Orginally this comes from itchka,and this was on 2014.0 specification list, see wiki. We discussed this on TC meeting, and conclusion was that Council need a final decision.
Wysłano z BlackBerry® w Orange -----Original Message----- From: Rolf Pedersen <[email protected]> Date: Sun, 20 Apr 2014 08:52:19 To: <[email protected]>; Cooker OpenMandriva<[email protected]> Subject: Re: [OM Cooker] Odp.: Re: Questions! I am not disagreeing with the decision to be safe from potential for legal action. I did mistake the author of the proposal as you, as the linked Loomio page starts with, "From TPG". https://www.loomio.org/d/t3NUhoBu/libdvdcss but I can see, now, "Raphaël Jadot <https://www.loomio.org/u/H9V7EcJg/raphael-jadot> created a proposal: Include libdvdcss in main repos 3 months ago" So, I am in agreement with the ultimate decision against this proposal. Rolf On 04/20/2014 08:40 AM, Tomasz Paweł Gajc wrote: > Sure we can include all stuff what is patented. I wonder who will then take > the responsibility of further court suits, or any further charges? > Wysłano z BlackBerry® w Orange > > -----Original Message----- > From: Rolf Pedersen <[email protected]> > Sender: [email protected]: Sun, 20 Apr 2014 08:28:15 > To: Cooker OpenMandriva<[email protected]> > Reply-To: Cooker OpenMandriva <[email protected]> > Subject: Re: [OM Cooker] Odp.: Re: Questions! > > My read is that TPG proposed inclusion of libdvdcss in main/iso and > disagree votes prevailed. At any rate, I use VLC a lot, along with > others, but I realize I have to adjust to what development provides, in > OMV or elsewhere. The pulse of *this* community member is that the > profanity, condescending remarks, and personal attacks are neither > productive nor welcome. > Rolf > > On 04/20/2014 08:16 AM, [email protected] wrote: >> Il 20/04/2014 16:33, Tomasz Paweł Gajc ha scritto: >>> This was raised by TC to support libdvdcss and friend libraries to >>> support DVD play. OMA Council dedided this is still a patent threat >>> to our community and we can not provide such software. >>> >>> To cut that discussion, our products are FREE and support FREE/LIBRE >>> software. >> Ok , It is romp OSS? Or qmplay2? they work out of the box ... all i'm >> seeing here is your stubbornness in keeping vlc... as i saw bero and >> proyvind ware much more >> open to debate , this is a problem and hide under a decision that was >> taken outside the real world >> is childish , but since you are the big man here and I ain't nobody, >> of course you have right >> to do whatever you please, seeing this , MANDRIVA SA -like attitude of >> yours i'm glad that >> I'm just an outsider,... and now c'mon , honestly what would be my >> dark and devious >> purposes in dropping that vlc crap? >> qmplay2 will be the default player on lxde-qt, very well maintained, >> romp is the best , no need further more comments, >> smplayer no comments, why you want the vlc crap so bad? Did they pay you? >> On what serious linux distro is vlc the default player? >> all players based on mplayer or ffpaly support out of the box dvd >> play... >> It might be OPENmandriva but the old habits never change.... and you >> TPG is one of the >> "old habits", you would do a perfect team with A.N and Misc. >> A open minded association would take the user side and not >> his own commodity ... >> I hate mdv and all what it was about it , and now you are acting like >> they would.... >> I just wonder with how many end users are you in touch , just to feel >> the pulse of the day...??? >> For your information top of the pops is multimedia, first thing searched >> by a normal user, ..and this libdvdcss excuse is bullshit ( and i'm >> polite here), >> no need for close/restricted player /codecs in order to have a >> full-optional >> default media player, an i'm more then sure that if you bring this to >> your council >> will agree with dropping vlc... if no serious distro adopt vlc as default >> must be a reason... >> IMO you are still believe that that small amount of users that we have >> will accept everything you impose them , then you can be proud , >> MANDRVA SA >> lives in you. >> bleah I'm out of here. >> >> PS: >> Blacky might be a "bigmouth" and the installer can not be changed in time >> but he has a point, you justify your decisions with your proposals.... >> >> https://www.loomio.org/d/t3NUhoBu/libdvdcss >> From TPG: >> one of 2014.0 specs needs Council decision: >> bla bla bla >> >> and we stuck with vlc ... did they pay you well ??? did they hire there? >> >> I've being around long enough to read the subtitles.... >> I might be a nobody but you just pissed this nobody off... >> And long live mandriva s.a ....bleah.. >> >> I'm really thrilled to be part of the team... >> >> Greetings >> >> ___________________ >> >> MRB ain't no shit >> >> Rosalinux.Ro >> >> Mandrivausers.Ro >> >> ________________ >> >> Talk is cheap, show me the code. >> >> > >
