very well said. I think AG is the second best after Mani when it comes to give the right visualization to ARR's songs. Picturizations of Yeh jo des, Saawariya, Chale chalo, Ghanan ghanan, Azeem-o-shaan and Khwaja were really great, near perfect. And those for O ri chori and Radha kaise na jale were also pretty good.
--- In [email protected], "rayrai2k" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > Take Lagaan.. wasn't the picurization the best? AG had given > importance to every note of ARR. The use of Lezims in Ghanan.. the > multiple voice for multiple actors. Radha kaise na Jale so far the > best... O re Chori you might have to look for once again. > I had always felt ARR when he works with AG that if ARR gives a > virtual visualization AG give the sound felt through visuals. They > collaborate very well with each other.. Think of Khwajaji. Azeemo > Shaanshansha was indeed well pictuarized. The righ instuments were > brought to the foreground when the sound appeared. Though > Jashnebahara & Manmohana came in parts it was picuarized with a > proper background. So no critic ever said the songs slowed down the > movie as they did for GURU. Dont you remember how many critics ARR's > music was a speed breaker? pal pal hain bhaari was given proper > justice. I liked the way Saawariyan was done it was more touching. > Try to remember the sequence for Yeh jo des the scene just before > that He was in other words did justice for songs. > > > > > --- In [email protected], V S Rawat <vsrawat@> wrote: > > > > On 7/19/2008 9:28 AM India Time, _Pradeepan R_ wrote: > > > > > Sorry,. dont agree with you. > > > AG is one of the few movie makers who know what a > typical 'musical' is.. > > > And ARR loves those kind of movie makers. > > > Swades was awesome in terms of songs/BGM fitting with the movie. > > > > > > > Could you highlight some movies of ARRs in which songs didn't fit > with > > the movie? > > > > Say, what about Guru? Did songs fit or not? > > > > What about Yuva, Nayak, RDB, Bombay, Dil Se? Did songs fit or not? > > > > or not even entire movie, but any particular song that didn't fit > on > > screen? Mangal Pandey? > > > > or do you mean ARRs all songs fitted perfectly well in all his > movies? > > Hmm. That is telling enough. > > > > -- > > V > > >
