Hi Rawat, I understand you are waging lone battle here today:-) .Let me just get you right . You are saying.. JA music is good but it didn't the fit the nature of the movie JA. Now could you please get a little in-depth here.could you clarify , what you would have expected in place of those each and every 5 songs of JA ( considering AG has has given 5 slots to rahman in the movie and asked him to compose songs for those situations) .
1.Azeem-o-shan 2.Jashn-e-bahara 3.Kwaja mere kwaja 4.In lamhon ke 5.Man mohana. Could you explain more on these 5 situations and what kind of songs would have replaced these each songs . I am sure , there is something which you have felt very strong at to look at the music of JA as an out of sync compisition for the movie.i just want to know it by song by song.Becuase i am of the opinion that azeem-o-shaan really evoked the mood of the situation , same as Kwaja and jashn-e etc....for me i am unable to take even an example of songs which would have better replaced any of these ones here , situationally , musically. Regards Jamshid --- On Sat, 7/19/08, V S Rawat <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: From: V S Rawat <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Subject: Re: [arr] Re: ARR not composing for Ashutosh Gowariker's next? To: [email protected] Date: Saturday, July 19, 2008, 2:43 AM On 7/19/2008 5:36 AM India Time, _Chord_ wrote: > I think ARR's songs have some of the best picturization and treatment > with Ashutosh's films. I want ARR and Ashutosh to continue together. > They make a great team. And if JA was indeed a "shit, purposeless > movie" as you say, it wouldn't have labeled a box office hit and > garnered good reviews from most critics. Ashutosh is one of India's > finest directors. Should I give the list of major movies that were box office hits during the last 30 or 10 years. And critics? When anybody writes a bad thing about movie/ music, guys here are prompt to label that critic Anti-ARR. -- V
