--- In [email protected], Vaj <vajradh...@...> wrote: > > We have EEG evidence of Samadhi in Patanjali > yogins, so we know what it looks like. If you can't replicate those > findings in students, I would hope that would be a point of concern
Vaj - can you not see the methodological flaw in this? It's circular. Let me re-phase your statement slightly: We have tested these guys and found a pattern. We see that that pattern matches what samadhi looks like. Therefore we now know what samadhi looks like. Groan... Or is it: We don't know what samadhi is, but whatever it is, we know these guys have got it (how, if we don't know what samadhi is?). So now we've measured them, and as a result we now know what samadhi is. Groan...
