2015-02-25 11:07 GMT+01:00 moltonel 3x Combo <molto...@gmail.com>: > > How will removing any "fixme" tag make the actual _data_ in OSM better? > > It'll just make it harder for people editing it to determine what is > > good data and what isn't. > > +1 >
I'm willing to believe that a particular fixme value is useless > (either because it was fixed without removing the tag or because it is > now deemed not a problem or because QA tools do a better job of > pointing out the error), but you'll have to make the case for each > individual value. None of the values in your "get rid" list are > obviously useless to me, please explain. > +1 > > The fact that something has a "low chance to get fixed" is irrelevant. > +1, in any case it seems more likely that the problems gets fixed with a fixme tag than without. > > Now here's my shortlist of fixme tags that can be simply deleted, with > explanation : > * fixme=yes > Provides no information > -1, it indicates a certain overaverage probability of some (not further specified) problem > * fixme=name and variants of add_full_address when QA tools agree that > a name or address is missing > The QA tools do a better job of pointing those out. But watch out > for "fixme=name" that > really mean "the tagged name is wrong" for example. > +1 cheers, Martin
_______________________________________________ talk mailing list talk@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk
