Can you put that on the Umbrella thread?  More for clean archiving and 
collecting everything in one spot.


> On Feb 13, 2018, at 8:25 AM, Mark Struberg <> wrote:
> Hi folks!
> Mike had a grat response on the imact and potential downsides of becoming an 
> Umbrella project.
> I asked for his permisson to forward, so here we go.
> Txs Mike for the additional input!
> LieGrue,
> strub
>> Von: Mike Kienenberger <>
>> Betreff: Aw: Implementing Microprofile JWT
>> Datum: 13. Februar 2018 um 16:08:24 MEZ
>> An:
>> As the Chair of an umbrella project (MyFaces), I strongly recommend
>> against making umbrella projects.
>> Umbrella projects end up with a lot of unloved components, and this
>> happens without anyone realizing it as it is difficult to have the
>> same oversight for subprojects as there is for a TLP.
>> There is going to be some point where smaller items are too small to
>> handle individually, but you should have the mindset that whenever a
>> subproject gets enough community to support it that it should
>> immediately spin off to its own TLP.
>> Right now, MyFaces has 11 subprojects.   Only two of them are actively
>> developed.  The people working on several of these subprojects drifted
>> away and no one noticed because it wasn't important to the remaining
>> people.   Most of those who remain are, rightly so, not willing to
>> devote volunteer time to something they have little-to-no involvement
>> with.  The other PMC members will still do it grudgingly but as a
>> burden.   Even "retiring" these subprojects is not possible because no
>> one is willing to spend the time to make that happen.
>> To recap, my recommendations to the PMC of an umbrella project would be:
>> - Require subproject reports.   Have them due two weeks before the TLP
>> board report is due.   Merge them into the TLP board report.   Use
>> similar criteria to determine subproject health.  The PMC becomes "the
>> board" within their domain.
>> - Split subprojects off to TLPs immediately as soon as a sustainable
>> community develops.  This might be before code exists.
>> - Have a plan beforehand on when and how you are going to "retire"
>> subprojects which are no longer maintained.  You are going to need
>> your own attic concept.

Reply via email to