Rob Miller wrote:
those of us planning out the next Plone releases are in a bit of a
bind. we really want to make use of GenericSetup's newer
Z3-interface-based means of defining import and export handlers, so
that we can start work on rewriting our migration engine to use XML
import and export, and so we can keep up w/ CMF 2.0 as it moves forward.
to this end, it would be very useful for us to have a 1.5-compatible
version of CMF that makes use of the newer Generic/CMFSetup semantics.
this would allow us to use the new site creation code (which we've
nearly completed) in our next release without breaking backwards
compatibility with the existing add-on products. this would also make
it easier to keep up w/ CMF trunk development w/o having to maintain
two radically different branches of Plone. CMF 2.X would be required,
of course, with the subsequent release.
how do folks feel about this? (note that we, i.e. the plone
developers, are willing to do the work.) would you be willing to have
an additional 1.5 release, or perhaps a 1.6 release, which includes
these changes? our current tentative release schedule has a Plone
alpha in late december, beta in february, release some time in march.
CMF 1.5 is Zope 2.7 compatible. A Zope 2.7 compatible version of
GenericSetup would be a lot of work and it would loose the new semantics
because they depend on Five features.
But if Plone 2.2 requires Zope 2.8 it should be easy to use CMF 1.5 with
GenericSetup 2.0 instead of CMFSetup 1.5. Except for the CMF specific
handlers that should work out of the box.
A CMF 1.6 release that requires Zope 2.8 and essentially bundles CMF 1.5
with GenericSetup 2.0 (and compatible CMF setup handlers) might be a
Hm seen in that light, I also have a need for a CMF 1.6 that drops
support for Zope 2.7. The reason are the recent changes I proposed to
support Five 1.2, which need super() to work properly. So it needs Zope 2.8.
GenericSetup is still a moving target. I would not create a branch for
1.6 before 2.0 has stabilized.
+1 on branching CMF 1.6 soon, with the goal of:
- dropping support for Zope 2.7
- allowing Five 1.2 events activated to work, even if it doesn't
*require* Five 1.2 events
- be closer to CMF 2.0 w.r.t. setup.
Florent Guillaume, Nuxeo (Paris, France) Director of R&D
+33 1 40 33 71 59 http://nuxeo.com [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Zope-CMF maillist - Zope-CMF@lists.zope.org
See http://collector.zope.org/CMF for bug reports and feature requests