Quoting Heather Perella <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>:

>      [Platt]
> > I wonder: 1) Is there a requirement that the inmates
> work to provide > some of their own necessities (food,
> shelter, clothing).
> 
>      You see this has to do with safety.  Fairness is
> a perspective that leads an event to be safe or
> dangerous.  Here's an example.  In this culture we
> have houses.  If you don't have a house, then your
> living in the streets.  Before you live in the
> streets, and are called a worthless, no effort lazy
> bum, then you put effort into getting a house.  You'll
> work for years and years to keep a house.  In fact,
> most people go into debt and pay interest (thus extra
> $) to have a house.  This is social pressure. 
> Remember how Amerindians were moved onto reservations
> into houses.  This is the U.S. and any decent U.S.
> citizen must have a house.  Now, in this culture if
> you are not able to keep a house or rent from an
> apartment, then the pressure's on.  Major social
> pressure.  Who said we have to live in a house?  How
> about a tent, box, cave, etc...  To not have a house,
> or to foresee one losing their own house, I believe
> fear and/or despair would arise.  Would you differ
> from this conclusion?  Let's start with this first and
> then move on in our discussion if you would.

If for no other reason I think most people would prefer to live in a house with
plumbing for the health of themselves and their children. Sure, there is
some social pressure to have a nice house, but there's social pressure to do
a lot of things, like earn a living instead of depending on others for the
necessities of life. So yes, I differ from your conclusion about owning a house
being a source of fear and despair. In fact, home ownership has been a growing
financial asset for millions of people over the years. But it does require work
to build and maintain a home.    

     [Platt]
> > and 2) is a religious or spiritual program part of
> the therapy, such as > a 10-step program?
> 
>      As to religion being part of the program, where I
> work the residents can go to church on Sunday
> (Presbyterian) or stay back on the unit and do a
> value's clarification (non-religious) or some other
> religious activity.  Also, Bible study is once a week,
> if the residents want to go.  Bible study on the unit
> I work is during gym time.

I mistakingly said 10-step instead of 12-step program. It's my understanding
that 12-step programs have a high degree (relatively) of success in dealing
not only with alcohol and drug addictions, but also behaviorial problems.
The programs are semi-religious because one of the steps is: "Made a decision
to turn our will and our lives over to the care of God as we understood Him."
Perhaps, if your facility is government funded, such a program would be 
considered an "establishment of religion."

Platt

 


-------------------------------------------------
This mail sent through IMP: http://horde.org/imp/
Moq_Discuss mailing list
Listinfo, Unsubscribing etc.
http://lists.moqtalk.org/listinfo.cgi/moq_discuss-moqtalk.org
Archives:
http://lists.moqtalk.org/pipermail/moq_discuss-moqtalk.org/
http://moq.org.uk/pipermail/moq_discuss_archive/

Reply via email to