[nlug] Re: DSL: Is it worth switching?

2009-02-04 Thread Perkins, Jerry
xor wrote: > Also, I've heard that Comcast will drop your rate for a few months if > you call them & want to drop their service. Is that true? Two weeks ago I called them and they did not offer a break in the rate. But two months ago we were going to drop Dish and the wife talked them down

[nlug] Re: DSL: Is it worth switching?

2009-02-04 Thread Jim Peterson
We have both Comcast and AT&T lines here, 3MB service on each. The AT&T(BellSouth) DSL is far more reliable for us than the Comcast has been, mostly due to faulty equipment in our 'grid square.' Our BellSouth line hasn't gone down in the past year and a third (my time here), while the Comcast side

[nlug] Re: DSL: Is it worth switching?

2009-02-04 Thread Richard Thomas
Andrew Farnsworth wrote: > If the phone company / DSL provider has their termination equipment in > your backyard, you should be able to get 24 Mbit DSL (provided it is > DSL2+). If it is "nearby" then you may get 16 Mbit, then speeds drop > with distance out to 0.5 Mbit at about 3 miles. Find o

[nlug] Re: DSL: Is it worth switching?

2009-02-04 Thread Andrew Farnsworth
If the phone company / DSL provider has their termination equipment in your backyard, you should be able to get 24 Mbit DSL (provided it is DSL2+). If it is "nearby" then you may get 16 Mbit, then speeds drop with distance out to 0.5 Mbit at about 3 miles. Find out where exactly the termination

[nlug] Re: DSL: Is it worth switching?

2009-02-04 Thread Chris McQuistion
What kind of download speed can you get over DSL? On downloads I regularly get over 1000 kbps, and this is on Comcast's lowest speed plan. I used to have their top speed plan and could get 1500-2000 kbps on downloads. I was under the impression that DSL tops out at around 6 mbps. Comcast has cab

[nlug] Re: DSL: Is it worth switching?

2009-02-04 Thread Perkins, Jerry
Chris McQuistion wrote: > I would stick with Comcast. Their service is MUCH faster than DSL. It has been my experience that DSL is faster. This is from 6 years of experience using both systems. In fact on big downloads DSL is always faster EVEN when I am connected via X-Forwarding which put

[nlug] Re: DSL: Is it worth switching?

2009-02-03 Thread Jack Coats
I agree, that for the most part, cable companies have not figured out that 2-way communications means consistent availability. AT&T has been known to forget that (The great Lilly Tomlin operator skits were based more on perceived reality from many peoples experience than fiction.) from time t

[nlug] Re: DSL: Is it worth switching?

2009-02-03 Thread Daniel Owen
I would say it depends. I left Comcast and moved to AT&T ADSL about a year ago and have been very happy. I left because Comcast service in my neighborhood had gotten to a point where I was loosing service every 3-4 weeks. The final kick for me was when I called to report an outage and the automated

[nlug] Re: DSL: Is it worth switching?

2009-02-02 Thread Chris McQuistion
I would stick with Comcast. Their service is MUCH faster than DSL. Here is the trick to getting a lower bill. I just did this a couple months ago. Call Comcast and ask for the customer retention dept. They will try to argue with you and see if they can help you with your problem. Stick to your

[nlug] Re: DSL: Is it worth switching?

2009-02-02 Thread xor
I forgot to say, that I am about 2 miles from the Bellsouth CO that would service the DSL if I signed up. On Feb 2, 3:20 pm, xor wrote: > I currently have Comcast cable as an internet provider,  and have had > Comcast for the better part of 10 years. > > Currently AT&T is offering a $125 rebate