Re: [Finale] Spreadbury diary

2014-02-21 Thread Matthew Naughtin
As a professional orchestral music librarian (also a composer and copyist), I'm usually the first one to see poorly engraved and laid-out orchestra materials sent from publishers and composers. As recent posts lament, there are too many music copyists (including self-published composers) who

[Finale] Spreadbury diary

2014-02-20 Thread Craig Parmerlee
And here is Daniel Spreadbury's latest diary entry: http://blog.steinberg.net/2014/02/development-diary-part-the-fifth/ I really appreciate the things he is discussing. I play in a symphony orchestra that does 5 subscription concerts a year. In 2 of the last 4 concerts we were given music

Re: [Finale] Spreadbury diary

2014-02-20 Thread Eric Dannewitz
They also sell cars to anybody.and look at the drivers out there. They also sell violins to anybody. A tool is a tool. If a publishing house lets complete crap out, you should tell them that by returning that crap. If a composer comes in with a piece, and its totally NOT readable, then you

Re: [Finale] Spreadbury diary

2014-02-20 Thread timothy . price
Craig, you make an excellent point. But as a composer, it is nearly impossible to be confident that our manuscripts are what musicians are comfortable with. There is lacking, imo, the interface between the good composer, and the musicians, when it comes to the manuscript. It would be greatly

Re: [Finale] Spreadbury diary

2014-02-20 Thread David H. Bailey
On 2/20/2014 3:21 PM, timothy.price wrote: Craig, you make an excellent point. But as a composer, it is nearly impossible to be confident that our manuscripts are what musicians are comfortable with. There is lacking, imo, the interface between the good composer, and the musicians, when it

Re: [Finale] Spreadbury diary

2014-02-20 Thread Craig Parmerlee
In one of my examples, the composition was a major part of that concert and had been announced. It came from a house in Germany and there was no option not to program the piece. So I rewrote all the brass parts between the first and second rehearsals. Our orchestra manager even offered to

Re: [Finale] Spreadbury diary

2014-02-20 Thread Craig Parmerlee
Amen, brother. My orchestra is paying almost twice per rental what we paid just 5-6 years ago. That is WAY above the rate of inflation. It is affecting what we can program. When you pay $800 to rent a big work, it does seem reasonable to expect that the parts are error free. Most of these

Re: [Finale] Spreadbury diary

2014-02-20 Thread timothy . price
I didn't imagine the extent of the problem. Like much of our society today, we are charged money for services of poor value. I don't believe that my work would get this sort of criticism. Craig wrote: You would think that if a publisher is renting a piece for $10,000 revenue a year (or

Re: [Finale] Spreadbury diary

2014-02-20 Thread David H. Bailey
On 2/20/2014 6:18 PM, timothy.price wrote: I didn't imagine the extent of the problem. Like much of our society today, we are charged money for services of poor value. I don't believe that my work would get this sort of criticism. Craig wrote: You would think that if a publisher is

Re: [Finale] Spreadbury diary

2014-02-20 Thread Craig Parmerlee
And you would probably never be able to rent anything from that publisher again, or else they would establish a special price just for you. For orchestras, there are only a few big houses that hold the rights to most of the non-public-domain literature. And any given work may be available