RE: automatic upgrades via install + drakautoinst WAS: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-17 Thread Mark Stewart
Hi David, The drakautoinst method I'm imagining would avoid all the issues and (most of the) complications involved with using urpmi (or apt-get or similiar program) to upgrade an installation. In terms of package management the I've been trying that method more or less with success

Re: automatic upgrades via install + drakautoinst WAS: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-16 Thread David E. Fox
The drakautoinst method I'm imagining would avoid all the issues and (most of the) complications involved with using urpmi (or apt-get or similiar program) to upgrade an installation. In terms of package management the I've been trying that method more or less with success for many different

Re: automatic upgrades via install + drakautoinst WAS: [expert]Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-16 Thread Vox
This time [EMAIL PROTECTED] (David E. Fox) becomes daring and writes: The drakautoinst method I'm imagining would avoid all the issues and (most of the) complications involved with using urpmi (or apt-get or similiar program) to upgrade an installation. In terms of package management the

RE: automatic upgrades via install + drakautoinst WAS: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-12 Thread Mark Stewart
: automatic upgrades via install + drakautoinst WAS: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity Is it possible to use drakautoinst to automate an effectively upgrade a machine from one release to another? Rather than try to use the upgrade Should be. I've wondered the same thing, although

Re: automatic upgrades via install + drakautoinst WAS: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-11 Thread David E. Fox
Is it possible to use drakautoinst to automate an effectively upgrade a machine from one release to another? Rather than try to use the upgrade Should be. I've wondered the same thing, although not in the context of drakautoinst. Debian (for instance) allows you to do a dist-upgrade (aka

Re: automatic upgrades via install + drakautoinst WAS: [expert]Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-11 Thread Jack Coates
On Tue, 2003-03-11 at 21:22, David E. Fox wrote: Is it possible to use drakautoinst to automate an effectively upgrade a machine from one release to another? Rather than try to use the upgrade Should be. I've wondered the same thing, although not in the context of drakautoinst. Debian

Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-06 Thread Michael Adams
There was talk about updates being available for this product for three years. But at present i only see a one year support cycle. http://www.mandrakesoft.com/products/corporate-server and http://www.mail-archive.com/[EMAIL PROTECTED]/msg65843.html from which i quote quote From: Vincent Danen

Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-06 Thread Michael Adams
Whups, i should finish reading the posts before replying. Sorry Vincent. On Thu, 06 Mar 2003 08:26, Vincent Danen wrote: On Tue Mar 04, 2003 at 10:52:18PM -0500, Jim Hubbard wrote: I think that now is a really good time for Mandrake to reconsider their snip will happen I think in about a

Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-06 Thread Vincent Danen
On Thu Mar 06, 2003 at 10:40:42PM +1300, Michael Adams wrote: There was talk about updates being available for this product for three years. But at present i only see a one year support cycle. Support as in phone support... this does not refer to updates support. The EOL for each product is

Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-06 Thread Vincent Danen
On Thu Mar 06, 2003 at 10:57:45PM +1300, Michael Adams wrote: Whups, i should finish reading the posts before replying. Sorry Vincent. Apparently I suffer from the same symptoms. =) See my reply to your reply. On Thu, 06 Mar 2003 08:26, Vincent Danen wrote: On Tue Mar 04, 2003 at

Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-06 Thread Ric Tibbetts
Vincent Danen wrote: On Wed Mar 05, 2003 at 12:29:42PM -0800, James Sparenberg wrote: I think part of Redhats motivation was the far too numerious requests for requests like: When will redhat make rpms for kde3.1 for Redhat 7.3? And such. Truth is, they won't. But people don't seem to get

Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-06 Thread Bill Mullen
On Wed, 2003-03-05 at 14:26, Vincent Danen wrote: Corporate Server 2.1 was just announced, and it has a 3 year life policy. It's also cheaper than RHAS I believe. There is your choice. Supporting 9.1 for 3 years isn't an option. Mandrake Linux 9.1 is a desktop OS and while it works quite

Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-06 Thread Vincent Danen
On Thu Mar 06, 2003 at 09:39:07PM -0500, Bill Mullen wrote: Corporate Server 2.1 was just announced, and it has a 3 year life policy. It's also cheaper than RHAS I believe. There is your choice. Supporting 9.1 for 3 years isn't an option. Mandrake Linux 9.1 is a desktop OS and while it

Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-05 Thread Anne Wilson
On Wednesday 05 Mar 2003 7:24 am, Bill Mullen wrote: On Tue, 2003-03-04 at 22:52, Jim Hubbard wrote: I think that now is a really good time for Mandrake to reconsider their end of life policy. Here's how I see it: Redhat has effectively shut out the very folks who made their distro popular

Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-05 Thread Norman
Jim Hubbard wrote: I think that now is a really good time for Mandrake to reconsider their end of life policy. Here's how I see it: Redhat has effectively shut out the very folks who made their distro popular by changing their update system to a paid service and by saying that they'll only

Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-05 Thread Tom Brinkman
On Wednesday March 5 2003 01:00 am, James Sparenberg wrote: On Tue, 2003-03-04 at 19:52, Jim Hubbard wrote: Oh and one more thing. For God's sake please don't release iso's this time until AFTER the retail product is on shelves. No one point you made is more loudly echo'd by me than the

Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-05 Thread Keith Powell
I agree that the boxed sets should be made available before the download version. Possibly four weeks before would be a good timescale. However, I can see problems with making a version available for club members to download at the same time as the boxed versions are available. This assumes

RE: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-05 Thread Jim Hubbard
-Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Behalf Of Norman Sent: Wednesday, March 05, 2003 6:41 AM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity WHen I first heard Mandrake had problems I upped my club membership to silver

Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-05 Thread Greg Meyer
On Wednesday 05 March 2003 10:55 am, Keith Powell wrote: This makes it a very difficult decision for people who either have no credit card, or who, like me will not send my credit card details either over the internet or by the equally open FAX. They will not even accept credit card details

Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-05 Thread Jack Coates
On Wed, 2003-03-05 at 01:27, Anne Wilson wrote: ... As for the idea of making early downloads available to club members, it would only work if club members don't pass on copies until the boxed sets are available. It could work, though, if club members use that time to get to know the

Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-05 Thread J. Grant
Hi Keith, Using HTTPS is much more secure than sending via post. I am also in the UK, I have never been the victim of online fraud. However before the net revolution some one did charge my CC and it was refunded. All online CC have a garentee against fraud just like anything else. MDK could

RE: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-05 Thread Jim Hubbard
www.rock.lug.net -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Behalf Of J. Grant Sent: Wednesday, March 05, 2003 12:14 PM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity Hi Keith

Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-05 Thread Greg Meyer
On Wednesday 05 March 2003 12:14 pm, J. Grant wrote: Hi Keith, Using HTTPS is much more secure than sending via post. I am also in the UK, I have never been the victim of online fraud. However before the net revolution some one did charge my CC and it was refunded. All online CC have a

Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-05 Thread synrat
I'm pretty sure there was a good reason for redhat to make life shorter for their releases. After all it is the only commercially successful distro. They wouldn't shoot themselves in the foot or in the head like that I'm positive they know what they're doing. No serious admin. would install

Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-05 Thread James Sparenberg
On Wed, 2003-03-05 at 08:22, Jack Coates wrote: On Wed, 2003-03-05 at 01:27, Anne Wilson wrote: ... As for the idea of making early downloads available to club members, it would only work if club members don't pass on copies until the boxed sets are available. It could work, though, if

Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-05 Thread Ric Tibbetts
I think part of Redhats motivation was the far too numerious requests for requests like: When will redhat make rpms for kde3.1 for Redhat 7.3? And such. Truth is, they won't. But people don't seem to get the picture. So they had to put an eol on there. I know, there are plentyof other reasons,

Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-05 Thread James Sparenberg
On Wed, 2003-03-05 at 07:55, Keith Powell wrote: I agree that the boxed sets should be made available before the download version. Possibly four weeks before would be a good timescale. However, I can see problems with making a version available for club members to download at the same time

Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-05 Thread Anne Wilson
On Wednesday 05 Mar 2003 6:52 pm, James Sparenberg wrote: On Wed, 2003-03-05 at 07:55, Keith Powell wrote: A small Canadian firm from whom I buy things, will accept payment by any of the above methods, and also by a cheque made out in GB Pounds for the current rate of exchange between

Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-05 Thread Vincent Danen
On Tue Mar 04, 2003 at 10:52:18PM -0500, Jim Hubbard wrote: I think that now is a really good time for Mandrake to reconsider their end of life policy. Here's how I see it: Redhat has effectively shut out the very folks who made their distro popular by changing their update system to a paid

Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-05 Thread Vincent Danen
On Wed Mar 05, 2003 at 02:24:09AM -0500, Bill Mullen wrote: [...] Another possible benefit of Jim's proposal is the shift it could bring in the (wholly inaccurate, but unfortunately all too common) perception of Mandrake as a limited distro that is exclusively aimed at the desktop user and

Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-05 Thread Vincent Danen
On Wed Mar 05, 2003 at 10:49:02AM -0800, Ric Tibbetts wrote: I think part of Redhats motivation was the far too numerious requests for requests like: When will redhat make rpms for kde3.1 for Redhat 7.3? And such. Truth is, they won't. But people don't seem to get the picture. So they

Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-05 Thread Keith Powell
On Wednesday 05 March 2003 5:35 pm, Jim Hubbard wrote: This thread is beginning to stray from the original point I was trying to make, which is that Mandrake has an opportunity to pick up where Redhat has left off. There are many folks out there that are looking for the same benefits that

Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-05 Thread James Sparenberg
On Wed, 2003-03-05 at 11:31, Vincent Danen wrote: On Wed Mar 05, 2003 at 10:49:02AM -0800, Ric Tibbetts wrote: I think part of Redhats motivation was the far too numerious requests for requests like: When will redhat make rpms for kde3.1 for Redhat 7.3? And such. Truth is, they

Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-05 Thread Todd Lyons
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Jim Hubbard wrote on Wed, Mar 05, 2003 at 11:08:02AM -0500 : open-source users the wrong way, including me. Mandrake has exactly the right idea with MandrakeClub, but unfortunately, the current EOL policy (Mandrake's and Redhat's) is just a

RE: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-05 Thread Franki
PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Behalf Of Vincent Danen Sent: Thursday, 6 March 2003 3:34 AM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity On Wed Mar 05, 2003 at 02:24:09AM -0500, Bill Mullen wrote: [...] Another possible benefit of Jim's proposal is the shift

Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-05 Thread Vincent Danen
On Wed Mar 05, 2003 at 12:37:32PM -0800, Todd Lyons wrote: open-source users the wrong way, including me. Mandrake has exactly the right idea with MandrakeClub, but unfortunately, the current EOL policy (Mandrake's and Redhat's) is just a dealbreaker when it comes to a server OS. Just

Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-05 Thread Vincent Danen
On Wed Mar 05, 2003 at 12:29:42PM -0800, James Sparenberg wrote: I think part of Redhats motivation was the far too numerious requests for requests like: When will redhat make rpms for kde3.1 for Redhat 7.3? And such. Truth is, they won't. But people don't seem to get the

Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-05 Thread Todd Lyons
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 James Sparenberg wrote on Wed, Mar 05, 2003 at 12:29:42PM -0800 : And moreif you have ever tried to compile a kernel on 8.0 grin I've seen people complain about this. I think I'm going to find an 8.0 machine and see what the big hubbub is

Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-05 Thread Vincent Danen
On Thu Mar 06, 2003 at 04:39:13AM +0800, Franki wrote: my concern with all of this.. is that M$ is telling people that the lower cost of linux (ie they mean free) is not the full picture, and the extra training etc and so on should be taken into account when working out TCO... with

RE: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-05 Thread Franki
... rgds Franki -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Behalf Of Vincent Danen Sent: Thursday, 6 March 2003 4:59 AM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity On Thu Mar 06, 2003 at 04:39:13AM +0800, Franki wrote: my concern

RE: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-05 Thread Jim Hubbard
3:49 PM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity On Wed Mar 05, 2003 at 12:37:32PM -0800, Todd Lyons wrote: open-source users the wrong way, including me. Mandrake has exactly the right idea with MandrakeClub, but unfortunately, the current EOL

automatic upgrades via install + drakautoinst WAS: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-05 Thread Mark Stewart
This is sort of tangential to the EOL discussion but... Is it possible to use drakautoinst to automate an effectively upgrade a machine from one release to another? Rather than try to use the upgrade option which so rarely succeeds it seems like it wouldn't necessarily be hard to automate the

RE: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-05 Thread Bill Mullen
On Wed, 2003-03-05 at 12:35, Jim Hubbard wrote: This thread is beginning to stray from the original point I was trying to make, which is that Mandrake has an opportunity to pick up where Redhat has left off. There are many folks out there that are looking for the same benefits that running

Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-05 Thread Vincent Danen
On Thu Mar 06, 2003 at 06:11:43AM +0800, Franki wrote: noone is suggesting that it all be given away for free. Microsoft spend big dollars before each release working out exactly what $$$ amount would net them the most sales/most income..(not alway the same thing)... It just seems

RE: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-05 Thread Franki
- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Behalf Of Vincent Danen Sent: Thursday, 6 March 2003 7:07 AM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity On Thu Mar 06, 2003 at 06:11:43AM +0800, Franki wrote: noone is suggesting that it all be given away for free

Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-05 Thread Vincent Danen
On Wed Mar 05, 2003 at 05:12:58PM -0500, Jim Hubbard wrote: (You need to fix your reply-to) You know, I understand that developing software is hard. I know I can't do it. And not to make light of developer's efforts (many of them volunteers!), but to someone who's choosing a server OS, it

Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-05 Thread Vincent Danen
On Thu Mar 06, 2003 at 07:33:34AM +0800, Franki wrote: Thanks.. I'll do that (place my wish) I have never used any linux support other then updates and mailing lists... and I get bye... rtfm and stfw has worked pretty well for the most part.. so yes.. I'll email that wish through...

Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-05 Thread James Sparenberg
On Wed, 2003-03-05 at 12:54, Todd Lyons wrote: -BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 James Sparenberg wrote on Wed, Mar 05, 2003 at 12:29:42PM -0800 : And moreif you have ever tried to compile a kernel on 8.0 grin I've seen people complain about this. I think I'm going to

[expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-04 Thread Jim Hubbard
I think that now is a really good time for Mandrake to reconsider their end of life policy. Here's how I see it: Redhat has effectively shut out the very folks who made their distro popular by changing their update system to a paid service and by saying that they'll only support a release for 1

Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-04 Thread James Sparenberg
On Tue, 2003-03-04 at 19:52, Jim Hubbard wrote: I think that now is a really good time for Mandrake to reconsider their end of life policy. Here's how I see it: Redhat has effectively shut out the very folks who made their distro popular by changing their update system to a paid service and

Re: [expert] Mandrake's Golden Opportunity

2003-03-04 Thread Bill Mullen
On Tue, 2003-03-04 at 22:52, Jim Hubbard wrote: I think that now is a really good time for Mandrake to reconsider their end of life policy. Here's how I see it: Redhat has effectively shut out the very folks who made their distro popular by changing their update system to a paid service and