorward Then I think it is a screen-reader issue as I believe there is no point to have this as default setting since documents are supposed to contain the expansion in plain text already... Specify the expansion of each abbreviation or acronym in a document where it first

Re: [WSG] Acronym tag usage

2007-05-10 Thread Kevin Futter
On 11/5/07 1:08 AM, russ - maxdesign [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Well, technically this is not an acroynm or even a tag. :) An acronym is defined as a WORD formed from the initial letters of a multi-word name. The important point here is that an acronym must be a WORD - this means that the

Re: [WSG] Acronym tag usage

2007-05-10 Thread Dan Dorman
On 5/10/07, Kevin Futter [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Russ is indeed absolutely correct. These terms are confused all the time, and while colloquial use might have become blurred in recent years, their technical definitions have not. I'm genuinely interested in seeing some references on the proper

Re: [WSG] Acronym tag usage

2007-05-10 Thread Kevin Futter
On 11/5/07 10:23 AM, Dan Dorman [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: On 5/10/07, Kevin Futter [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Russ is indeed absolutely correct. These terms are confused all the time, and while colloquial use might have become blurred in recent years, their technical definitions have not. I'm

Re: [WSG] Acronym tag usage

2007-05-10 Thread Katrina
Oh, and I'd vote for just the first instance on each page - as others have suggested. I've been thinking about this, and I think that each time the abbreviation is mentioned it should be marked up. That is the only way to get across your specialised aural styles. Unless screen-readers