On 11/2/2012 5:29 AM, Platonist Guitar Cowboy wrote:
On Thu, Nov 1, 2012 at 10:55 PM, Stephen P. King
<stephe...@charter.net <mailto:stephe...@charter.net>> wrote:
On 11/1/2012 12:23 PM, Platonist Guitar Cowboy wrote:
Don't get me started on reductionism! I don't believe in it
as I don't believe in ontologically primitive objects that
have particular properties.
Then I don't see how you can make an ontological bet. You're at
the table, betting on 24 or whatever, but you won't place your chips.
Where is the Doctor's Office? I want to make an appointment!
Until its tech is proven, I am taking Dr. McCoy's stance:
That's funny. I'll follow you. But I know that show and all its
incarnations since my childhood. Bad red herring to evade the bet
The thing about "where is the Doctors office?" is a guarded
agreement on my saying Yes to the Doctor. So, I do accept the betting.
This fictional universe, and the doctor, accept UDA step 8 eventually,
as I will demonstrate through examples:
1) The transporter did work in the end, so the original series does
assume comp in this sense.
2) Kirk is probably not aware of reconstitution delay, when he gets
back, and they've all learned to live with this weirdness.
3) McCoy, or the doctor, also uses the transporter throughout the
series. So if you took an appointment and told him that you don't want
to be transported and cited this video: "Just get up on that platform
and do it. We all do and it works in this fictional universe. Or are
you out of your Vulcan mind?"
4) McCoy is simultaneously "occupied" by his soul and Spock's soul in
"search for Spock" which slowly kills him + makes him act very
strangely until Spock's soul is given a new body in Vulcan.
=> Dr. McCoy understands after this, that his materialist bias is
offset by Vulcan's spiritual practice, who are all logicians since
childhood, and that spirit is transferable and independent of
particular physical bodies.
5) With the Doctor in "Voyager" extension of the show (who is a pure
medical doctor hologram/program, but realizes his universality and
demands his freedom, which the crew eventually grant him) => program,
strings of code, becomes conscious.
6) And the total denial of physical resources, in line with UDA step
8, needed for consciousness is here:
The species "Q" in "the next Generation" version of the show,
completely eliminate the need for physical resources to maintain or
run them. This species is clearly not limited by physical resources,
space, or time restraints.
Thus, your portrayal of McCoy's stance is not faithful to the
fictional universe of that television series, which does support Step
8 on numerous occasions :)
I agree with a weak version Step 8, one that allows for the
"appearance of a robust physical universe" but in the way I explained in
my posts yesterday.
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups
"Everything List" group.
To post to this group, send email to firstname.lastname@example.org.
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to
For more options, visit this group at