jkesselm commented on code in PR #1:
URL: https://github.com/apache/xalan-test/pull/1#discussion_r1189227238


##########
tests/bugzilla/Bugzilla1266.java:
##########
@@ -74,52 +94,58 @@ public void execute(Datalet d)
         Templates templates = null;
         Transformer transformer = null;
         try
-        {
-            factory = TransformerFactory.newInstance();
-            logger.logMsg(Logger.STATUSMSG, "About to factory.newTemplates(" + 
QetestUtils.filenameToURL("identity.xsl") + ")");
-            templates = factory.newTemplates(new 
StreamSource(QetestUtils.filenameToURL("identity.xsl")));
-            transformer = templates.newTransformer();
-
-            // Set the errorListener and validate it
-            transformer.setErrorListener(loggingErrorListener);
-            if (transformer.getErrorListener() == loggingErrorListener)
-                logger.checkPass("set/getErrorListener on transformer");
-            else
-                logger.checkFail("set/getErrorListener on transformer");
-
-            logger.logMsg(Logger.STATUSMSG, "Reproduce Bugzilla1266 - warning 
due to bad output props not propagated");
-            logger.logMsg(Logger.STATUSMSG, 
"transformer.setOutputProperty(encoding, illegal-encoding-value)");
-            transformer.setOutputProperty("encoding", 
"illegal-encoding-value");
-
-            logger.logMsg(Logger.STATUSMSG, "about to transform(...)");
-            transformer.transform(new 
StreamSource(QetestUtils.filenameToURL("identity.xml")), 
-                                  new StreamResult("Bugzilla1266.out"));
-            logger.logMsg(Logger.STATUSMSG, "after transform(...)");
-            logger.logMsg(Logger.STATUSMSG, "loggingErrorListener after 
transform:" + loggingErrorListener.getQuickCounters());
-
-            // Validate that one warning (about illegal-encoding-value) should 
have been reported
-            int[] errCtr = loggingErrorListener.getCounters();
-            if (errCtr[LoggingErrorListener.TYPE_WARNING] > 0)
-                logger.checkPass("At least one Warning listned to for 
illegal-encoding-value");
-            else
-                logger.checkFail("At least one Warning listned to for 
illegal-encoding-value");
+            {
+                factory = TransformerFactory.newInstance();
+                logger.logMsg(Logger.STATUSMSG, "About to 
factory.newTemplates(" + QetestUtils.filenameToURL("identity.xsl") + ")");
+                templates = factory.newTemplates(new 
StreamSource(QetestUtils.filenameToURL("identity.xsl")));
+                transformer = templates.newTransformer();
+
+                // Set the errorListener and validate it
+                transformer.setErrorListener(loggingErrorListener);
+                if (transformer.getErrorListener() == loggingErrorListener)
+                    logger.checkPass("set/getErrorListener on transformer");
+                else {
+                    logger.checkFail("set/getErrorListener on transformer");
+                   throw new Exception("failed set/getErrorListener on 
transformer");
+                }
+
+                logger.logMsg(Logger.STATUSMSG, "Reproduce Bugzilla1266 - 
warning due to bad output props not propagated");
+                logger.logMsg(Logger.STATUSMSG, 
"transformer.setOutputProperty(encoding, illegal-encoding-value)");
+                transformer.setOutputProperty("encoding", 
"illegal-encoding-value");
+
+                logger.logMsg(Logger.STATUSMSG, "about to transform(...)");
+                transformer.transform(new 
StreamSource(QetestUtils.filenameToURL("identity.xml")), 
+                                      new StreamResult("Bugzilla1266.out"));
+                logger.logMsg(Logger.STATUSMSG, "after transform(...)");
+                logger.logMsg(Logger.STATUSMSG, "loggingErrorListener after 
transform:" + loggingErrorListener.getQuickCounters());
+
+                // Validate that one warning (about illegal-encoding-value) 
should have been reported
+                int[] errCtr = loggingErrorListener.getCounters();
+                            
+                if (errCtr[LoggingErrorListener.TYPE_WARNING] > 0)
+                    logger.checkPass("At least one Warning listned to for 
illegal-encoding-value");
+                else {
+                    logger.checkFail("No Warning reported by listener for 
illegal-encoding-value");
+                   throw new Exception("No Warning reported by listener for 
illegal-encoding-value");
+                }
                 
-            // Validate the actual output file as well: in this case, 
-            //  the stylesheet should still work
-            CheckService fileChecker = new XHTFileCheckService();
-            fileChecker.check(logger, 
-                    new File("Bugzilla1266.out"), 
-                    new File("identity.gold"), 
-                    "transform of good xsl w/bad output props into: " + 
"Bugzilla1266.out");
+                // Validate the actual output file as well: in this case, 
+                //  the stylesheet should still work
+                CheckService fileChecker = new XHTFileCheckService();
+                fileChecker.check(logger, 
+                                  new File("Bugzilla1266.out"), 

Review Comment:
   Sigh. Code style conventions. 
   
   This is exactly the same style (vertical alignment of arguments) used 
elsewhere in that same .java file. If we're gonna object to it, we should be 
reformatting the entire testcase to whatever our established preferred style is.



-- 
This is an automated message from the Apache Git Service.
To respond to the message, please log on to GitHub and use the
URL above to go to the specific comment.

To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscr...@xalan.apache.org

For queries about this service, please contact Infrastructure at:
us...@infra.apache.org


---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscr...@xalan.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: dev-h...@xalan.apache.org

Reply via email to