On 06/24/2011 12:59 PM, Ferenc Szekely wrote: > On 06/24/2011 10:29 AM, David Greaves wrote: >> >> We need to chat on how to do this. >> >> I think the vote system should be returning the vote to the BOSS process >> and then the process should apply valid votes. This allows for other >> voting mechanisms to be introduced and means the logic is not tied to a >> web system (and changes don't need a redeployment). It also means that >> we can have an independent 'get metadata' task in the process that talks >> to the OBS (or maybe later talks to some other system). >> > MeeGo Apps implements the OCS interface and can receive votes (and > comments) from any system (via HTTP) as soon as we finish the "Comments" > [1] implementation of the OCS spec. > > We can tell BOSS about a new vote coming in, but then BOSS should also > be able to tell us current votes or notify when a new vote arrived > through an other channel, so all other 'clients' can sync their own data > (if they wanted to do so). > > I see no problem that a web service receives all the votes as long as it > supports an open standard. > > How BOSS would implement a public interface for getting votes etc? > Well, we are probably talking about two different things here. I had a chat with Niels and got enlightened.
David, I understand now that 'votes' here in this email thread refer to a result of an individual QA review done by person X.Y. And then the process roughly goes like: - MeeGo Apps will tell each 'vote' to BOSS - BOSS implements the "approval" or "rejection" logic - BOSS promotes or demotes an application Up until today I thought that based on all review results it will be MeeGo Apps to decide if an app has passed the QA review or not. This is what I spoke about in San Francisco [1], but apparently that was not the a common understanding. Glad, that it has been clarified now, before work was done. Cheers, ferenc [1] Slide 13 http://sf2011.meego.com/sites/all/files/slides/meegosf_meego_apps_16x9-2_0.odp _______________________________________________ MeeGo-community mailing list [email protected] http://lists.meego.com/listinfo/meego-community http://wiki.meego.com/Mailing_list_guidelines
