*They all have to agree with you. Because . . . Why exactly?* Because it is a truth of nature and the way the universe works.
The NRC does regulate X-Ray machines but only to insure that the radiation produced is below the statutory limits. If the LENR reactor is well shielded, and produces no radioactive isotopes then the NRC regulation has limited impact on the commercialization of the LENR reactor. If the competitors of the DGT reactor want to question its theory of operation, they must fund the research that attempts to disprove that theory. *Everyone will look at the present evidence, decide it is sufficient, and instantly dismiss a large chunk of conventional nuclear physics.* This is a new chemical reaction that is not in the purview of current nuclear physics. Cheers: Axil On Fri, Aug 31, 2012 at 4:26 PM, Jed Rothwell <[email protected]> wrote: > Axil Axil <[email protected]> wrote: > >> "Chemical transmutation," is what is going on. The physics commumity must >> come to terms with this reality. >> > They all have to agree with you. Because . . . Why exactly? > > >> Chemically Assisted Transmutation Reaction (CATR) reactions are produced >> through the action of electrons not neutrons. >> >> The NRC regulates the use of neutrons not electrons. >> >> If no neutrons are produced, there is no need for NRC regulation. >> > Two problems with this: > > 1. Celani did detect neutrons, so maybe they are produced. It will take a > lot more research to settle this issue. > > 2. Do you seriously expect that everyone in the scientific establishment, > every regulator, and every lawmaker will agree with you about this? Do you > think there will be no debate? No funds allocated to determine whether you > are right or wrong? Everyone will look at the present evidence, decide it > is sufficient, and instantly dismiss a large chunk of conventional nuclear > physics. > > - Jed > >
