Agreed Tom. A well written standardized dungeon crawl, ---- as in Eamon can be a fun litle diversion, but for a true exploration setting I deffinately want more background and detail. I think many writers, (particularly of pvp heavy grinders), have been very lazy in just snipping superficial elements from tolkeen without actually writing any propper details of the world's overall plot, how the adventure figures into things, or what races actually are.

Once again though Sryth, Arborell (where there's even an entire gamebook, and upcoming series playing as a non human race), and the Lone wolf series have all done this very well.

But world building in scifi is something we've just not seen yet. Strictly speaking, the final fantasy games, ----- particularly later entries in the series are actually much closer to scifi than traditional sf, sinse the world, technology and history is very much magitech, ---- magic, robots, airshipsand weapons ranging from firearms through swords to lasers.

this was one reason my first big writing project was a novelization of the Ps1 rpg Xenogears, that I found the world so intreaguing.

Again though, this is a style of world and game we've just not seen done in text, ---- other than a few hints in lone wolf.

I'd personally be more in favor of a freshly created world for the game than using an existing one. Much as I'm a fan of Doctor who, Startrek etc (and rapidly becoming a bigger fan of the starwars universe), imho discovery of the world itself and it's races is one of the most fun elements of a game. That's why i love the background entries in Sryth.

On the other hand, in a pre-done world, you do have the fun of exploring locations such as the jedi temple or ds9 yourself, with your own character, rather than just having to sit back and watch or read about them.

Personally, if it was me I'd be more in favour of a unique game world, ---- but again, i'm not the one doing the programming, and it's just a difference of style I think.

Btw, i am at the moment planning a gamebook for the june Arborell competition. I have a section plan, plopt and unique setting myself fixed, and it's only necessary now to write in the actual adventure pages (which to me is the fun bit), ---- which will probably be my contribution to world building games I think.

Beware the Grue!


Gamers mailing list __
If you want to leave the list, send E-mail to
You can make changes or update your subscription via the web, at
All messages are archived and can be searched and read at
If you have any questions or concerns regarding the management of the list,
please send E-mail to

Reply via email to