On Sun, Jan 22, 2012 at 11:18 AM, Jed Rothwell <jedrothw...@gmail.com>wrote:
> There is plenty of blame to go around. There certainly is. And most should go to investigators who don't provide clear and unequivocal, independently replicated and properly controlled and calibrated studies using the best state of the art methodology. You've been asked again and again to provide a SINGLE credible paper which shows robust heat production for a long period without the introduction of Joule heating or fresh fuel, thus proving without a doubt a nuclear process. I have yet to see such a paper. You expect critics to believe that LENR is real because of large volumes of papers which are convoluted, often badly written and always needlessly complex. That won't help LENR research. A single properly conducted experiment with robust results and no question of deception would have convinced everyone about Rossi or Defkalion specifically and LENR in general long ago. We're still waiting for it while you say it happened but you can't say who, what and where. We're still waiting for it while you make excuses for obvious tangential responses and evasive posts by Rossi and Defkalion. That is not what they and you should do to make the field credible. You should attack them and not the critics. The critics are the only ones who make sense. A single good result in LENR could not possibly be suppressed. In this internet age, there is no way it could happen. Look at all the attention and acclaim given to Rossi and for what?
